Voyage of the Damned: Carnival Liberty Cruise Review by WorkingOnTheSecond 100

Carnival Liberty 3
WorkingOnTheSecond 100
Member Since 2010
7 Forum Posts

Overall Member Rating

Voyage of the Damned

Sail Date: October 2012
Destination: Western Caribbean
Embarkation: Miami
This was my wife's and my first cruise (and last!) on Carnival. We had just gotten off RCCL's Vision of the Seas the day before, having crossed the Atlantic on RCCL after our cruise on Celebrity's Constellation around France, Spain and Portugal.

Here's my brief synopsis on Carnival:

Pricing: An attractive price lured us in to try Carnival

Check In: Pleasantly quick, considering we had no "status" on Carnival.

Cabin: Fairly standard size, amenities, and furnishings. Would have been fine, except it was WAY too warm for us. We contacted maintenance that first day, and when a technician arrived at our cabin, we were told that the 74.5 degree temp in our room was "within Carnival's pre-determined acceptable range of 72-74 degrees". In other words, Carnival tells you what temperature THEY think your room should be, and you are stuck with that!

Food: Surprisingly good -- better than RCCL. There were some quirks, however. The taco bar (the More tastiest food option for off-hours dining) had limited hours, which [in]conveniently was always closed when coming off a Carnival shore excursion. The Pool Bar made popcorn, but on a "toy" popcorn machine which pumped out about a half-gallon every 15 minutes -- with a queue of 20-30 people waiting, it was apparent you would wait more than an hour for a small portion.

Crew: Good to very good. The waitstaff in the dining room (from hostess to assistant waiters) all were familiar with food allergies, and made ordering around the menu a reasonable exercise. Crew was generally courteous and efficient. It was our first cruise where we never saw the Captain walking around the ship.

Ports of Call: Here was the supreme disappointment. See below.

Shore Excursions: Pretty standard, but since all cruise lines subcontract out to local companies, no surprise there.

Fellow Passengers: The showstopper. In all our cruises, we'd never experienced loud partying in the corridors -- at all hours! Putting out a "Do Not Disturb" sign was as effective as the proverbial "Kick Me" sign on your back. People were rude in the dining rooms, rude in the hallways, rude in the bars (as well as being loud and very drunk), and people seemingly smoked everywhere.

In summary, the passengers made the cruise unpleasant. I guess we're just not Carnival people . . . Less

Published 10/22/12

Cabin review: 6A Ocean View

Read All Ocean View (6A) Reviews >>

Port and Shore Excursions

Belize City was a real port of call, but hot, steamy, and no real interest within the seedy downtown.

Carnival berths at Carnival's own "Fake Town, Mexico", called Puerta Maya. It's a not-inexpensive cab ride to get into the "real" Cozumel. Why is Fake Town not real? It's merely a village of the same shops as on the ship, with more choices and variety. The proof is no sale of Cuban products, including rum and cigars. If you were really in Mexico, every store would be selling them . . .
Read 5466 Cozumel Reviews

Grand Cayman was real, and a delight. We had lunch downtown, and it was our best meal of the cruise.

Carnival berths at Mahogany Bay, or "Fake Town, Honduras" -- owned by Carnival. Same shops and limited shopping as Cozumel. No Cuban products for sale. It would have cost $10-20 to get from Fake Town to any real town on the island (French Harbor or the West End).
Read 2443 Roatan Reviews

Compare Prices on Carnival Liberty Western Caribbean Cruises

Read more Carnival Liberty cruise reviews >>
Read Cruise Critic’s Carnival Liberty Review >>

Compare Prices on Carnival Liberty Western Caribbean Cruises

WorkingOnTheSecond 100
Member Since 2010
7 Forum Posts
Enrichment Activities
Family & Children
Fitness & Recreation
Onboard Experience
Public Rooms
Shore Excursions
Value for Money
Share feedback
Thank you!  Cruise Critic values your feedback.
How can we improve this page?
Skip X

See Carnival Liberty deals up to 82% off:

September Deals
Carnival Liberty 76% Loved It

4 Day Bahamas Itinerary
See all Carnival Liberty Deals >>