Stay or leave Carnival: Carnival Glory Cruise Review by nancylc

Carnival Glory 3
Member Since 2012

Overall Member Rating

Stay or leave Carnival

Sail Date: October 2012
Destination: Canada & New England
Embarkation: New York (Manhattan)
We are regular cruisers and this was our ninth cruise, the fifth with Carnival. We had sailed on the Carnival Glory once before out of Miami. We had never done the New England Cruise before and decided to save a little money and book with Carnival again.

There are pro's and con's with this cruise. Let's start with the pro's. The service is impeccable. The staff gives all they have to make sure you are enjoying your cruise. The food is in the dining room was very good and the food in the Emerald steakhouse was fabulous! We have eaten at five star restaurants and never ate at the Emerald Steakhouse just because we thought being on a ship it wasn't worth it, but IT IS! We had a wonderful cabin steward that took care of our cabin and great waiters! The debarkation only took us only 20 minutes. We always do self assist so it is usually quick.

The con's. The food in the Red Sail restaurant is pitiful. We ended up throwing our food away and noticed many others did as well. More Embarkation was a nightmare. It took over 3 hours after we arrived in the terminal (around 11:30 am) to actually get ton the ship. We were told their computers were having problems which were creating delays.

We could deal with these things however the next two items have pretty much changed our minds about Carnival and we will not be sailing with them again until we have heard things have changed. First thing, Carnival ships have the same activities planned that they had planned years ago. There are no new activities and no variances in any of their ships. In other words it is the same old schedule every time you cruise with them on every, gender show down games, art auction, Trivia, Hairy chest contest, ice sculpting, mixology, etc. If you are a first time cruiser with Carnival you will enjoy it however if you have sailed with them before you will be BORED! Second thing, the shows have gotten out of control with costumes and R rated scenes. We do not take our kids on cruises any more since they have moved out a few years ago, however my husband and I were embarrased and could not believe the costumes on the dancers are showing less and less. From the rear view, the dancers are literally nude. I could see parents with children in the shows that were appalled. There was a show 'living in America' and on one of the country songs there is a scene that is literally a sex scene between a man and woman on a horse. These are NOT family friendly shows and if you don't have kids (like us) they are even decent.

The ports we're wonderful and we wrote reviews on our excursions. From now on, we will be sailing again with Princess and Royal Caribbean. Less

Published 10/15/12

Cabin review: 6A Ocean View

Read All Ocean View (6A) Reviews >>

Port and Shore Excursions

We did the Hop on Hop off Trolley Tour. We had purchased our tickets online instead of through the ship because they are much cheaper online. We also did the 2 1/2 mile freedom walk. Tons of history! We really enjoyed this place. We ate at Union Oyster House for lunch. It is the oldest restaurant in the US and the ambience and food was incredible! Make sure you have the Boston Cream Pie!!

Read 489 Boston Reviews

Peggy's Cove

Best tour of the cruise! Absolutely a must! The drive there and back is beautiful and Peggys Cove is enchanting. The little shops, rocky cliffs, lighthouse were all so enjoyable. The guides were wonderful. We really enjoyed this tour!


Before we did the Kennenbunkport tour we got off the ship and bought two tickets for the city bus tour (there is a stand on the dock where you can purchase each ticket for $5.00 each.) We took the bus around to get aquainted, shopped in some of the cute little shops close by and had lunch at Allsions. Lunch was very dissapointing. We had the lobster roll and lobster bisque and there was about a teapsoon of lobster in the roll. Allisons was on the main strip of restaurants, maybe we just chose the wrong one. Loved Loved Loved the Kennebunkport Tour! Kennebunkport is adorable and we went during the fall foliage season so it had beautiful colors! Quaint little shop and wonderful homemade blueberry pie ala mode at all the restaurants! The guides were very knowledgeable and friendly.

City Tour

We did the 10 Best of Saint John. This was a good tour. The best was going to St. Martins and seeing the sea caves. You also see a couple of covered bridges and some quaint little shops in a shiping cove. Old City Market was enjoyable but the rest we could have skipped.

Compare Prices on Carnival Glory Canada & New England Cruises

Read more Carnival Glory cruise reviews >>
Read Cruise Critic’s Carnival Glory Review >>

Compare Prices on Carnival Glory Canada & New England Cruises

Member Since 2012
Enrichment Activities
Family & Children
Fitness & Recreation
Onboard Experience
Public Rooms
Shore Excursions
Value for Money
Share feedback
Thank you!  Cruise Critic values your feedback.
How can we improve this page?
Skip X

See Carnival Glory deals up to 82% off:

September Deals
Carnival Glory 74% Loved It

7 Day Exotic Western Caribbean
See all Carnival Glory Deals >>