Our overall impression of this cruise was very positive, and we would align ourselves more with skintman's assessment than with more negative reviews.
The key requirements were definitely in place: a safe and well managed cruise on an excellent, well maintained and very clean ship, with friendly and courteous staff. Our balcony cabin was very pleasant: well equipped, spacious enough for us, comfortable bed.
There were a lot of different nationalities represented in terms both of passengers and staff. Some passengers were in large family and friend groups, and at times the children were a bit noisy. It's probably inevitable in the main school holiday period, and with apparently free places for children.