Liberty ups and downs: Carnival Liberty Cruise Review by TJ&TJ

Carnival Liberty 4

Overall Member Rating

Liberty ups and downs

Sail Date: April 2012
Destination: Eastern Caribbean
Embarkation: Miami
My wife and I were on the Carnival Liberty cruise out of Miami on April 28th. We had a few bad experiences, one totally unacceptable experience, but enough positives to make us look forward to our next Carnival cruise.

The trip started off with a flight from Baltimore to Ft. Lauderdale. On the way, I dozed off while holding a hot cup of coffee. The second degree burn on my tummy woke me up much better than drinking the cup of coffee would have. This was bad thing #1 -- obviously this wasn't Carnivals fault, but it set the stage for the next bad thing.

The transfer from the Ft. Lauderdale airport to the port of Miami went without a hitch. We arrived in the port at about 10:30 and as we pulled in we noticed the line for embarkment went out the door and down the block with nearly 1000 people waiting in it (I didn't count, but it was a whole lot of people). It took us over 3 hours to actually get on the ship. Carnival blamed it on customs, but we found out later More that the liberty was late returning to port, the customs agents had moved on to check in another cruise ship, and the people on the previous cruise could not debark until the customs people could clear the boat. With a burnt belly, my tolerance at having to wait in line and in a big room with no air-conditioning, before finally getting on the boat, was really low. This was bad thing #2 (and I noted something similar happened to an earlier cruise in a previous review).

Because we had to wait so long to get on the ship, our cabin was ready for us. Since all we do is sleep, change clothes, and shower in the cabin, we always take an inside, mid-ship, cabin, and this time was no exception. This is where our first good thing happened -- wet met our cabin steward (Wayan). He greeted us by name, gave us a tour of the cabin (it didn't take too long). Throughout the cruise, he made sure that everything we needed (as far as the room went) was perfect. We had room service delivered one afternoon (BLT with extra chips) and the next time we saw him, he asked if the room service was satisfactory, even asking specifically about the sandwich.

After dropping our stuff off in the cabin, we went up to the lido deck to grab something to eat (the last time we ate was in Baltimore) where we discovered good thing number 2... Guy's Burgers. WOW!!! Perfectly done, a condiment bar with every possible topping for a burger. My only complaint is that it was open only for a couple of hours every afternoon -- A late night burger would have been a nice treat. (Carnival -- if you're reading this - hint hint).

Now we get to the completely unacceptable experience. At dinner that evening we met our server -- Robert -- He was rude, ignored us, and food took forever to get to us. The first evening we were at our table precisely at 6:00, we were seated, and 15 minutes later our order was taken. At 6:45 we got our appetizers, and at 7:30 we got our dinner. Dessert came at 8:00 and we had to leave the table before the 8:15 seating. We skipped dinner the next evening, but tried one more time (everyone deserves a bad day). If possible, this dinner was much worse. I don't expect 5-star service, but I expect at least the same level of service I would expect at any Denny's. We didn't eat in the dining room for the rest of the cruise and we visited the pursers desk and adjusted our tips accordingly.

The rest of the cruise went pretty well. The high point for us was visiting the Bacardi factory in San Juan. Our guide (Marko) was a gem. His love for Puerto Rico, knowledge of its history and culture, and sense of humor made the entire tour one worth repeating -- we came away with an appreciation for Puerto Rico and its people.
Debarkation was quick and easy. Our Transfer bus broke down on the way back to the airport, but another bus was sent to pick us up with only a minimal delay.

We've already booked our next Carnival Cruise on the new Carnival ship -- the Breeze, leaving out of Miami on December 8th. Hope to see some of you there. Less

Published 05/12/12
Helpful? Thank TJ&TJ

Cabin review: 4C Interior

We found that a Mid-Ship inside cabin with nothing but cabins above or below are quiet, easy to get to, and just perfect for our needs. We were on the empress deck (deck 7).

Read All Interior (4C) Reviews >>

Port and Shore Excursions

A nice little place - good shopping right off the boat. Margaritaville is not to be missed - good food and great drinks. Good swimming/snorkling very close to the boat. One question remains - if this was Grand Turk, what does regular Turk look like.
Read 1691 Grand Turk Reviews

We didn't have much of a chance to explore as the weather gods were not nice to us. Raining Cats and Dogs the whole day. We made it onto the island for less than an hour before we decided it was a wash out -

We did the Bacardi tour. Since my wife doesn't drink, and since we both had 2 drink tickets, I had 4 stiff drinks before 11:00 AM. My wife tells me I enjoyed the rest of the day.
Read 2945 San Juan Reviews

This was a shopping stop for us. There were a lot of people trying to get us to visit "off the strip" shops. Some of them were funny, some were nice, some were just creepy. The one shop we visited had jewelry. On close inspection, the metal was scratched and quite dirty. They did give us diet cokes, though...
Read 3993 St. Thomas Reviews

Compare Prices on Carnival Liberty Eastern Caribbean Cruises

Read more Carnival Liberty cruise reviews >>
Read Cruise Critic’s Carnival Liberty Review >>

Compare Prices on Carnival Liberty Eastern Caribbean Cruises

Enrichment Activities
Family & Children
Fitness & Recreation
Onboard Experience
Public Rooms
Shore Excursions
Value for Money
Share feedback
Thank you!  Cruise Critic values your feedback.
How can we improve this page?
Skip X

See Carnival Liberty deals up to 82% off:

September Deals
Carnival Liberty 76% Loved It

4 Day Bahamas Itinerary
See all Carnival Liberty Deals >>