1. Home
  2. Find a Cruise
  3. Disney Magic
  4. 5 Night Transatlantic Cruise from New York (Manhattan)

5 Night Transatlantic Cruise from New York

5 Night Transatlantic Cruise from New York (Manhattan)

Save
Disney Magic
Loading ...

Itinerary


Disney Magic

Cruise Critic Editor Rating:
4.5
460 reviews
Why Choose Disney Magic?

Pros

"Tangled"-themed dining, show and programming; Marvel Day at Sea sailings

Cons

Small pool for families; crowded elevators for strollers and mobility impaired

Bottom Line

Regularly updated with first-class entertainment, dining and more


Cruise Reviews

Sail Date: September 2018
I think this must be my second review even though we are world cruisers, for years, and have sailed many different cruise lines. We have a lot of experience with all aspects of a cruise. I have cruised Disney once before to the Bahamas. ... Read More
I think this must be my second review even though we are world cruisers, for years, and have sailed many different cruise lines. We have a lot of experience with all aspects of a cruise. I have cruised Disney once before to the Bahamas. My perspective is of an adult, and safety for the children. Arriving a day before the cruise at Quebec City, we found it quaint. (We had been there once before on an excursion with another cruise line). Our embarkation seemed to have gone smoothly, until i found that all my cruising info papers, med sheets, all the papers i bring with me were missing, and were lost somewhere between the port and the stateroom. I called the front desk, they didnt have them. Okay we can deal with that, there are always the originals to find on the computer. Although i didnt like my information out in public. The problem was they had no service to speak of and my husband after using his free 100 minutes, paid for 200 mins(I dont know why they dont go by Megabytes), and by the time he would get on, it had "used" up all the time he had. You couldnt sign off, and for some reason their antiquated system kept you on, if you didnt "officially" sign off. Luckily we were in a concierge room, (which we paid a lot more for) and our concierge had printed out our entire itinerary, and was excellent. All three concierge "cast members" seemed seasoned, and Disney schooled. We especially liked Andy. A major problem occured when we tried to sleep the first night. Our "special" concierge room was under the Cabana's outside buffet. It was oddly configured, possibly 2 staterooms put together to make a large suite with 2 full bathrooms, and a tiny closet. There was lots of draw space. BIG PROBLEM....I didnt sleep for the 1st night because there seemed to be no sound insulation above the master bedroom, and the outside buffet. Until late, the first night all we heard were shoes thumping and chairs screeching. My husband and I missed the first excursion, the following day....we were exhausted. By the way the room number was 8602. DO NOT CHOOSE THIS ROOM, if you want to sleep. This is the basis of any trip, not feeling like your dragging and are sleep deprived. After the first night i called the concierge to ask them what they could do. They said they couldnt control the people eating in the cabana. I had gone up to the cabana and evaluated the situation and found that if the could rope of or take away 2 tables right above us, that may help the situation. I gave each person working there including the "officer" $20.00 each and ask them to please remove or rope off the tables. They said they couldnt promise to do this. Second night, same thing. I called the concierge, who happily came to my door(2 females) and in a disney manor jumping and smiling told me how great i looked. After that went on for a while i asked them to come upstairs to see what i was talking about. The Cabana was roped off for that one night. After that i gave up. it was hit or miss whether i slept or not. On to excursions. They were not great, and somewhat boring. I spent most of this review on the stateroom, so i am not going to recap them, except to say, there was one dangerous part of an excursion where we asked if we wanted to walk over a dilapidated walking bridge. I thought disney wouldnt allow this if it was dangerous, so we embarked. The bridge was held together at certain parts with what seemed to be rotten fiber board. We had to tell children and others to watch and we turned around and got off the bridge. This was in Baie-Comeau. The only other bad experience with excursions, was when we returned to the ship and were delightfully welcomed with hot chocolate. It was a chilly day. The drink was so hot the first sip i took, i immediately had to spit out because it was scalding the inside of my mouth, and i wasnt about to swallow it. I angrily told the servers, who just looked at me, that they need to test the temperature on this, before serving it. The burn stayed with me until after NY, but under the circumstances of all else, it wasnt something continuously happening so I protested no further to the servers, who i am not sure understood English anyway. I should note also that while we on an excursion, our stateroom door was left propped open all day, and the Executive Hoosekeeper, mortified by this was so anxious to apologize(which i appreciated greatly). This only happened once. Good stuff: The entertainment during dinner, where your waiting service followed you to each venue, was excellent! Best part of the cruise. Manuel, was excellent, and gave service with a smile. Cant say enough about the wait service. He even did magic Palo, their upscale italian restaurant, had wonderful food, and our waiter, was a consummate disney actor who made the experience almost real. His name was Roberto, excellent. We had children of 4 different ages. I think they all enjoyed their clubs and especially their special dress ups, princess gathering, Royal Teas.....we scheduled them for every ago approrriate activity you could do on the ship. This is why we went on the cruise, for the children. So this is the thing....We do family cruises every few years, with up to 47 people. I am torn because i have reserved 12 rooms for a family cruise next December, to the Bahamas, and this cruise is in no way an adult cruise. It 99.9% for children, or adults who have younger children, or adults who would prefer to be a child. I am hoping i made the right decision. I am hoping the more than one bad experience i had on this cruise will not happen again. The last Bahama cruise i went on with Disney seemed awesome compared to what happened on this one Read Less
Sail Date: September 2018
The Disney Wonder is indeed wonderful except in one area: Dining. Both the food quality and the dining options were substandard. When I worked at Disneyland for 3 years we were told that high menu prices are justified ONLY IF the food ... Read More
The Disney Wonder is indeed wonderful except in one area: Dining. Both the food quality and the dining options were substandard. When I worked at Disneyland for 3 years we were told that high menu prices are justified ONLY IF the food is first rate. On the Disney Cruise we were served steaks that were tough, shrimp that had a definite bad taste from being too old, dry chicken, and cheaper cuts of meat that we had to cut the gristle and fat away. The food is very fancy but not very good. Cruise lines like Carnival and Royal Caribbean cost less than half the Disney cruise and have better quality food and dining options. As to the dining options, other cruise lines offer a buffet with a wide selection as an alternative to the sit-down dinner. On the Disney Wonder the buffet, “Cabanas”, offered only menu service. Room service menu was very limited and while you can order a full breakfast on other cruise lines, Disney Wonder offers you only a Continental Breakfast similar to what you would find in the lobby of Motel 6. Other than the expensive and hard-to-reserve “Palo” the dining choices become extremely limited. If you want something other than the sit-down dinner your best bet is the low quality fast food served outside by the pool. A warmed over slice from Pinocchio’s Pizza can be had most of the day. There are other places with snacks but very limited times. The Crown and Fin Pub has hot dogs with stale buns for 1 hour (10:30 to 11:30). Tried ordering a pretzel from the Pub and was told they had to be ordered in advance. Please don’t get me wrong: Everything else was outstanding. Great service and caring, helpful employees, wonderful shows, amazing program for our kids, immaculate ship, easy embarkation, and everything else you would expect from a first-class expensive Disney cruise. Walt Disney once sampled the food at the Employees Cafeteria at Disneyland and said, “I wouldn’t serve this to my dog!”. Very soon the food was upgraded to the same wonderful food served to the guests. I hope Walt’s successors will do the same for the food quality and availability on the Disney Cruise Ships. Read Less
1 Helpful Vote
Sail Date: September 2018
We were a party of 7 adults (from 20 to 76 years old) all on our first cruise. We departed from New-York and disembarked in Quebec City. Both embarkation and disembarkation went exceptionally well. We never felt like there was almost 2000 ... Read More
We were a party of 7 adults (from 20 to 76 years old) all on our first cruise. We departed from New-York and disembarked in Quebec City. Both embarkation and disembarkation went exceptionally well. We never felt like there was almost 2000 people getting on and off the ship. The Disney Magic is a wonderful ship. We enjoyed that it it not too big or too small. We had plenty of public rooms to hang around and every single decor detail was perfect. The ship is in really good shape for its age. Crew members are working day and night on repainting and cleaning, making the ship look as new. The most outstanding thing is the cleanliness. From the pools to the lobby to little corners of public spaces. Everything shines and crew members are cleaning 24/7. The furnitures all over the ship looked and felt high quality. We were 3 adults in a cabin and 4 in the other. We were anxious that the single beds would be uncomfortable for adults, but they happened to be very comfy (my 20 years old sister is very picky and said she slept very well in those beds). We all had great nights of sleep. The deck 2 is really quiet all day and night. The cabin is so big that we had enough room and private space for 4 adults ! There is more than enough storage space. The split bathroom (one with toilet and sink and the other with bathtub/shower and sink made getting dressed and everything really smooth with 4 adults in the same cabin. The thick curtain to split the cabin in two was also really useful. The food on the ship was overall very good and better than i expected (i read a lot of reviews before cruising). We tried the specialty restaurant Palo for dinner. The food was good but not exceptional. We wouldn't recommend it, since the food in the main dinning rooms was really good. The service was outstanding in all the complimentary venues. There was a lot of variety in the buffet menu and the offering was different every time we went. The food at Lumiere's for lunch was excellent and the service really smooth. The ambiance was perfect when we wanted to escape the noise of the buffet and have a 3 course meal for lunch. We knew that Disney Cruise Line was renowned for its onboard entertainment and we learned why. The quality of the shows is amazing. Even the older ones in our party, who don't know a lot about Disney Characters and Movies, had a wonderful time. It really was outstanding for a ship of that size. There was always something to do all day long. We never managed to do everything. One great thing was that the pools were heated, which was perfect for colder Fall weather. We enjoyed the quiet adults only pool. There wasn't as many kids as we expected on the ship and we don't see them a lot since they are spending most of their time in the kids clubs. We chose a Disney cruise for the outstanding guest service and our expectations were exceeded ! Every crew member was friendly and very professional. That service is worth the price ! The excursions were a little too expensive. We visited a Hydro-electric Dam in Baie-Comeau and we enjoyed our tour, but the price was a little bit too much. For the other ports, we walked around by ourselves since the ship was docked close to everything. Special mention to Saguenay, where the welcoming celebrations were amazing ! The fireworks in Québec were also incredible ! Reminded us of the ones in Disney World ! We already booked our next Disney cruise for next September ! Read Less
View All Disney Magic Reviews
Find Your Roll Call