• Write a Review
  • Boards
  • Log In

Carnival New York (Manhattan) Cruise Reviews

Carnival
Ship
Destination
New York (Manhattan)

Traveler rating

Excellent

586

Very Good

367

Average

274

Poor

131

Terrible

80

Cruise type

1,463 Carnival New York (Manhattan) Cruise Reviews


mcreached avatar

mcreached

2 Reviews Written

4 Helpful Votes

Very Crowded, at all times

|

I went with two members of my family on this cruise near the end of August 2019. I'm late writing this review, but after a few months of thinking about our vacation, one thing became glaringly obvious: this ship is ...
Read More

4 photos

Sail Date August 2019


thegreatlumpino avatar

thegreatlumpino

1 Review Written

3 Helpful Votes

Spend more money and go with another cruise line. You get what you pay for

Booked because it was cheap. The cruise was booked for 2 infants, 2 adults. Only one crib was placed in the room, and fit in the room. I was told that I should have known the dimensions of the room, and it became my ...
Read More

Sail Date August 2019


retired widow avatar

retired widow

1 Review Written

4 Helpful Votes

SUNRISE VACATION WAS A PUBLIC PROJECT VACATION IN THE ATLANTIC OCEAN

Because I had to cancel the Horizon ship cruise due to being hospitalized last year I booked Sunrise.Sunrise offered same itinerary on New York port embankment. In order not to lose my money I went back on this ...
Read More

Sail Date September 2019


Keith B. avatar

Keith B.

5 Reviews Written

18 Helpful Votes

Yup, another wonderful cruise

Introduction: This cruise was booked 16 months prior to sailing. While it is not our first cruise, it is the first with my daughter and her husband who had no previous cruise experience. I sprang the invitation ...
Read More

Sail Date September 2019


SapnaKaur avatar

SapnaKaur

2 Reviews Written

6 Helpful Votes

Ghetto Cruise - Super Old Ugly Ship

Cabin - Spa Balcony on the 11th Floor Cabin No. 1104. Embarkation & Disembark at 12th Avenue 55th Street in Manhattan, NY. The ugliest ghetto ship i've ever been on. This was a 4-day cruise to Bermuda and we ...
Read More

Sail Date September 2019


Zsmendoza avatar

Zsmendoza

1 Review Written

10 Helpful Votes

Awesome cruise

We chose this cruise as it suited our time frame and the price was extremely fair. I was however nervous a couple of days prior to departure after reading some terrible reviews. Embarking went fantastic very ...
Read More

Sail Date September 2019


CelticTee avatar

CelticTee

2 Reviews Written

8 Helpful Votes

Not sure what ship some of these reviewers were on...

I never write reviews but felt inclined to after seeing so many negative reviews. This is my 4th cruise. I just came back from the 8 day Eastern Caribbean cruise - a cruise which I was a little concerned about ...
Read More

Sail Date September 2019


Johnny cruise nut avatar

Johnny cruise nut

1 Review Written

4 Helpful Votes

People will always complain

I truly cannot believe some of the negative reviews. Maybe they had bad luck, or you cannot make them happy no matter what. If i see one more comment about long food lines. What the hell do you expect with 3000 ...
Read More

Sail Date August 2019


caddy_daddy avatar

caddy_daddy

2 Reviews Written

6 Helpful Votes

Hurricane Dorian Cruise - Still a great time

Chose this cruise because it left from NY. Short hour drive from our home state of RI. Prior to leaving for the trip I was concerned due to all the bad reviews. I knew going in what my expectations were and was ...
Read More

Sail Date August 2019


Armandito563 avatar

Armandito563

1 Review Written

3 Helpful Votes

Carnival Sunrise

Of variety, I like the crusero, but in this one I am disenchanted, because I saw things on board that I did not like, first long line to be able to eat, in the buffet, second cockroach we found inside the dishes and ...
Read More

Sail Date August 2019


WMQueenie avatar

WMQueenie

9 Reviews Written

42 Helpful Votes

Not sure we'd sail the Sunrise again

There were 5 of us on this cruise, all of us in our 60's, 2 first time cruisers and 3 experienced cruisers. My husband and I and been on 6 Carnival cruises - 4 Royal Caribbean and 5 Norwegian cruises. Traveling ...
Read More

Sail Date August 2019


Phil G358 avatar

Phil G358

1 Review Written

2 Helpful Votes

Overall a decent experience, great for kids!

Overall had a great time! Family of 4 (kids 5 and 9). 4 night cruise to Bermuda on August 15th. The crowd was very diverse, but very friendly. Met a lot of people from NY and CT, even a few from England. We are ...
Read More

Sail Date August 2019


Saltynutt1 avatar

Saltynutt1

1 Review Written

7 Helpful Votes

Waste of money!

$200 million dollar renovation? Let's start with my room. We had a grand sweet, room 7295. We had dirty water from someone else's room leaking into our bathroom. It was so bad that mold was growing. And not sure ...
Read More

Sail Date August 2019


JoeN964 avatar

JoeN964

1 Review Written

5 Helpful Votes

More of a retread than a refit.

Apparently the main objective of Carnivals transformation of the Triumph into the Sunrise was to increase their revenue and the customer be damned. While some welcome amenities were added, more of the focus of the ...
Read More

Sail Date June 2019


alamba121 avatar

alamba121

1 Review Written

4 Helpful Votes

Great Family Cruise

We live in NY and chose this cruise as a nice family get away since it left from NY and we would not have to fly to get on the ship. Embarkation was a breeze. We got to port and walked right on to the ship. We ...
Read More

Sail Date August 2019


mjd31 avatar

mjd31

2 Reviews Written

4 Helpful Votes

Great Room Steward (Room 7275) and Dining Crew, Table 617, Early seating!!

Cruise on Carnival Sunrise 8/7/2019 thru 8/15/2019 Booked a Suite on Deck 7, Family of 2 Adults and 2 Children. We had 11:30/ 12:00 am Boarding time. When we got to the cruise port it was easy to get into ...
Read More

Sail Date August 2019


Ryanchizmar18 avatar

Ryanchizmar18

2 Reviews Written

3 Helpful Votes

Perfect cruise for family of 6!!!

We chose this cruise as a first vacation for our blended family of 4 kids. With interior and balcony rooms on deck 6 aft we had plenty of space for her 2 girls and my 2 boys (ages 10, 10, 13, and 14.) Speaking of ...
Read More

Sail Date August 2019


5YearsCruzin avatar

5YearsCruzin

1 Review Written

6 Helpful Votes

Overcrowded Ship

We sailed on the Carnival Sunrise as part of a large 40+ group of friends, so we did not choose this particular ship or itinerary. We have sailed with Carnival before and are Gold level members. Embarkation: ...
Read More

Sail Date August 2019


peaceonearthxxoo avatar

peaceonearthxxoo

1 Review Written

5 Helpful Votes

Highly recommend other ships!!!

This was my platinum cruise and was very convenient choice for us but I absolutely do not want to ever go on this ship again and will def rethink ships remodeled! This ship was old and had a negative history. ( ...
Read More

Sail Date August 2019


Tails915 avatar

Tails915

1 Review Written

3 Helpful Votes

Had a great time but room was too warm!

So we chose this cruise because I liked the idea that it was refurbished and it looked beautiful with lots to do. We are 5 people in an oceanview room. First, embarkation was fantastic! We parked in the manhattan ...
Read More

Sail Date July 2019


kdominus avatar

kdominus

1 Review Written

6 Helpful Votes

First Cruise. Would Not Do Carnival Again.

If I could do two and a half stars, I would. We decided to do a cruise, which was not something we had ever done before. We decided on this ship because it was well priced, out of NYC (which is where we live), ...
Read More

Sail Date July 2019


Jeffrey sydnor avatar

Jeffrey sydnor

1 Review Written

3 Helpful Votes

Amazing

I choose Carnival because I have always had a great experience, I am a third time cruiser and I enjoy the activities that are set in place, the way Carnival has you feeling like family, the restaurants are great, ...
Read More

Sail Date July 2019


dstrock avatar

dstrock

1 Review Written

4 Helpful Votes

Overcrowding, bottlenecks and teeny, tiny pools.

My wife and I decided to take our three kids on a cruise. This was my first cruise and my wife had been on a couple many years ago. Our kids are 7, 10, and 11. I'll work from cruise start to finish so I don't miss ...
Read More

Sail Date July 2019


altolan avatar

altolan

1 Review Written

1 Helpful Vote

Sighhh

This was my first cruise experience. My coworkers tell me to try again, but I just can't. It was an extremely rocky ride...so I struggled. It did smell like sewage the whole time. The other guests on the cruise ...
Read More

Sail Date June 2019


mama2129 avatar

mama2129

3 Reviews Written

15 Helpful Votes

Awesome cruise

We cruised out of NY since it wasn't too far from home. We had an interior room on deck 2 (2295). We were mid ship close to the elevators, when things were happening in the lobby it got pretty loud in our room. ...
Read More

Sail Date July 2019


Never Miss a Deal!
Subscribe and Save
By proceeding, you agree to Cruise Critic’s Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.

Find a Cruise

Easily compare prices from multiple sites with one click

Other Cruise Line Cruise Reviews from New York (Manhattan)

Want to cruise smarter?
Get expert advice, insider tips and more.
By proceeding, you agree to Cruise Critic’s Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.