1. Home
  2. Land-Based Holiday Versus a Cruise? We've Done the Maths For You.

Land-Based Holiday Versus a Cruise? We've Done the Maths For You.

Fred. Olsen's Black Watch in Naeroyfjord, Norway (Photo: Fred. Olsen Cruise Lines)
Fred. Olsen's Black Watch in Naeroyfjord, Norway (Photo: Fred. Olsen Cruise Lines)

Find a Cruise

By proceeding, you agree to Cruise Critic’s Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.

Sponsored by Fred. Olsen Cruise Lines

If you’re new to cruising, you may not yet have realised what incredible value a cruise holiday is. So much is included on board – all meals, entertainment and lectures, daily classes in the gym and on some voyages, drinks.

Updated November 1, 2019

The convenience is a real consideration, too. Step up the gangway and simply relax; all you have to do is enjoy the scenery and explore exciting new ports every day. Your ship will whisk you effortlessly from one gorgeous spot to another.

A cruise can be many things. In Norway, let the scenery unfold as you glide along glassy fjords against a backdrop of snowy mountains and tumbling waterfalls. In France or the Mediterranean, a cruise resembles a string of effortless, glamorous city breaks, with no flying in between, your floating hotel often moored right in the city centre. Further afield, a journey by ship is a convenient and pleasurable way of visiting a series of hard-to-reach ports in a relatively short space of time.

Life on board is all part of the adventure; the friendly crew, the romance of sailing away at sunset, cocktail in hand, anticipating the night ahead, or the excitement of waking up with a new view every day.

Land-based holidays have their place, of course; we’re prepared to admit that not everywhere in the world is accessible by ship. But we reckon that once you’ve tried your first cruise, value aside, you’ll be hooked on the freedom, the friendly atmosphere, the fine food and the attentive service that makes everybody feel like a VIP.

So, which option is the better value? Here, we tackle three different destinations and styles of holiday – the Norwegian fjords, northern France and southeast Asia – and dig down into the costs each type of holiday offers. We’ve used three different Fred. Olsen cruises as the benchmark. Clearly, we’re not always pitting like against like – but these comparisons should give you a clear picture of the fantastic value offered by a cruise. All prices are per person.

The Norwegian fjords

View from land of Fred. Olsen's Black Watch in Flam, Norway (Photo: Fred. Olsen Cruise Lines)

A seven-night cruise, or a self-drive holiday from Bergen?

This seven-night Spellbinding Fjords of Norway cruise on Fred Olsen’s Boudicca sails round-trip from Dover and includes stops in historic Bergen, with its colourful waterfront, Bryggen; Olden and the unspoilt village of Flam, both surrounded by mountains; as well as a rare sailing of the entire Naeroyfjord, a narrow, winding route only accessible to smaller ships, against a backdrop of towering mountains and ribbon-like waterfalls. Extensively rerfurbished in 2018, the 880-passenger Boudicca has three heated pools, Jacuzzis, a large sun deck, a library, self-service laundry, five restaurants and a spa and gym.

 Why go?

  • No flying
  • You only unpack once
  • All meals and drinks are included so budgeting is easy
  • Long days to relax on deck as the ship sails along beautiful fjords

What’s included: All meals including snacks, afternoon tea, room service and tea and coffee; all entertainment and lectures on board; alcoholic drinks; Captain’s formal welcome party.

The maths

The cruise…

  • Seven-night Norwegian fjords cruise on Boudicca: £1,099
  • Meals and drinks: Included
    Total per person: £1,099

…or a fly-drive holiday

  • A seven nights’ self-drive, including flights, car hire and accommodation: £1,707
  • Seven-night self-drive holiday including flights, car hire and half board hotels: £1,707
  • Budget for wine with dinner each night: £100
  • Budget for lunch on seven days: £100
    Total per person: £1,907

Winner:

The cruise is a clear winner on price, all the more so as it’s all-inclusive. Beautiful though it is, Norway is an expensive place to visit on a land-based holiday if you’re having to budget for meals and drinks.

Asia

Photograph: Panorama view. Supertree Groves in Gardens by the Bay at twilight time, Singapore - Photography by SURAKIT SAWANGCHIT via Shutterstock

All-inclusive resort or a 14-night cruise?

This 14-night Indonesian Island Discovery cruise on Fred. Olsen’s Boudicca packs in the experiences, with opportunities for beaches, snorkelling, visiting temples and markets. There’s an overnight in spotless Singapore, for street food, the spectacular, lush Gardens by the Bay and Singapore Slings in Raffles; and a day in Semarang, jumping off point for the Borobudur temple complex. In sleepy Lombok, waterfalls and volcano hikes beckon, while Komodo is famed for its massive dragons, which you should spot on a hike with a ranger. The voyage ends in Bali, with an overnight before disembarking.

 Why go?

  • Multiple ports to give you a real insight into the destination
  • Overnights in Singapore and Bali
  • A chance to see the famous Komodo dragons
  • Sea days for relaxing on deck by the pool
  • All meals included so budgeting is easy    

What’s included: Flights, transfers, all meals, tea and coffee, afternoon tea; entertainment; Captain’s Drinks Party and Gala Buffet.

The maths

The cruise…

  • Holiday cost including flights: £1,899
  • All-inclusive drinks upgrade \@ £19 per night: £266
  • Meals: Included
    Total: £2,165 per person

…or an all-inclusive resort in Thailand

  • Two weeks at Phuket’s Mandarava Resort & Spa: £2,127
  • Meals and drinks: Included 
    Total: £2,127 per person

Winner:

The all-inclusive resort works out marginally cheaper and is an obvious choice if you simply want to flop on a tropical beach. But look at the opportunities on the Fred. Olsen cruise; you’ll see seven different faces of Asia, with overnights to explore Phuket, Singapore and Bali, as well as having lazy days at sea to recharge the batteries and lounge by the pool.

France

The Louvre in Paris, France shot at night with reflections from the pools (Photo: Nigel Wiggins/Shutterstock)

A mini-cruise from Southampton or a city break in Paris?

This leisurely Five Night Seine cruise from Southampton on Boudicca is essentially two mini breaks in one, as you’ll overnight in both Rouen and Honfleur. There’s time sailing the bucolic countryside of Normandy as the ship makes its way inland, too, an experience you can only enjoy on a vessel small enough, like Boudicca, to navigate the river. With an overnight in Rouen, there’s time to explore the medieval city and learn about the tragic story of Joan of Arc, or join a tour to Giverny to see Monet’s dazzling garden. Paris is easy, too, as an excursion or on your own by train. The intercity service does the journey in just over an hour and a quarter, whizzing you to the heart of the city for the museums, galleries, shops and gardens.

Then, there’s an overnight in gorgeous Honfleur, the picturesque port that inspired Monet and his cohorts to capture the colours and the light. Make time for fresh seafood and a glass of chilled white on the waterfront, watching the boats.

Why go?

  • No flying, as you sail from Southampton
  • An easy and convenient way to see two beautiful cities
  • A chance to spend an evening or a day in Paris
  • Scenic sailing along the dreamy Seine
  • No need to budget for meals, as they’re included

What’s included: All meals, alcoholic drinks, tea and coffee, afternoon tea; entertainment; Captain’s Drinks Party and Gala Buffet.

The maths

 The cruise…

  • Holiday cost: £699
  • All meals and drinks: Included
    Total: £699 per person

…or a three-night city break in Paris

  • Three nights’ B&B in a four-star hotel, including Eurostar travel, transfers, metro tickets, a Seine cruise and a museum pass*: £658
  • Budget for dinner with wine on three nights: £75
    Total: £733 per person

Winner:

The five-night cruise is certainly more affordable than a three-night stay in the French capital, and with all food and drinks included, the only extras you’ll incur are excursions and shopping. Of course, you may want to focus entirely on Paris, in which case a Eurostar break is a convenient option, but there’s a wonderfully relaxing quality to a voyage on the Seine, mooring in lovely old cities for the night.

References:

  • Norway: The Hidden Fjords itinerary from Discover the World
  • France: City break with Kirker Holidays
  • Thailand: Mandarava Resort & Spa from Tui

Intrigued by Fred. Olsen's small ship cruises? Read more on Cruise Critic:

One Great Reason Among Many To Try a Small Ship Cruise: Magnificent Ports of Call

All Aboard! Cruising the Baltic on Fred. Olsen’s Boudicca and Why Small and Friendly is the Way To Go

A Land-Based Holiday Versus a Cruise? We've Done the Maths For You.

Travelling Solo? Here's Why a Cruise Makes Perfect Sense For Your Next Holiday


With more than 19 years of editorial experience and a number of awards and nominations, London-based journalist and editor Rebecca Barnes has sailed around the globe in order to create travel and cruise-related content for countless consumer, trade and customer titles. Rebecca, who is a former editor of World of Cruising, currently works with Best Magazine, Cruise Adviser, Cruise Critic, easyJet, The Jewish Chronicle, The Telegraph and Travel Weekly, among others.

Find a Cruise

By proceeding, you agree to Cruise Critic’s Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.

Popular on Cruise Critic

Best Time to Cruise
It's one of the most common cruising questions: When is the best time to cruise Alaska, Australia, the Caribbean, Canada/New England, Hawaii, Europe or the South Pacific? The answer depends on many variables. For example, fall foliage enthusiasts will find September and October the best time to cruise Canada/New England, whereas families prefer to sail in summer when temperatures are warmer for swimming. The best time to cruise to Alaska will vary depending on your preferences for viewing wildlife, fishing, bargain-shopping, sunshine, warm weather and catching the northern lights. For most cruise regions, there are periods of peak demand (high season), moderate demand (shoulder season) and low demand (low season), which is usually the cheapest time to cruise. High season is typically a mix of when the weather is best and popular travel periods (such as summer and school holidays). However, the best time to cruise weather-wise is usually not the cheapest time to cruise. The cheapest time to cruise is when most travelers don't want to go because of chillier temperatures or inopportune timing (too close to holidays, the start of school, etc.). But the lure of cheap fares and uncrowded ports might make you change your mind about what you consider the best time to cruise. As you plan your next cruise, you'll want to take into consideration the best and cheapest times to cruise and see what jibes with your vacation schedule. Here's a when-to-cruise guide for popular destinations.
7 Dumbest Cruise Mistakes Ever
We've all been there: almost getting your Romanian spouse forcibly debarked -- and expatriated; sprinting through the St. Thomas jungle to catch your departing ship; eating three of Guy Fieri's 1,000-calorie burgers in one sitting. Perhaps not, but as Bram Stoker wrote in Dracula, "We learn from failure, not from success!" What has failure taught Cruise Critic's editors and contributors when it comes to cruising? Do your homework on visa requirements, and triple check that you know how to get where you're embarking. Be careful what you eat and what you book. Read our seven mini-stories of supreme stupidity, have a laugh at our expense, and vow never to make the same mistakes.

Find a Cruise

By proceeding, you agree to Cruise Critic’s Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.