• Cheers to 25 years: Celebrate with Us!
  • Write a Review
  • Boards
  • Log In
  • Find a Cruise
  • Deals
  • Excursions
  • More
You may also like
Dismiss
Norwegian Cruise Line vs. Carnival Cruise Line
Top Ships of 2018 Compared: Carnival Horizon vs. Symphony of the Seas vs. Norwegian Bliss
Carnival Horizon

Top Ships of 2018 Compared: Carnival Horizon vs. Symphony of the Seas vs. Norwegian Bliss

Top Ships of 2018 Compared: Carnival Horizon vs. Symphony of the Seas vs. Norwegian Bliss
Carnival Horizon
Dori Saltzman
Contributor
  • Facebook
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter
Spring 2018 will see three mega-cruise ships launching in short succession: Royal Caribbean's Symphony of the Seas, followed by Carnival Cruise Line's Carnival Horizon and ending with Norwegian Cruise Line's Norwegian Bliss. All have multiple restaurants, intriguing outdoor activities and a range of entertainment options, but each has its own flair. Cruise Critic gathered everything we know about the three ships to compare them, so you know which one most appeals to you.

Size

Symphony of the Seas, Norwegian Bliss and Carnival Horizon are mega-cruise ships, so if you're looking for a cozy, intimate vacation you won't find it here. Symphony became the largest ship in the world (by gross tonnage) when it launched in spring 2018. Measuring nearly 230,000 gross registered tons (GRT) and holding 5,535 people at double capacity, it dwarfs both Norwegian Bliss (167,800 GRT and 4,004 passengers) and Carnival Horizon (133,500 GRT and 3,960 passengers).

Dining

Despite its much larger size, Symphony of the Seas has only one more spot to grab food than both Norwegian Bliss and Carnival Horizon (18 versus 17 on both other ships). Cuisine styles you'll find across the ships include Italian, Asian, Mexican and fresh seafood, and dining venues range from date-night fancy to casual to grab-and-go.

For cruisers who don't like shelling out for extra-fee specialty restaurants, Carnival Horizon might be the best choice as it has the most complimentary venues, at least for lunch. Of its nine free restaurants, only three of them are open for dinner. Norwegian Bliss and Symphony of the Seas have five and four free options for dinner, respectively.

Each of the ships feature many of their respective line's signature restaurants, but also debuted new eateries.

On Carnival Horizon and Norwegian Bliss, new barbecue joints are featured, both serving up hearty brisket, ribs and other smoked meats, along with savory side dishes. If you need live country music with your barbecue, Norwegian Bliss' Texas Smokehouse, Q, features a house band playing pop-country hits every night.

Featured Videos

Freedom of the Seas: What's It Like Onboard a Test Cruise? (Cruise Critic & Royal Caribbean Blog

Freedom of the Seas: What's It Like Onboard a Test Cruise? (Cruise Critic & Royal Caribbean Blog

Anthem Of The Seas Welcomes Gigi The Giraffe

Anthem Of The Seas Welcomes Gigi The Giraffe

Oasis Of The Seas Ship Tour - Ship Exterior

Oasis Of The Seas Ship Tour - Ship Exterior

What It Means To Be Loyal To Royal

What It Means To Be Loyal To Royal

Here's What We Packed For Our Royal Caribbean Cruise (June 2021)

Here's What We Packed For Our Royal Caribbean Cruise (June 2021)

7 Can’t-Miss Experiences on Allure Of The Seas

7 Can’t-Miss Experiences on Allure Of The Seas

Celebrity to Restart from U.S. Homeport, PLUS Royal Caribbean Given Green Light for Test Cruises! (VIDEO)

Celebrity to Restart from U.S. Homeport, PLUS Royal Caribbean Given Green Light for Test Cruises! (VIDEO)

Live Interview With Frank Del Rio, NCLH President And CEO, About Company's "Safe To Sail" Campaign

Live Interview With Frank Del Rio, NCLH President And CEO, About Company's "Safe To Sail" Campaign

Odyssey of the Seas -- From Steel Cutting to Delivery 2021

Odyssey of the Seas -- From Steel Cutting to Delivery 2021

Video Of Odyssey Of The Seas Conveyance March 2021

Video Of Odyssey Of The Seas Conveyance March 2021

Video: Royal Caribbean Group Announces E-muster, Keyless Cabin Check-in And Other App Improvements

Video: Royal Caribbean Group Announces E-muster, Keyless Cabin Check-in And Other App Improvements

How To Make A Towel Animals: Swans, Dogs And Elephants

How To Make A Towel Animals: Swans, Dogs And Elephants

Towel Animals With Carnival Cruise Line And Cruise Critic  How To Make Towel Swans

Towel Animals With Carnival Cruise Line And Cruise Critic How To Make Towel Swans

Towel Animals With Carnival Cruise Line And Cruise Critic: How To Make A Towel Dog

Towel Animals With Carnival Cruise Line And Cruise Critic: How To Make A Towel Dog

Towel Animals With Carnival Cruise Line And Cruise Critic: How To Make A Towel Elephant

Towel Animals With Carnival Cruise Line And Cruise Critic: How To Make A Towel Elephant

[Sponsored] Interview With John Padgett

[Sponsored] Interview With John Padgett

Royal Caribbean Odyssey Of The Seas Steel Cutting At Meyer Werft

Royal Caribbean Odyssey Of The Seas Steel Cutting At Meyer Werft

Shipyard Tour: Royal Caribbean’s Symphony Of The Seas Gets Its Finishing Touches -- Video

Shipyard Tour: Royal Caribbean’s Symphony Of The Seas Gets Its Finishing Touches -- Video

Cruise Critic Quick Chat With Carnival CEO Arnold Donald

Cruise Critic Quick Chat With Carnival CEO Arnold Donald

Norwegian Bliss Virtual Tour - Why You Should Be Excited About Norwegian's Newest Ship - Video

Norwegian Bliss Virtual Tour - Why You Should Be Excited About Norwegian's Newest Ship - Video

How To Make Carnival Cruise Line's Famous Warm Chocolate Melting Cake - Video

How To Make Carnival Cruise Line's Famous Warm Chocolate Melting Cake - Video

Shaquille "Shaq" O'neal Named Chief Fun Officer Of Carnival Cruise Line

Shaquille "Shaq" O'neal Named Chief Fun Officer Of Carnival Cruise Line

Carnival Cruise Line's "Choose Fun" Commercial

Carnival Cruise Line's "Choose Fun" Commercial

Harmony Of The Seas Video Tour – Inside Look At One Of Royal Caribbean’s Most Popular Cruise Ships

Harmony Of The Seas Video Tour – Inside Look At One Of Royal Caribbean’s Most Popular Cruise Ships

Symphony Of The Seas Video Tour

Symphony Of The Seas Video Tour

Carnival Splendor Highlights

Carnival Splendor Highlights

Norwegian Breakaway Highlights

Norwegian Breakaway Highlights

Royal Caribbean’s Spectrum Of The Seas Celebrates Keel Laying

Royal Caribbean’s Spectrum Of The Seas Celebrates Keel Laying

Sea Beyond: An Innovative Cruise Experience By Royal Caribbean

Sea Beyond: An Innovative Cruise Experience By Royal Caribbean

Carnival Conquest Highlights

Carnival Conquest Highlights

Carnival Pride Highlights

Carnival Pride Highlights

Carnival Dream Highlights

Carnival Dream Highlights

Sneak Peak At Symphony Of The Seas

Sneak Peak At Symphony Of The Seas

Carnival Sunshine Highlights

Carnival Sunshine Highlights

The Waterfront On Norwegian Cruise Line - Video

The Waterfront On Norwegian Cruise Line - Video

Carnival Breeze Highlights

Carnival Breeze Highlights

What’s Your Size? Royal Caribbean's Oasis Class Vs. Majesty Of The Seas - Video

What’s Your Size? Royal Caribbean's Oasis Class Vs. Majesty Of The Seas - Video

Norwegian Getaway Highlights

Norwegian Getaway Highlights

Inside Look: The Haven On Norwegian Cruise Line - Video

Inside Look: The Haven On Norwegian Cruise Line - Video

Royal Caribbean's Oasis Of The Seas Highlights

Royal Caribbean's Oasis Of The Seas Highlights

Spectrum Of The Seas Steel Cutting At Meyer Werft

Spectrum Of The Seas Steel Cutting At Meyer Werft

Carnival Liberty Highlights

Carnival Liberty Highlights

Royal Caribbean's Enchantment Of The Seas Highlights

Royal Caribbean's Enchantment Of The Seas Highlights

Norwegian Escape's Ropes Course - Are You Brave Enough

Norwegian Escape's Ropes Course - Are You Brave Enough

Inside Look  Norwegian Sky In Cuba

Inside Look Norwegian Sky In Cuba

Norwegian Escape Attractions - 7 Free Things You Have To Try - Video Tour

Norwegian Escape Attractions - 7 Free Things You Have To Try - Video Tour

4 Exclusive Spots On Norwegian Escape - Video Tour

4 Exclusive Spots On Norwegian Escape - Video Tour

Harvest Caye Cruise Port Video Tour

Harvest Caye Cruise Port Video Tour

Norwegian Escape Photo Tour

Norwegian Escape Photo Tour

Royal Caribbean's Allure Of The Seas

Royal Caribbean's Allure Of The Seas

Skyride On Carnival Vista: Cruise Critic Tries It

Skyride On Carnival Vista: Cruise Critic Tries It

Carnival Vista Top Deck Attractions

Carnival Vista Top Deck Attractions

Behind the Scenes at CSMART - Carnival's Arison Maritime Training Center

Behind the Scenes at CSMART - Carnival's Arison Maritime Training Center

Video Tour of Allure Of The Seas' Bars

Video Tour of Allure Of The Seas' Bars

Cruise Pier Runners In Cozumel -- Carnival Liberty

Cruise Pier Runners In Cozumel -- Carnival Liberty

Harmony Of The Seas Youth Place

Harmony Of The Seas Youth Place

Harmony Of The Seas Boardwalk

Harmony Of The Seas Boardwalk

Harmony Of The Seas Pool And Sports Zone

Harmony Of The Seas Pool And Sports Zone

Harmony Of The Seas Central Park On Royal Caribbean International

Harmony Of The Seas Central Park On Royal Caribbean International

Harmony Of The Seas Royal Promenade

Harmony Of The Seas Royal Promenade

Harmony Of The Seas Entertainment Place

Harmony Of The Seas Entertainment Place

Harmony Of The Seas Vitality Spa And Fitness Center

Harmony Of The Seas Vitality Spa And Fitness Center

Perfect Storm Water Slides On Harmony Of The Seas

Perfect Storm Water Slides On Harmony Of The Seas

Cruise Critic Tours Harmony Of The Seas

Cruise Critic Tours Harmony Of The Seas

Harmony Of The Seas Cabins - Video Tour - Cruise Critic

Harmony Of The Seas Cabins - Video Tour - Cruise Critic

Cruise Critic Tours Harmony Of The Seas

Cruise Critic Tours Harmony Of The Seas

Greased Lightnin'  Royal Caribbean Brings Another Broadway Hit

Greased Lightnin' Royal Caribbean Brings Another Broadway Hit

Plunging Into Adventure On The Tallest Slide At Sea: Royal Caribbean Reveals 10-Story Ultimate Abyss

Plunging Into Adventure On The Tallest Slide At Sea: Royal Caribbean Reveals 10-Story Ultimate Abyss

Cruise Critic Flowrider On Royal Caribbean's Freedom Of The Seas

Cruise Critic Flowrider On Royal Caribbean's Freedom Of The Seas

Cruise Critic Tours Anthem of the Seas

Cruise Critic Tours Anthem of the Seas

Norwegian Breakaway Video Tour

Norwegian Breakaway Video Tour

Oasis Of The Seas Flowrider - Cruise Critic Goes Surfing

Oasis Of The Seas Flowrider - Cruise Critic Goes Surfing

Oasis Of The Seas Royal Promenade

Oasis Of The Seas Royal Promenade

Oasis Of The Seas Jazz On 4 Performance

Oasis Of The Seas Jazz On 4 Performance

Oasis Of The Seas Royal Promenade Parade

Oasis Of The Seas Royal Promenade Parade

Oasis Of The Seas Carousel In Action

Oasis Of The Seas Carousel In Action

Oasis Of The Seas Ship Tour   Main Dining Room

Oasis Of The Seas Ship Tour Main Dining Room

For those looking for some pub grub, Symphony of the Seas debuted the Playmakers Sports Bar & Arcade in the ships' Boardwalk neighborhood. Here cruisers can chow down on wings and fries while taking in a sports game on the big-screen TVs or in between sessions of arcade games, including Skee-Ball and long shot basketball.

Outdoor Fun

All three ships have plenty of outside fun for cruisers to enjoy, but here Symphony of the Seas really does shine, with many more activities than either Norwegian Bliss or Carnival Horizon.

As if three water slides, two FlowRider surf simulators, a zipline, mini-golf course, rock wall and the Ultimate Abyss thrill slide that drops riders 10 decks isn't enough, Symphony also has three pools, an outdoor Boardwalk with working carousel and a kids' splash water park.

Norwegian Bliss, on the other hand, has a two-deck electric go-kart racetrack (designed to be used even in inclement weather), an outdoor laser tag arena, three pools and the Aqua Park with two water slides and a kids' splash zone.

Carnival Horizon also has a water park and three pools, though one is reserved during the day for cruisers staying in the Havana section of cabins. Like Symphony, Horizon has a mini-golf course. But, what Horizon has that the others don't is the SkyCourse ropes course and SkyRide, which suspends riders on recumbent bikes while they pedal their way around the midair course.

Bars

When it comes to bars and lounges, all have many of the same standards (pool and atrium bars, casual pub) but each new ship has a few standouts.

Beer drinkers will want to check out either Norwegian Bliss for its District Brew House or Carnival Horizon for Guy's Pig & Anchor Bar-B-Que Smokehouse & Brewhouse, which actually brews up a small selection of craft choices onboard.

Those who prefer a glass of wine will want to look at Symphony of the Seas, with its Royal Caribbean signature venue Vintages, or Norwegian Bliss, which features The Cellars Wine Bar, a product of the line's relationship with the Mondavi wine family.

Symphony of the Seas also has two of the most gimmicky of all the bars: Rising Tide Bar, which is an elevator-style space that rises and falls between three decks while cruisers sip on standard wines, beers and cocktails; and the Bionic Bar, where robotic arms mix cocktails to music.

Cabins

Norwegian Bliss Haven Suite

Symphony of the Seas, Norwegian Bliss and Carnival Horizon all offer standard cabins in inside, outside and balcony categories, but each also offers a few unique accommodations.

Suite cruisers will be most interested in Symphony and Bliss. On the former, there are 13 suite choices including four- and two-bedroom options. The ship also has one Ultimate Family Suite, a loft-style suite that features a slide that takes kids (of all ages) from the top level to the bottom and a LEGO wall for family playtime. Cruisers staying in suites on Symphony of the Seas get a slew of perks, including several all-inclusive packages (dining, drinks, Wi-Fi) as well as access to a suites-only lounge and sun deck.

Norwegian Bliss has the cruise line's ship-within-a-ship suites enclave, The Haven, which has its own restaurant, swimming pool and lounge. Cruisers staying in The Haven also get a slew of perks including several all-inclusive packages.

Families with kids should check out Carnival Horizon, which features Family Harbor, a keycard-accessible area specifically designed for families. Family Harbor has rooms that can hold anywhere from two to five people (depending on configuration), as well as a family-only lounge for playing and a casual buffet breakfast.

From a geeky tech perspective, we can't not mention the "virtual view" cabins on both Symphony and Bliss. Both have rooms with virtual views piped in from cameras located outside the ship: on Symphony the views are floor to ceiling and on Bliss, picture window-sized.

Entertainment & Activities

From big stage song-and-dance shows (on all three) and Broadway musicals ("Hairspray" on Symphony and "Jersey Boys" on Bliss) to live music venues, comedy clubs and large casinos, these big ships are packed with entertainment.

Like going to the movies? Carnival Horizon has one of the only two IMAX movie theaters at sea.

Need something for the entire family to do together? Symphony of the Seas features an ice-skating rink, indoor laser tag arena and the Puzzle Break escape room experience.

And, while all feature live music in several spots every night, only Norwegian Bliss has The Beatles-inspired The Cavern Club with attendant Beatles-tribute band.

Family Focus

All three ships are good choices for families, with plenty to do to keep kids, tweens and teens occupied; all three also have robust kids' and teen's clubs. But, they do differ in a few significant ways.

Only Symphony of the Seas has a nursery where parents can drop off their babies (6 to 36 months) with child care professionals and then go enjoy the day on their own.

Symphony of the Seas is also the only ship that provides in-cabin babysitting (though on a limited basis); group babysitting is also offered on Symphony and is the only type of babysitting you'll find on Norwegian Bliss and Carnival Horizon. On all three an extra fee applies.

Updated January 08, 2020

How was this article?

Featured News

1
Circuit Court Flips on Stay Order; Previous Ruling That CDC is Overstepping in Cruise Stands
5
Silversea Cruise News: Door-to-Door Car Service Now Part of Luxury Cruise Perks
Want to cruise smarter?
Get expert advice, insider tips and more.
By proceeding, you agree to Cruise Critic’s Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.

We have updated the Cruise Critic Privacy and Cookie Statement effective on October 1, 2020. Please click here for more information.