Star Legend Review

Call our partner agents at 866-501-2339 to book your cruise.
58% of cruisers loved it
55 reviews | Write a Review

Why Choose Star Legend?

  • Pro: Destination-driven yacht that visits the world's most off-the-beaten-path ports of call
  • Con: Older ship shows its age despite its $8.5 million refurbishment in 2015
  • Bottom Line: Ideal for active couples seeking a romantic, small ship atmosphere

Star Legend Overview

By Andrea M. Rotondo, Cruise Critic contributor
Editor Rating
3.0

For years, Windstar Cruises had been a fleet of three majestic motor-sail-yachts: Wind Surf, Wind Star and Wind Spirit. But in 2014–2015, the line doubled in size when it purchased a trio of 212-passenger luxury yachts from Seabourn. Star Legend is one of those yachts; it, along with sister ship Star Breeze, made its maiden voyage with Windstar in May 2015.

Windstar's vibe of laid-back luxury carries over from the sailing ships to the yachts. The intimacy of the ship means that the crew -- especially the stewards, wait staff and bartenders -- get to know you and anticipate your requests. The staff is friendly and will call you by your first name -- not Mr. or Mrs. So-and-So, as is often the case on the luxury lines. The ship's ambiance is relaxed but classy, with casual attire recommended during the day and resort casual in the evenings. The freedom of no formal night means travelers don't have to pack too much.

Star Legend offers an "almost luxury" experience, just like its fleetmates. Your cruise fare isn't all-inclusive like it is aboard the ships of SeaDream, Regent Seven Seas or Silversea. Non-alcoholic beverages (soda, water, specialty teas and coffee) are included, but you'll need to buy a beverage package or pay a la carte for any alcoholic drinks that you order. You'll likewise pay for all shore excursions, with the exception of Windstar's special complimentary private event -- often a beach BBQ or a visit to a cultural center for a concert and canapes. All dining options, including the intimate Candles, are surcharge-free.

Experienced cruisers will note some significant differences between the motor-sail-yachts and Star Legend. For starters, this is more of a traditional cruise ship and that means the cabins are larger than those on the sailing ships. In comparison, they feel downright spacious with walk-in closets, a marble bathroom with double sinks and a shower (or shower/tub combo), and either large picture windows or a French balcony. There are also elevators (not found on Wind Star and Wind Spirit), which makes this ship more appropriate for anyone with compromised mobility. (However, be aware that there is no way to initially board the ship other than a flight of stairs, and one of the elevators did not always work during our voyage.)

Windstar applied $8.5 million in upgrades to Star Legend before it joined the fleet. Cabins, the restaurants and all public spaces benefitted from the refresh. The redesign of The Yacht Club was particularly successful; it's a main gathering place on the ship, offering coffee, sandwiches and snacks along with terrific views. The size of the pool on the Sun Deck was curiously decreased, but there are two lovely hot tubs that passengers use frequently.

Despite Star Legend's refit, the ship's two tenders have had technical problems ever since the ship debuted with Windstar. During our voyage, one tender was inoperable and the other was underpowered for the task of ferrying all passengers ashore. At one port, the wait for tender service reached an hour or more, making travelers miss out on precious time ashore. To Windstar's credit, the line did arrange for rental tenders in most other ports, but the crew was not always on hand to assist passengers on and off these vessels. It seemed to be both a mechanical and service lapse.

That's too bad, because the line's calling card is its destination focus. Star Legend calls in immensely popular ports (St. Martin, Venice, Barcelona) while also visiting lesser-known spots that the big ships can't get anywhere near (Montserrat, the BVI's Jost Van Dyke and Isafjordur, Iceland). Windstar's port-intensive itineraries are a major selling point to many passengers who select their voyage based on the destinations Windstar visits. Star Legend isn't the type of ship where travelers stay aboard all day when the ship is in port. They get out there and explore -- either as part of a ship-sponsored shore excursion or on their own.

Star Legend Fellow Passengers

Star Legend attracts well-to-do professional couples in their 40s and 50s, as well as active retirees in their 60s who enjoy meeting fellow passengers and partaking in pastimes such as water sports from the ship's aft marina. It also appeals to older and less mobile folks who need to make use of the elevator (not found on Wind Spirit or Wind Star). Warm-weather voyages tend to draw a younger demographic, and almost everyone you meet will be American or Canadian.

Star Legend Dress Code

One of Windstar's hallmarks is its ability to offer luxury in a laid-back atmosphere. There is no daytime dress code: Shorts, jeans, T-shirts and capris are all fair game and underscore the overall casual vibe of the ship. In the evening, bank on "elegantly casual" attire such as sundresses, blouses and capris for ladies, and slacks and collared shirts for men. Jeans, T-shirts, shorts and sneakers are prohibited in the restaurants at dinner. There are no formal nights on Windstar, though they do throw deck BBQs that allow shorts and more casual attire. (If your itinerary includes Monaco, men might want to bring a jacket and tie since many casinos require them for entry.)

Star Legend Gratuity

All passengers are charged $12 per person, per day, for gratuities. The fee is added to your tab and can be paid at the end of the cruise via cash, traveler's check or credit card (American Express, Discover, Visa and MasterCard only). If you wish to tip more or less than the suggested amount, visit the Reception Desk. A 15 percent tip is automatically charged to all beverage orders and spa treatments at the time service is rendered. The onboard currency is the U.S. dollar.

Next: Star Legend Cabins
Print this section

Start your review of Star Legend

Click to rate

Star Legend Member Reviews

I came upon the itinerary Land of the Midnight Sun purely by chance when looking for another family trip, but it was an itinerary we had been looking for, on a small ship, and so we signed up. The offices, which are out of Seattle, did not ... Read more
My husband and I chose this cruise for the itinerary, which was very interesting: Dublin, Orkney Island, Norwegian fjords, Faroe Islalnds, Reykjavik. Being an old Seaborne ship, the cabin is a suite which was large with a sitting area, walkin ... Read more
Did a circumnavigation of Iceland. Ship was in very good condition, considering its age (but it did have a refurb last May). A few minor things could have been better, tho. Liked our window stateroom - at 277 sq. ft, it was large for a very small ... Read more
1 - 3 of 55 Reviews
Show The Lowest Price

Star Legend Ratings

Editor Rating 3.0 Member Rating
Category
Editor
Member
Dining
3.0
3.9
Public Rooms
4.0
4.0
Cabins
5.0
4.4
Entertainment
3.0
3.2
Spa & Fitness
4.0
3.0
Family & Children
1.0
0.5
Shore Excursions
4.0
3.2
Enrichment
1.0
3.1
Service
3.0
4.2
Value-for-Money
3.0
3.4

Explore This Ship

Star Legend Deck Plans Star Legend Cabin Reviews
Ship Stats
Crew:
145
Launched:
2015
Decks:
6
Tonnage:
9,975
Passengers:
212
Registry:
Bahamas
CDC Score:
94
Pricing:
$899 - $4,770 (Based on standard per person rates for Outside Stateroom)
Share feedback
Thank you!  Cruise Critic values your feedback.
How can we improve this page?
Close ×
See Deals on Star Legend up to 82% off