Become a Cruise Insider
Tips, deals and more in your inbox.
Your Ultimate Cruise Guide

Carnival Fantasy Review

Carnival Fantasy
Carnival Fantasy - Pool Deck Carnival Fantasy - Oceanview Cabin Carnival Fantasy - Mini-Golf Carnival Fantasy - Carnival WaterWorks
72% of cruisers loved it
753 reviews | Write a Review
  • 25-year-old ship with a multi-million dollar facelift
  • Casual dress codes -- jeans are OK at night
  • Dining options: patisserie, sushi, Mongolian, pizza
Show The Lowest Price

Carnival Fantasy Overview

By Ashley Kosciolek, Copy Editor
Editor Rating
4.0
Carnival Fantasy is like your favorite pair of jeans or an old pair of sneakers -- a little worn out but so comfortable you just keep coming back to them. Sure, the ship appears broken-in and shows its age in some spaces -- I mostly noticed this in the cabins -- but that's easily overlooked in light of its friendly, welcoming atmosphere. And it's just plain comfortable, from bed linens and pillows to deck chairs and dress code. Not to mention that its muted color scheme, compared with some of its sister ships, is very easy on the eyes. Dark bluish-purple tones in the elevator lobbies and on the first floor of the Grand Atrium exude a calming vibe, while nearby cabin hallways are unobtrusively cheerful with their bright, cream-colored walls.

Even better, thanks to Carnival's fleetwide $350 million "Evolutions of Fun" initiative (a designer patch on those old jeans, if you will), this 20-year-old vessel now looks less than half its age. During a 2008 dry dock, the ship was spruced up with cabin upgrades (including flat-screen TV's), a new water park and expanded dining options. Carnival Fantasy even looks more trendy and modern, with cabins furnished in reds and golds, and dining rooms accented with plush chairs and soft white lights. And while the ship still doesn't have all the amenities of its younger siblings, the upgrades offer something new and fresh for passengers and keep the ship attractive to cruise travelers.

Beyond the hardware, what really stood out on my sailing was the service. From our room steward and waiters, to the folks at Guest Services, every single crewmember onboard seemed to want me to have the trip of a lifetime, and all other passengers with whom I spoke agreed. On embarkation day, our room steward stopped by to introduce himself and called us by name every single time we bumped into him afterward. During dinner, our waiters, Thanet and Djedje Idi, asked us about our trip and made a point of remembering our nightly preferences to better anticipate our needs -- two dishes of ice cream instead of one, a pina colada with dessert, water instead of iced tea. And when I couldn't decide which of three soups I'd like best, they brought me one of each!

Another plus for Carnival Fantasy: It's the first -- and currently the only -- ship to sail out of Charleston. Out-of-towners will find that this friendly port city can make for a great pre- or post-cruise stay, while locals will find it to be an easy drive-to cruise experience (which would explain why there were so many Southerners on our sailing).

Carnival Fantasy Fellow Passengers

Carnival ships draw lots of families, especially during the summer months. The majority of those onboard seemed to be in their late-30's and 40's, many with children. (Again, there were more than 600 kids on our summer sailing.) Most are from the southern United States, and many I met were from North and South Carolina -- within easy driving distance of the ship's Charleston homeport.

Carnival Fantasy Dress Code

The dress code onboard is "Cruise Casual." Most people opt for shorts and T-shirts or tank tops with bathing suits underneath. However, dinner in the dining rooms is a slightly more dressy affair, with men wearing khakis and button-downs or collared shirts and women wearing sundresses or blouses with skirts or dress pants. Sailings of six nights or less will have one "Cruise Elegant" formal night, during which men generally wear suits, tuxes or -- at the very least -- ties and blazers. Most women opt for evening gowns, cocktail or party dresses or pantsuits. Cruises of seven nights or more have two formal nights. No cutoffs, gym shorts, flip-flops or bathing suits are allowed in the dining room at any time. Jeans are fine, as long as they aren't ripped.

Carnival Fantasy Gratuity

Carnival recommends $12.00 per person, per day. The guidelines allocate $6.10 to dining room services, $3.90 to cabin services and $2 per day for alternative services, which include kitchen, entertainment, guest services and other hotel staff members. The amount is automatically added to your shipboard account, but it can be adjusted in either direction at the guest services desk. A 15 percent gratuity is automatically added to bar bills. Tipping a couple dollars for room service at delivery is expected (and appreciated) by the service staff.
Next: Carnival Fantasy Cabins
Print the entire ship review

Carnival Fantasy Member Reviews

Very Good Trip wannagonow123
08/15
Even though this was an older and smaller ship, we had a great time. My husband and I are retired and decided to take a short trip. Even though we did not read a lot of positive reviews, we decided to take the chance, and we are glad we did. We had ... Read more
Traveled solo for this one. Enjoyed the fact that we were the only ship in every port we went to. The Boston Concert was outstanding. Lasted a good 2 hours. While the ship was rusting in some areas around doorways, the service from the crew was ... Read more
My cruise to the Bahamas on Carnival Fantasy was wonderful with one exception, the manager of the casino. He was a very tall thin man about 6ft 5, with a condescending arrogant attitude towards me. Everyone else on this cruise ship was very ... Read more
1 - 3 of 753 Reviews
Show The Lowest Price

Carnival Fantasy Ratings

Editor Rating 4.0 Member Rating
Category
Editor
Member
Dining
4.0
3.9
Public Rooms
4.0
4.1
Cabins
3.0
4.0
Entertainment
3.0
3.8
Spa & Fitness
3.0
3.8
Family & Children
5.0
3.5
Shore Excursions
3.0
3.8
Enrichment
2.0
3.4
Service
5.0
4.4
Value-for-Money
5.0
4.1

Sailing From

Charleston Miami

Cruises To

Bahamas Caribbean - Eastern Caribbean - Western

Explore This Ship

Carnival Fantasy Deck Plans Carnival Fantasy Cabin Reviews
Ship Stats
Crew:
920
Launched:
1990
Decks:
10
Tonnage:
70,367
Passengers:
2,056
Registry:
Panama
CDC Score:
94
Close X
Show Prices for Carnival Fantasy

Thank You For Signing Up!

Please Note: To ensure delivery of your free e-letters, please add news@cruisecritic.com to your address book.
We're committed to protecting your privacy and will not rent or sell your e-mail address. By proceeding, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.