Subscribe today
Get Cruise Critic in your inbox
Luxury Deals Luxury Ship Reviews Luxury Itineraries Luxury Features Luxury Cruise Forum

Sea Cloud Review

Home > Cruise Ship Reviews > Sea Cloud > Sea Cloud Review
100% of cruisers loved it
  • World's most luxurious tall ship
  • Built in 1931 for heiress Marjorie Merriwether Post
  • Interiors restored to their original splendor

Show the Lowest Price
Departure Month
Please select at least one vendor.
Cruise.com

Sea Cloud Overview

(5.0) 5.0 out of 5+ star rating
Only a select few vessels in the world have the mystique to turn everyone's eye and generate excitement and envy whenever they sail into port. An authentic remnant from another era, the square-rigged, 1931-built Sea Cloud is just such a vessel. Managing to combine the luxury and intimacy of a private yacht with the history and romance of a sailing ship, some consider a voyage on Sea Cloud to be not only one of the best cruises in the world, but one of the top travel experiences available anywhere.

Built for American cereal heiress Marjorie Merriweather Post, the Sea Cloud was at that time the largest private yacht ever constructed. Mrs. Post spent years designing the ship and spared no expense in its fitting out. Just to make sure everything was perfect, a Brooklyn warehouse was even rented where she constructed full-scale mock-ups of the interior.

Sailing as Mrs. Post's beloved yacht until 1955, Sea Cloud had a remarkable career entertaining royalty and being used on diplomatic missions for one of Mrs. Post's husbands. During World War II, despite the initial objections of President Roosevelt who felt that she was simply too beautiful to be sacrificed, the ship was loaned to the U.S. Coast Guard and saw service against German U-Boats. Stripped of her masts, painted gray and fitted with anti-submarine guns, she served as a weather observation platform in the Atlantic.

Eventually sold to the dictator of the Dominican Republic, the ship's career was more checkered until it was bought in 1978 by a German group of investors who cared about it as much as Mrs. Post did. After a significant refurbishment, Sea Cloud entered passenger service in 1979 with a capacity of 65 passengers and 61 crew, a ratio that no accountant with a major cruise line would permit.

Today, Sea Cloud still feels very much like a private home and boasts some of the most attractive public rooms and cabins at sea. Days are tranquil and relaxed, either spent on deck under sail or at anchor in some of the smallest and most exclusive ports in the Caribbean or Mediterranean. Food and service are generally exceptional, with meals often served on deck. The ship's loyal staff (repeat passengers are quickly recognized), the friendly camaraderie between like-minded passengers, and the magic of the billowing sails create an experience that is impossible to duplicate.

Sea Cloud's most remarkable feature is its four masts, 29 sails and the tangled web of lines stretching skyward 178 feet to support the rigging. Unlike the modern, electronically operated Windstar Cruises ships, or Star Clipper's racier reproductions, Sea Cloud is genuine, and all sail setting is done by hand. Eighteen crewmembers scamper up the rigging and perform dazzling acrobatic acts, suspended over the ocean -- and your head -- as they furl sails.

With sailing one of the main reasons people choose Sea Cloud, the engines are used as little as possible, and itineraries created to allow for sufficient time underway. On my March sailing in the Caribbean, we often cruised with the engines off and just the sails pulling us along as the ship heeled gently under the wind. Because of the extra manpower required to operate the sails, they come down at 6 p.m., and the vessel motors during the evening.

Sea Cloud is maintained to the highest standards, and few ships can match the beauty of her teak decks, constantly gleaming brightwork and numerous details. In fact, the level of detail in the construction is so great that every vantage of the ship seems beautiful, and every coil of line on deck becomes a piece of art. Seen from afar with sails furled, the rigging is fascinating in its complexity, but with sails set, it is an evocative call to the past.

Reviewer's Note: Rating Sea Cloud was difficult! Judging by Cruise Critic's general guidelines, Sea Cloud doesn't offer enough amenities to warrant five stars (there are no balconies or alternative eateries). But this is one case (actually it's not the first case -- SeaDream's ships have also won a five star rating without many of the usual bells and whistles of luxury ships) where the overall experience might be justified in putting five stars. Much of the ratings have to reflect the uniqueness of the ship in some bit.
Sea Cloud Fellow Passengers
Sea Cloud is almost an icon in Germany, and a large percentage of the passengers will be German. Average passenger are in their late 40's to 70's, with a concentration centered around the late 50's.

Throughout the year, however, Americans make up the largest percentage of passengers carried, with the greatest percentage of Americans traveling in the summer Mediterranean season. It is possible, however, to get trips where Americans are in the minority. On my March Caribbean sailing, only six of the 36 passengers were either British or American. The ship's crew is proficient in both English and German, and the ship easily operates with two languages when needed.

Most passengers are well educated and financially successful (and you have to be to afford the cruise), but not pretentious or stuffy. There is a nautical, yacht-club feeling that pervades, and many of the passengers either sail themselves or own their own boat (or yacht). For many passengers, sailing Sea Cloud is the fulfillment of a dream, and they walk around wide-eyed all week, marveling at their luck. One passenger I spoke to when asked why he booked, simply exclaimed, "Sea Cloud! Sea Cloud! This is the Sea Cloud! I must -- I had to!"
Sea Cloud Dress Code
During the day, Sea Cloud is casual, with most of the life centered around being outside in shorts and a T-shirt enjoying the weather and the sailing. At night, when eating outside, dress would be described in cruise line speak as "elegantly casual." Khaki pants and a nice collared shirt or button down shirt for men are sufficient, with women wearing a sundress or equivalent. Two nights a week are generally formal, with suits and a few jackets and ties being the norm. On these nights dinner is served inside in the dining room off a fixed menu.
Sea Cloud Gratuity
Gratuities run a bit steep at a recommended amount of 14 Euros ($17.50 U.S.) per day, but the service is excellent, and with so few passengers, stewards come to know the passengers well. Tips can be charged to your onboard account.
Print the entire ship review


Sea Cloud Member Reviews 4 Reviews
   Two Fantastic Ships - Sea Cloud and Sea Cloud II
June 2014

An elegant grandmother, Sea Cloud is a four masted beauty from 1931. She has all the richness and character of a family possession designed by Marjorie Merriweather Post, and to this day it feels like her family ship and as a guest on board like ...continue


National Geographic charters the magnificent Sea Cloud 100 days a year. We sailed coastal Turkey and The Aegean up to Athens in May, 2014. Everything about this trip was amazing. The boat is an astonishment and the experience of being under sail ...continue


It was evident from the start that this tall ship cruise was a 5-star experience. There were 81 guests, mostly Germans. The ship’s language is English, so the captain gives his orders in English. Although, there were only 10-12 English ...continue


1 - 3 of 4 Reviews


Overview   Cabins   Dining   Activities   Family   Deck Plans   More Reviews  
 

Show the Lowest Price
Departure Month
Please select at least one vendor.
Cruise.com
Sponsored Listings:
red arrow
red arrow
Sea Cloud Ratings
Member Rating
Dining
5.0
4.8
Public Rooms
5.0
5.4
Cabins
4.0
5.4
Entertainment
2.0
4.2
Spa & Fitness
2.0
4.0
Family & Children
2.0
0.0
Shore Excursions
4.0
5.3
Enrichment
3.0
NA
Service
5.5
5.3
Value-for-Money
4.0
4.8
Rates
5.0
0.0

Explore This Ship
Ship Stats
Crew: 61
Launched: 1931 (rebuilt 1979)
Decks: 3
Tonnage: 2,532
Passengers: 65
Registry: Malta
CDC Score: Not yet inspected
 
Community
Join the Forums
Get answers from real cruisers on the forums

Join the Roll Call
Make friends, share tours
About UsAdvertisingEditorial DisclaimerPress
PrivacySite MapStoreSubscribe
X

Thank You For Signing Up!

Please Note: To ensure delivery of your free e-letters, please add news@cruisecritic.com to your address book.

We're committed to protecting your privacy and will not rent or sell your e-mail address. By proceeding, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.