Subscribe today
Get Cruise Critic in your inbox

Discovery Review

52% of cruisers loved it
Why Go?
  • Sister to the original "Love Boat"
  • Passenger capacity limits: 800-guest ship is never full
  • Regionally focused enrichment lectures
  • Explores exotic destinations
  • Underwent a superb refit in 2003
  • Modern comforts and amenities
  • Passengers are mature and well-traveled

Discovery Overview

(3.5) 3.5 out of 5+ star rating
Along with the QE2 and Titanic, the MV Discovery must be among the most familiar looking passenger ships in the world. As the former Island Princess, she was the sister ship of the old Pacific Princess, TV's "Love Boat," and even stood in for her more famous and almost identical sibling on some episodes.

I love this ship. It was built during a time when vessels had graceful lines, when staterooms were designed to fit the shape of the ship and not manufactured in mass quantities, and it should be declared a historical landmark. A superb refit in 2003 has retained most of its original charm, and if you didn't know this vessel was more than 35 years old, you'd never guess it by its condition. They really don't make ships like this anymore, and it's a shame.

It has recently been announced that Discovery will enter dry dock later this year and will undergo an extensive refurbishment before entering service under the Cruise & Maritime Voyages brand in 2013. Voyages of Discovery will take delivery of another ship at the end of 2012, the 15,721-ton, 540-passenger mv Voyager. Voyager has undergone a multi-million dollar refit and will enter service in December with 270 cabins, 30 of which have balconies.

Discovery began its service as the Island Venture in September of 1971 for the Norwegian company Flagship Cruises, where it made the New York-to-Bermuda run. In 1972 it was renamed Island Princess when it joined the Princess fleet, where it stayed until it was sold to the Korean company Hyundai Asian Cruises in 1999. Briefly known as Platinum in 2001, it was bought later that year by Gerry Herrod's Discovery Cruises and launched as their only ship in 2003.

Voyages of Discovery describes itself as a "soft adventure" experience, a way for passengers to go to seldom visited destinations without the rigorous shore excursions and spartan accommodations of the "hard adventure" competitors. Exotic destinations include Greenland, Iceland, Faroe Islands, Norway's North Cape, Spitsbergen, the Amazon, Devil's Island, Easter Island and Robinson Crusoe Island. It is the only non-Ecuadorian cruise ship with a port of call in the Galapagos Islands. It even cruises to Cuba; those trips are marketed only through its British brochures and Web site.

Discovery carries four or five times more passengers than many other excursion ships, but this doesn't tell the whole story. Discovery has a passenger capacity of more than 800, but the line says it never carries more than 650. Further, the Ecuadorian government allows only 500 passengers when it visits the Galapagos.

Discovery Fellow Passengers
Passengers come from all corners of the former British Empire. On our cruise, which a spokeswoman for the line said was typical of a winter cruise, more than a third of the passengers were from the United Kingdom, a third were from the U. S. or Canada, and 20 percent were Australian or New Zealanders. She added that summer cruises tended to be about 60 percent British with the remaining balance from those same countries mentioned above.

Cruises are longer than average (10 to 48 nights in the current schedule), and it's no surprise that the great majority of passengers have passed the half-century mark. According to the cruise line, repeat passengers typically comprise 20 to 25 percent of passengers aboard. The exotic destinations and excellent enrichment programs tend to attract a well-traveled and intelligent crowd for which "soft adventure" is adventure enough.

About five percent of the passengers on our cruise were with a tour group from Japan, which I was told is not unusual. There were some announcements in Japanese and a Japanese-language version of the daily program. However, when one Japanese-American passenger who was not a part of that group booking requested copies of this daily program, a group representative refused to give them to her, and only after eventual intervention from the purser's office was the passenger provided with this amenity. I'm surprised that the hotel department took days to rectify the situation, and amazed that the Japanese travel company would go to such lengths to alienate a potential customer.
Discovery Dress Code
You can definitely leave the tuxedo and formal wear at home if you want -- comfortable and practical are the order of the day. There was a suggested after-six dress code buried on page three of the daily program, which seemed to be unnoticed or disregarded by a fair number of passengers. Two-thirds of our nights called for "casual" (slacks and sport shirt) dress; with two "informal" (suit or jacket and tie for the men, skirt or "trouser-suit" for the women) nights; and one "formal" (an evening or cocktail dress for women, a dark suit or dinner jacket for men) evening, the Captain's Welcome Cocktail Party and Dinner. For the Pirates of South America theme night, a "tropical" (bright or colorful clothing) dress code was also appropriate, with some passengers (obviously the ones who had sailed with the line before) sporting pirate accessories. Arrrgh!

Because many of the destinations are exotic, it pays to do your homework so you'll know what kind of climate(s) to prepare for. We left a winter storm in Philadelphia, flew directly to beautiful summer weather in the 70's in Buenos Aires, then encountered above-freezing temperatures on the Antarctic Peninsula -- three different wardrobes required for a two-week trip.
Discovery Gratuity
The line suggests a modest $7.50 per person, per day, which covers the cabin and dining room staff. This amount is automatically charged to your onboard account, but "Guests have the option of removing the charges if they feel they are unjustified."

Print the entire ship review


Discovery Member Reviews 70 Reviews
   Feeling ripped off
July 2014

Lets start off with the positives:

We got to see Iceland

The coffee was good

The Blue Lagoon was sublime

Our cruise aboard MV Discovery was, unfortunately, the worst cruising experience I have had. My husband, who ...continue


   Utter shambles
May 2014

This voyage was an utter shambles. Due to it being windy, the ship didn’t leave Bristol docks for 28 hours; consequently we were late arriving at several of the scheduled places to visit and two of the ports ( Oban and Stornoway) we never ...continue


We have just returned home after spending 7 nights on the HM DISCOVERY. We were charged £2000 of our hard earned money to travel around Scottish Isles This cruise advertised all of the wonderful wild life that we would be seeing at all of ...continue


1 - 3 of 70 Reviews


Overview   Cabins   Dining   Activities   Family   Itineraries   More Reviews  
Sponsored Listings:
Discovery Ratings
Member Rating
Dining
3.0
3.8
Public Rooms
4.0
3.8
Cabins
3.0
3.4
Entertainment
3.0
3.6
Spa & Fitness
2.0
3.1
Family & Children
1.0
0.0
Shore Excursions
5.0
3.9
Enrichment
5.5
NA
Service
2.0
4.2
Value-for-Money
5.0
3.3
Rates
3.0
3.4

Sailing From

Cruises To
Baltic & Northern Europe
Europe - Mediterranean All

Explore This Ship
Ship Stats
Crew: 364
Launched: 1971/2003
Decks: 8
Tonnage: 20,216
Passengers: 650
Registry: Bermuda
CDC Score: 89
 
Community
Join the Forums
Get answers from real cruisers on the forums

Join the Roll Call
Make friends, share tours
Cruise & Maritime Voyages Ships
Astor
Discovery
Marco Polo
About UsAdvertisingEditorial DisclaimerPress
PrivacySite MapStoreSubscribe
X

Thank You For Signing Up!

Please Note: To ensure delivery of your free e-letters, please add news@cruisecritic.com to your address book.

We're committed to protecting your privacy and will not rent or sell your e-mail address. By proceeding, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.