Went to Paradise Beach. Their new pool is amazing. Spent most of my time there. Food service was slow. My boys jet skied and had a ball. Lots of water toys to play on too. A great beach that does not charge to get in. You pay as you go.
I give this a three because we docked at Calica which is nothing but a salt mine. But once you get away from there it is amazing. Booked a tour through Edventure. Went to Tulum, snorkeled in a beautiful cave, ziplined, canoed, jumped off a cliff into a beautiful lagoon and had lunch on a beautiful beach. Wonderful company to do business with. Highly recommend! Another plus is Tulum is so close. Only a 30 to 40 minute drive from the port!