Alamo was the BEST, we arrived (along with 7 other people) after the last shuttle to the port. We attempted to hail a taxi which is an easy task in any large city.........except here. We tried 6 cab companies and 4 were closed and others couldn't service us.
Rented a car once again, the island is BEAUTIFUL. Easy to get around and a relaxed atmosphere. Be sure to stop at some of the local shops as they are very friendly and have great merchandise cheap for friends and family.