As divers, I booked a two tank dive trip with Blue Waters divers (see my TripAdvisor.com post) for four of us and my wife and daughter took the Catarman excursion through Holland. All of us had a great time!
Scuba - certified Rating:
As divers, I booked a two tank dive trip with Blue Waters divers (see my TripAdvisor.com post) for four of us and my wife and daughter took the Catarman excursion through Holland. All of us had a great time!
We docked at 12noon, so we spent the afternoon walking around Old San Juan. I highly recommend that you just turn left at the dock, stop by the Tourist office for a map and continue walking down the Promanade/walkway to the Old San Juan Gate and El Morro fort! (see my TripAdvisor.com review)
I rented an SUV at Hertz ($155/day) and all six of us drove to Maho Bay beach to see the incoming airplanes, then we drove to the French side of the island and circled the island back to the port. In the future, I would skip the French side (dirty) and just drive to Orient beach. (see my TripAdvisor.com review)
we just enjoyed playing on the beach (bring a frisbee) and rest in the sun (sunscreen!) I realize that it's logistically difficult to feed 3,000+ people at Half Moon Cay, but they need to improve the availability of food (no Mahi left) and organization of the food lines.
More 
