We booked a private tour guide. We went to Dunn's Rivers Falls and river tubing. The Falls were fun except for the vendors on your way out. They were very aggressive. We could have done without the tubing. we did stop at Scotchies and had real good Jamaican BBQ.
The beach that we were allowed on with this tour was ok. It had more vendors trying to sell things than I thought there would be on a private beach. We walked around the property after the beach and that was very nice.