Crew Members were good, They sold food on the boat and also had souvenirs for sale (cheap and just about OK) We didn't eat the food no reason to spend $$ when we were headed back shortly. We did bring our own water anyway - so we were good.
Segways were fun - but the tour was stupid - we went down a sidewalk and by the roads/beaches (nothing GREAT) We would have been better off staying at Senor Frogs and drinking
The Island still needs to be developed better. It was nice but it would have been better if they offered authentic Island food instead of hamburgers, hot dogs & pizza (same as the late night food on the ship). If it weren't raining we could have marked it better - its not NCLs fault BUT it did feel like a waste. We did do the wave runner tour - and that was good (we would rate it a 4)
More 
