Carnival Magic Cruise Review by DisasterGuy: Working out the Wrinkles
Overall Member Rating
Working out the Wrinkles
Destination: Europe - Western Mediterranean
The Carnival Magic is a beautiful ship. We were looking forward to our second Med cruise with Carnival. New port of departure for us; Barcelona was dazzling and different from what we experienced in other trips to Europe. Nice weather, nice food, friendly (for an urban setting) people, and breathtaking architecture and history.
This cruise was a month after the maiden cruise and it was interesting for us to see crews still hurrying about finishing "the punch list": corrections (prior table/umbrella design didn't hold up on rear deck so they were being retrofitted); chaise and chairs were breaking and being replaced so initial tight budget items being re-examined; finishing certain repairs every morning had hammering and drilling waking my wife up early. Thank goodness for good coffee. These are things you might think about with new buildings, interesting to see it apply to a big, beautiful ship. I learned that that was part of advantage for Carnival to sail in Med after More maiden trip: closer to construction company.
The crew was friendly and trying hard to get into the groove that helps them in their time onboard. Some were still learning differences between the Magic and where ever they had last served. The cruise director, John Heald, was already on script by our trip; an odd advantage of CruiseCritic reviews was that we had already heard his "Nice & Ezy" joke online.
The itinerary was fantastic -- like going through a dessert buffet where everything looks good: Monaco, Rome, Florence/Pisa, Naples, Dubrovnik, Venice and Messina. We stuck with the menu theme and tried a little of everything: some ports on our own, some with excursions, and even one staying on the boat (we had cruised to Messina the previous summer; had the hat and scarf already).
Looking forward to future Med Cruises. Still haven't seen Istanbul! Less
Read more Carnival Magic cruise reviews >>
Read Cruise Critic's Carnival Magic Review >>
Cabin review: 4B7963 Interior
This small, out-of-the-way cabin was great. Less foot traffic in the hallway outside your door. Only a few steps from the less-used rear stairwell up to the Lido deck for breakfast and the rear deck for sun (and the smoking area)Read All Interior (4B) Reviews >>
Port and Shore Excursions
Capri Walking Tour
Pompeii Walking Tour
All Round Great Adult Holiday
Great itinerary, great new shi...
Great destination cruise but t...
Family Cruise for Dad's 75th B...
Had a great time but the Magic...
Magical Family Reunion Cruise