“Great time on the Magic”
Cruise review of Carnival Magic

BUSTERBROWN99 Carnival Magic 5 Great time on the Magic
Member Since 2012
No Helpful Votes
Overall Member Rating
We just got off the Magic last Sunday with 3 adults and 3 kids ages 8-13. We had such a good time! It was the second cruise for my daughter and I. We brought other family members with us for their first cruise and they're hooked now! We got on the ship a little after 11:30 am, embarkation was smooth. The room wasn't ready until 1:30 but that was no problem for us. Yes it was crowded but it's a big ship and lots of passengers, so we expected that and just worked with it. The younger children enjoyed Camp Carnival and Circle C but the 13 yr old wouldn't have any part in it, just a typical teenager thing. There were great things about the ship but where it lacked it wasn't that bad. The crew were friendly and the ship all around was kept clean, saw very little messes if any. We went to the MDR Northern Upper with the exception of two nights and it was fantastic! The servers were amazing and the food was great! I sailed on the Dream and the MDR there was terrible, both the servers and food, so we always went to the buffet instead. We had made reservations last fall via Carnival's website for the steakhouse. It was okay, food was not as good as the Dream. The kicker was they put us right by the kitchen and was very noisy and incredibly busy with dishes plopped down beside us on a side table. There were no other tables available so we didn't raise a fuss but did mention on the survey sent from Carnival they should remove that table. The Lido had a different feel, no bands or singers. One early afternoon some passengers at the next table to us were really drunk. One older female who had too much thought it was funny to run around bouncing a fake coconut drink cup & lid in her top which created a wardrobe malfunction. We all saw way more of her than we wanted to (in front of children too), that image will stick with us unfortunately. Rather than creating a negative confrontation with large group of people who were all drinking we just moved away to somewhere else and continued to enjoy ourselves. The other thing to mention on the Lido was the morning show with the cruise director on the big screen. It's very loud it becomes so annoying we gave up and ate inside. The food is good reasonably priced and service was great. On the last night we were having a coffee on 5 mid, bravo bravo port side came over the speakers so we went to see what was going on. It was a crew member that went overboard as everyone knows now but at the time no one knew what was going on. I witnessed another passenger ask a crew member if we had to turn around and go back for him, why couldn't we just leave him behind. That blew me away, I couldn't believe what I heard. The crew member looked at him and then just walked away, that spoke louder than words. Makes you wonder about this world these days.... Disembarking was smooth and easy. The hard part was waiting for our shuttle as there were so many getting on and off. As much as we like the Magic, Galveston is expensive for us to travel to and from Canada. The next cruise we are currently planning will be out of Florida. For those who live close or easily commute without taking a loan out on airfare will enjoy Galveston & the Magic!
Carnival Magic Cruises to the Western Caribbean
Overall Ratings
  • Cabin
  • Dining
  • Embarkation
  • Enrichment Activities
  • Entertainment
  • Family & Children
  • Fitness & Recreation
  • Onboard Experience
  • Public Rooms
  • Rates
  • Service
  • Shore Excursions
  • Value for Money

Cabin review: Deluxe Ocean View

This stateroom is not for those who get motion sickness as it's close to the bow of the ship. Lots of storage for clothes and luggage. Two bathrooms one with a toilet both with showers. You can hear the shows from the showtime theatre above at night. Would hear sporadically a mechanical motor type sound, we think it was from the show theatre above. Otherwise it was fairly quiet.

Port and Shore Excursions

In Cozumel we decided to just stroll around the pier and do a little shopping. Lots of stores to browse in and lots of unique things to find, just watch the pricing and you can barter with most vendors. We ate lunch at Pancho's Backyard on the pier and it was fantastic! Had Margaritas, quesadillas, burritos, tortillas with homemade guacamole & salsa all really good. Then went back to the ship early and went swimming. Great way to end the day!!
Read 4,590 Cozumel Reviews
Island Tour
Not for kids, they will get bored. Enjoyed the sights of the island, guide very knowledgeable. Turtle farm, Tortuga Rum, & Hell stops very interesting. Really enjoyed this excursion.
Stingray Swim
Tour left 1/2 late for unknown reasons, rushed through, only had a 1/2 hr in water, too many people in the water, could not get close enough to see, touch or feed stingrays. Will not go on this excursion again.
Beach Break
Irie Mon Beach Party Pros: great food, drinks, beach & music. Cons: garbage (beer bottles, plastic cutlery hair bands etc) on the ocean floor & on the coral, aggressive vendors that are overpriced on the beach.
Published 03/02/12
No Helpful Votes
Read Cruise Critic’s Carnival Magic Review
Carnival Magic Cruises to the Western Caribbean
Share feedback
Thank you!  Cruise Critic values your feedback.
How can we improve this page?