Subscribe today
Get Cruise Critic in your inbox
Your Ultimate Cruise Guide

Carnival Victory Cruise Review by Rob&Bonnie: Red Solo cup tour


Rob&Bonnie
2 Reviews
Member Since 2003
0 Posts

Member Rating

Cabin 4.0
Dining 2.0
Embarkation 5.0
Enrichment Activities Not Rated
Entertainment 2.0
Family & Children Not Rated
Fitness & Recreation 1.0
Public Rooms 3.0
Rates 5.0
Service 4.0
Shore Excursions Not Rated
Value for Money 5.0

Compare Prices on Carnival Victory Eastern Caribbean Cruises

Red Solo cup tour

Sail Date: February 2012
Destination: Eastern Caribbean
Embarkation: San Juan

Pre cruise -- Stayed at the Fairfield Inn, Windsor Locks CT to take advantage of the park/sleep/fly pre flight. Hotels was adequate for a one night stay. Nothing fancy or special, but it was clean and felt safe. Took the shuttle to the airport at 5:30 am and breezed through checking our bags and security. Flight left on time and arrived in Puerto Rico at 12:30.
We had booked through Hotwire at the Intercontinental for both the pre and post night cruise stays with rates of $115 for one night, $130 for the other. I was not overly impressed with hotel -- I found it on the noisy side, and the staff seems a little put out when they see you booked through Hotwire. I also found that the hotel seemed to have inconsistent pricing at the bars - so be careful to check which bar charges what price if you stay there.
Our room was not ready, so we headed to the pool with the promise of a phone call when it was. The phone call never came, and the staff person at the check in desk More was a bit rude when my husband went to check at 4:00 as the reservation was in my name. The fact that we had checked in with his ID and credit card didn't seem to matter to her, so I had to come up and wait in line AGAIN to get the room. We showered and dressed, then headed to Ruth's Chris Steakhouse for dinner. This is a VERY PRICEY restaurant, but the meal and service were fantastic. This was our splurge dinner for the trip, and we had a great night.
Check out in the morning was quick, and we headed to the ship at around 11 am.
Check in
Check in went very quickly, Carnival staff was very friendly and efficient. As I was not announced as their bazillion customer and winner of a free cruise, we handed over our credit card and got what we affectionately call our 'drink & sink' card. We browsed through the duty free store looking for soda, but they didn't have what we wanted so we found seats to wait for boarding.
A quick note -- we had ordered booze through the Bon Voyage department to avoid the smuggling hassle. While it was pricey, it was worth it in my opinion. I'm diabetic, so the drink of the day doesn't work me, and most of the mixers are a problem as well. Unfortunately we could not find diet tonic to mix with our Vodka -- they don't seem to sell it anywhere in Puerto Rico -- we bought some Chrystal light lemonade instead. It was nice to not worry that someone would give me the wrong thing when they are busy.
Boarding began at a little after noon, and went pretty quickly. We had checked all but our backpacks with bathing suits and high risk items (jewelry, medications, cameras), so we headed up to the Lido deck and secured the deck chairs for the afternoon and took turns changing into bathing suits and grabbing a plate of food. We then settled in our chairs with our lunch and commenced people watching.
We had an active roll call and had decided to have a "Red Solo Cup" theme for our group. Being prepared, we broke out the red solo cups that we had packed -- including the ones we had attached to headbands. Yes, we looked goofy, but we had fun ? By the time the Superbowl started, we had about a dozen Roll call people together -- it was a great way to start the trip! Added to that -- we are GIANTS FANS!!!!
Our room:
We were in room 2348 on the main deck. The room was in a great location, very convenient to the Lido deck, dining rooms and debarkation area. The room was clean for the most part, though there are some improvements that could be made. One is that the showers really need some treatment for the tile grout. I know they are in tropical climates, but some Tilex occasionally could be helpful. The Victory also seems to have some problem with the water in the toilets -- every toilet on the ship had a black ring around the bowl, which made all of the bathrooms look dirty. I actually left a couple of bathrooms thinking they needed cleaning until I realized they were ALL that way. The room steward was invisible, and for the most part good. We had to ask him to refill the ice a couple of times, but other than that things were fine.
The ship:
Besides the black toilet ring issue, the ship was clean and NOT smoky (this is a big improvement over last years trip). Tables and food areas were constantly being cleaned, and staff were very attentive.
Entertainment on the ship was not the greatest. The dance shows were boring (lots of scantily clad women with terrible choreography) and the singers -- the female singer was downright bad, the gentleman could at least carry at tune, but wasn't great. The best show of the week was the one with the guests from the Karaoke contest -- most of them were really good.
A couple of our new Cruise Critic friends were great at Karaoke, so we spent some time there over the week. I have to say that it's the best in the black & red lounge, where the room is smaller and you feel like it's a party. I didn't think it was as much fun in the Adriatic Lounge -- then it was like a show and not as interactive. The one criticism I have of the Karaoke was the staff person (Kim), who spent a lot of time trying to impress one of the passengers to the point of it being uncomfortable for both the object of his attention and the rest of us. I think someone might have complained, as after a couple of days we noticed a couple of ship officers watching the show from outside the lounge -- which sent Kim into quite a tizzy when he realized he was being watched. The next night someone else was running Karaoke....
In addition, we threw our minimal amount into the casino, losing our budget within a short time as usual. And we played a little trivia here and there, watched the ice carving and hairy chested man contest, not so newlywed game -- there was enough to keep us amused ?
Food:
I have to say that this area is where I see the most decline over past Carnival cruises (this was trip #7). The Lido buffets leave a lot to be desired, with a lot of food that should be hot that is lukewarm at best. Breakfast is only saved by the omelet station, where they will also make you fried eggs if you ask. This sure beats the powdered scrambled eggs -- those are just nasty. Lunch was pretty boring, and while we found things to eat, it wasn't the best. We only had one sea day, and ate in port for most lunches and just had snacks back on board.
For dinner we had anytime dining, which we love. We usually ate around 6:30, and never had to wait. Had a table for 2 the first night, then met some of our Cruise Critic friends for other nights, with the group ranging from 6-10. Service in the dining room was outstanding, we were very well taken care of. The food -- well, I've had better. Nothing I had was 'bad' -- just not as good as it used to be. Less


Read more Carnival Victory cruise reviews >>
Read Cruise Critic's Carnival Victory Review >>

Cabin review: Carnival Victory Oceanview Main 2348

Great location for the cabin, very convenient for getting around the ship easily. Adjoining cabin door made it too easy to hear the people next door, we will avoid adjoining cabins in the future. Life vests were stored in a cabinet under the TV, which leaves more closet space - that was very nice. Cabin had a comfortable couch and small (somewhat useless) table.

Port and Shore Excursions


we had rain in the morning, so we decided to take an island tour which was pretty boring. It was supposed to be a 3 hour tour, with us being dropped off at the Boatyard beach after. The driver just kept finding just one more photo opp that we needed to stop for (yawn), so we were more than ready to hit the beach after hour 4. We actually got out of the cab and walked the half mile down the beach on one such stop so that we could get some beach time in. Boatyard was great as usual, we met some of our Cruise Critic friends there and after swimming for a while headed up to the bar for a couple of drinks to end the day.
Read 704 Barbados Reviews

For some reason, St Kitts is always an adventure for us, and this year was no different. We had decided to head out to Friars Beach for the day, and joined a group of about 8 others who were going to Cockleshell for the cab ride out. After loading up the van, the driver proceeded to make a 28 point turn to get out of the parking lot, then drove at a pace that was slower than most people walk. Before leaving the dock area, he suddenly jammed the van into park (without stopping first), grinding the gears and throwing the front seat passengers almost through the windshield. He then opened the door, looked out, closed the door and said "sorry, sorry" and started moving forward again. We looked at each other uneasily at this point, thinking there may have been a problem with the van. A little down the road the driver once again throws it in park (we had braced ourselves this time) and apologizes again. When DH asked if he was alright, the driver proceeded to pull out a gallon size zip lock bag of pills and tossed a couple down saying 'I didn't want to do this, but I have to take some pain pills'. At this point we are out of the ship area and worried about how to get back if we got out of the cab. The driver started moving again, and for a third time stopped abruptly. At this point he agreed it would probably be best if DH drove the rest of the way to the beach and moved over to the passenger side of the van. DH moved into the driver's seat -- much to the relief of the other passengers. We just had to keep reminding him to drive on the other side of the road, and he kept turning on the windshield wipers instead of signal lights, but at least he wasn't hopped up on pills.... Ours was the first stop, and one of the other passengers was quick to jump in the driver's seat for the rest of the trip -- no one was interested in the cab driver getting back behind the wheel. Unfortunately we didn't think of it, but we should have asked for tips -- it's customary to tip the driver, right? A missed opportunity.... Had a good day at Friars, lots of wave riding and sunbathing, then headed back to port and poked around the shops before re boarding.

St Lucia -- this was the only place we had pre planned an excursion with Spencer Ambrose. We took the land and sea tour, starting with a van trip around the island. We've been to most of the places we visited, but the driver shared a lot of information with us that we had not heard before. We then went to the beach and did a little snorkeling, the boarded a boat for the trip back to the ship. This was interesting as Spencer took us into the different areas and showed us the beach side of where we had visited in the van -- so a two sided view. It was also a fun group of people on the tour, so we enjoyed the island beer and the company along the way.

Headed out to Orient Beach for the day, finding chairs at one of the bars with WiFi and drinks included in the price. Sent a couple of pictures to the jealous friends at work and to the family, then relaxed for a day of people watching. And at Orient Beach, you get to see much more of the people than at most beaches. DH & I have a couple of theories on nude sunbathing. 1) If you can follow the drag marks in the sand back to your beach chair -- please re consider the clothing idea 2) Manscaping can be your friend 3) Matching thong bathing suits? Really? After an enjoyable day at the beach, we headed back to town and did a little shopping. Shopping in St Martin is by far the most high pressure of the islands and the area is a little seedy, which starts to annoy me in a short amount of time. So we didn't spend much time in town. We hopped on the water taxi and headed back to port pretty quickly. Before boarding the ship, we made one more stop ?, and found a great sale on a couple of Movado watches that we bought. We don't usually buy much on cruises, but we had looked at these watches at home and knew the price was well below what we'd seen.

Coki Beach. Coki is one of our favorite beaches. If you haven't been there in a while, they have beefed up the security, with a police officer on site. The seas were rough while we were there, and the water level was higher than we've ever seen it. We swam and relaxed on the beach until around 2, headed back to port and poked through a few stores, then headed back on board.
Read 2332 St. Thomas Reviews

Thank You For Signing Up!

Please Note: To ensure delivery of your free e-letters, please add news@cruisecritic.com to your address book.
We're committed to protecting your privacy and will not rent or sell your e-mail address. By proceeding, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.