Subscribe today
Get Cruise Critic in your inbox
Your Ultimate Cruise Guide

Norwegian Gem Cruise Review by ammagic: Three Gems is Enough


ammagic
7 Reviews
Member Since 2008
43 Posts

Member Rating

Cabin 5.5
Dining 3.0
Embarkation 4.0
Enrichment Activities Not Rated
Entertainment 3.0
Family & Children Not Rated
Fitness & Recreation 1.0
Public Rooms 4.0
Rates 4.0
Service 2.0
Shore Excursions Not Rated
Value for Money Not Rated

Compare Prices on Norwegian Gem Eastern Caribbean Cruises

Three Gems is Enough

Sail Date: January 2012
Destination: Eastern Caribbean
Embarkation: New York (Manhattan)

We booked our Eastern Caribbean cruise on the NCL GEM this year for the January 18th sailing. We had taken "family cruises" on the Gem in 2009 and again in 2010. This trip was with some family and 4 couples from my Yacht Club. Three of these couples had never cruised before. Having 15 cruises under my belt before I had been extolling the joys of cruising at my club and organized a "club cruise". My wife and I were anxious to see the faces of the "first timers" when they saw what a cruise ship looked like up close.
The embarkation was a snap. We arrived at the pier a bit after noon and went through security and the boarding procedure without too much standing on line. The "life boat" drill went quickly. It helps not to have to bring the life jackets to the drill. I'm not sure a walk to your lifeboat station on deck wouldn't be a good idea. The ship was clean and as always the room was clean and the room steward was a pleasure to deal with. Our first cruise on the Gem in 2009 was More one of our best. The ship was clean, the food great, and the service excellent. In 2010 it seemed the ship wasn't as clean as it had been before and the times for food available without room service seemed shorter. Of course the "Blue Lagoon" was available but that can be less then great at times. The favorite spot late night had been outside behind the Garden Buffet on the stern. You could sit outside and grab a light snack. This year it seemed the ship was again clean. The problem this year was food service in general. We ate at the Tequila as a group after making a reservation for eleven at 7:00 PM. We were seated on time and given a sample margarita and menus. Our food orders were taken and then we sat for over 30 minutes. No one even took a drink order. The food, when it came, came meal by meal and the ribs I ordered looked like they were sitting on a plate for 15 minutes before I got them. It seemed getting your food hot was a problem the whole trip. It would be easier to say the only time service was what it should be was at Cagney's. It was obvious the line was trimming down wait staff. Not one time in 10 days did someone ask me if I wanted a drink with dinner. In the Grand Pacific I asked the waitress if I could get a glass of wine and she rolled her eyes and said "What kind do you want". I had seen the episode of Undercover Boss on TV where Kevin Sheehan went on board a NCL ship to see how things were. For those who saw the show you could see he was pretty much useless at everything he did. I believe the man doesn't understand much besides how to wring every dollar out of a business. It is said he has increased the lines profits but at what cost. The food is generally cheaper cuts of meat and fish. The service has gotten less then one would expect at a decent restaurant. I realize running a cruise line is not a hobby but a business and there are stockholders etc. but isn't the idea to be treated well on vacation? The last great show was debarkation. We were scheduled to leave the ship at 10:00 AM. The Jewel had pulled in before us. This happens every two weeks. They held us up claiming "customs" wouldn't allow too many people on the pier at one time. This didn't stop "big Ken" from calling all guests with yellow and white tags and "walk offs" to disembark. We stood on a line that went from the mid ship elevators to the gift shop and back to the rear of the main lobby for 30 minutes. We didn't get to the pier till 11:40. I travel out of New York to avoid airports. Maybe they are no so bad. Our "first timers" thought that cruising was great and the ship was beautiful. They did give me an occasional "look" regarding service but it seemed only the repeat cruisers realized how bas it had gotten. Less

Read more Norwegian Gem cruise reviews >>
Read Cruise Critic's Norwegian Gem Review >>

Cabin review: Norwegian Gem Oceanview Stateroom with Balcony Deck Eight 10120

Cabin 10120. Mid-ship balcony. Standard cabin. A bit small after being in a Mini-suite. Not much in the flat space catagory to put things down. I prefer the BB cabins further aft. Closer to the stairway/elevators and buffet. Mini-suites are worth the extra bucks if you can afford it.

Port and Shore Excursions


This one is getting worse. The poverty is depressing. We went to Dickerson's Beach. The side near the ship was fine last year. This year they took us to the other side beyond the Sandals Resort. It was crowded and had too many folks trying to sell me things. I understand it has to be hard trying to make a living on a poor island. I try to help when I can but I'm on VACATION. I spent 3 grand to sit on a beach for a few hours in January. This one wasn't worth it.
Read 799 Antigua Reviews

Still not sure what the point is. There is a CVS drug store close by, maybe that's it.
Read 1358 San Juan Reviews

The main reason for the cruise. A nice island, a water taxi and a nice beach. Shopping one block back and food at the beach. Two chairs, an umbrella and a bucket of beer delivered for $20. Can't beat that.

Always a nice spot. We stop at the Blue Kahoona for Nachos and Corona's. A good jewelry store or two near by. Cardon's is best. Also good for cigarettes. Nice shops at the pier if you don't want to take a trip into town.
Read 2321 St. Thomas Reviews

A pretty little island. Unfortunately the last stop so a short stay. No time to take the tour to the other side and still get to Pussers. The little shops in town are fun. Love the chickens with the chicks following behind. The "security" folks are a pain in the butt. "No smoking in the compound", "Stay on the sidewalk". Give me a break. Someone should make the jerk with the mule go away. Even for an animal, life should be more then standing in a parking lot tied to a pole in the sun.
Read 501 Tortola Reviews

Thank You For Signing Up!

Please Note: To ensure delivery of your free e-letters, please add news@cruisecritic.com to your address book.
We're committed to protecting your privacy and will not rent or sell your e-mail address. By proceeding, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.