Subscribe today
Get Cruise Critic in your inbox
Your Ultimate Cruise Guide

Norwegian Pearl Cruise Review by surfacebreeze: NCL drops a notch


surfacebreeze
1 Review
Member Since 2012
0 Posts

Member Rating

Cabin 4.0
Dining 2.0
Embarkation 5.0
Enrichment Activities 4.0
Entertainment 3.0
Family & Children 3.0
Fitness & Recreation 4.0
Public Rooms 4.0
Rates 4.0
Service 2.0
Shore Excursions 5.0
Value for Money 4.0

Compare Prices on Norwegian Pearl Western Caribbean Cruises

NCL drops a notch

Sail Date: December 2011
Destination: Western Caribbean
Embarkation: Miami

We last took a cruise with NCL a bit over 2 years ago on the Jewel and we liked the experience a lot.
Last year we took a cruise on Royal Caribbean and at the time we thought we would always choose Royal Caribbean over NCL in the future. But, time passed and we found an NCL ship / itinerary / price we were happy with and we jumped on it. After the first day the difference was obvious and we were disappointed we hadn't stuck to our previous decision not to return to NCL.

Worse - NCL has actually dropped substantially in our estimation from our experience 2 years ago.

The ship is very nice although the decor is a bit psychedelic - shouldn't be a surprise if you've been on NCL before but we had forgotten just how bright the colours were - not a terrible thing, just different.

The biggest surprises came in the areas of food and service. Now Freestyle sounds like a no brainer great thing but it never really lives up to its marketing hype.

We actually More loved the designated seating on our last Royal Caribbean cruise (much to our surprise coming off previous cruises on NCL and a bit brainwashed at the time to the benefits of "Freestyle"). Having a fixed time and known table where you meet other couples and bond for the duration ended up being a good thing. Having the same waiter and service staff was fantastic since they quickly grew to know what we liked and had things waiting for us every night. The kids appetizers were often on the table when we arrived since the kids wanted to eat fast so they could get picked up by kids club staff early.
Anyway - I digress - the NCL Freestyle promise is that they offer it all better and with more options. This does not turn out to be the case.
The Buffet is Freestyle - but you have to hunt for a table a peak hours. The two free dinning rooms often had a 30 minute wait at busy times.
The food in the free dinning rooms was below our expectations and memory from just a couple of years ago.
Beyond those free options - you have a number of premium restaurants you can reserve in but they are now all at additional cost and a premium of $20 or $25 dollars per person (plus in some cases other premiums for some menu options) starts to defeat the premise of food being included.
If the premium restaurants were really extraordinary then maybe but we ended up paying premiums most nights because we were disappointed with the free dining options.

The service in all the restaurants - free and premium, was very poor with a couple of notable exceptions but surprisingly the two really attentive servers that we had were both in the free dining rooms - which was a big surprise.

NCL has now gone to Auto Staff Gratuity which means that instead of the guests getting to tip cabin stewards, service staff, etc that really deserve a tip, guests now get charged an automatic $12 per day per person (even for young children over the age of 3) and this gets distributed to the whole service staff.
I hate this model - tips are for people that provide great service to me - not so that I can pay part of the NCL payroll.
The net result of this policy is that the staff is no longer motivated to go out of their way and that was very obvious vs. past NCL cruises and the last Royal Caribbean cruise we were on.

We hardly eve saw our cabin steward and although our cabin was cleaned and serviced properly, in the past we got to know the cabin steward and they went out of their way to earn their merit tip - now that is not the case.

I actually heard the waiter at the table next to us tell the family there that the tip was not included on their dinner tab and when they noticed that there is an "Auto Gratuity" included on drinks etc - the waiter told them that yes there is an auto gratuity but the tip is not included - OK enough about my pet peeve "Auto Gratuity".

My daughters have always loved the kids club on every cruise we have taken but something happened on this one to turn them completely off the kids club staff - my 7 year old was in tears and assured us that nothing bad had happened to her but the staff was not nice and one of the female staff had been really mean to 2 other girls in her group and she didn't want to return.
This is a huge surprise and while I was tempted to complain - one of the best staff members we came in contact with did see her crying about this at a n evening snack and came over to console her later telling us that she was lodging a complaint through her boss.
My girls didn't return to kids club and that was fine by me but knowing how they had always loved kids club on other cruises I was disappointed that they didn't get to enjoy one of their favourite activities.

We travelled with my mom who was using a walker and in this area we did find the staff very helpful and accomodating.

The stop in the Bahamas at NCL's private island retreat of Great Stirrup Cay was excellent - NCL has improved their facilities here a lot and the weather was great for a relaxing beach day.

Unfortunately, at the very end the disembarkation process is still a nightmare that stains most cruises but it was even harder with my mom in a walker - the process kept being halted by customs over several hours due to congestion in the terminal and the line up just to get off the ship and into the next line up in the terminal was a nightmare. This isn't NCL's issue I guess but it sure does close the cruise off on a sour note.

In the end we did have a great holiday (we always do) but we will not take another NCL cruise any time soon, opting instead to go back to Royal Caribbean which we feel is several notches above NCL and not much if any more expensive (or maybe we'll try Princess or Holland America). Less


Read more Norwegian Pearl cruise reviews >>
Read Cruise Critic's Norwegian Pearl Review >>

Cabin review: Norwegian Pearl Oceanview Stateroom with Balcony Deck Eight

Port and Shore Excursions

(5)
Cozumel was a blast - we did the dolphin swim with the kids at Dolphinaris and loved it - spend a small fortune on the pics and DVD afterwards but didn't mind since we had such a great time. Strolled down the strip afterwards to shop and have lunch at the Palmeras restaurant just past the Cartier store - after 2 of the biggest and best margaritas I've ever had (which was really 1 too many but they were sooo good) - we staggered back to the boat and confirmed that Cozumel is still one of the best cruise ship stops.
Read 1069 Reviews

Grand Caymen was awesome - George Town is great to walk - lots of nice places to eat / shop. We took a 1.5 hour tour of the Island down the Seven Mile hotel stretch to the quaint little town of Hell and mailed ourselves a postcard for fun. Stopped at the Turtle farm and the Dolphin aquarium. On the way back we had the driver drop us off at the Royal Palms private beach along the Seven Mile beach stretch. $2 to get in and use all the facilities which is a great deal. We had grouper sandwiches for lunch at the beach bar and sipped rum drinks until we had to bolt to catch the ship. Beautiful!

Ocho Rios in Jamaica was the same as previous times I've been there (although it continues to grow) - once you've disembarked here once and climbed Dunn's River Falls - you may be tempted to stay on the ship next time. We went ashore and visited again but many passengers did just stay onboard. Not our favourite port but not bad.

Thank You For Signing Up!

Please Note: To ensure delivery of your free e-letters, please add news@cruisecritic.com to your address book.
We're committed to protecting your privacy and will not rent or sell your e-mail address. By proceeding, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.