Subscribe today
Get Cruise Critic in your inbox
Your Ultimate Cruise Guide

Carnival Magic Cruise Review by rpearlman: Carnival Magic - Overall a good time


rpearlman
1 Review
Member Since 2012
0 Posts

Member Rating

Cabin 4.0
Dining 4.0
Embarkation 4.0
Enrichment Activities 3.0
Entertainment 3.0
Family & Children 4.0
Fitness & Recreation 5.0
Public Rooms 4.0
Rates 4.0
Service 4.0
Shore Excursions 3.0
Value for Money 4.0

Compare Prices on Carnival Magic Mexican Riviera Cruises

Carnival Magic - Overall a good time

Sail Date: December 2011
Destination: Mexican Riviera
Embarkation: Galveston

What's not to love about the fact that Carnival is taking the port of Galveston seriously by putting in their newest and biggest ship there? While I've been on cruises out of Galveston, LA, Florida and New Orleans, it's nice to have a port with a new ship where I can drive there - I've usually felt that I had to compromise on the ship or the destination to be so close to home (Dallas), but not this time.

The setup:
This cruise was for our family of 5. Our three sons are 13, 10 and 7.

About the ship:
The Carnival Magic feels like all of the other Carnival ships that I've been on - just slightly larger. The kids really loved the sports court and the water slides. It was a big hit for the days we were at sea. My wife really loved the adults only area that was like an escape, and I enjoyed the many different seating options that aren't available on other Carnival ships that were way more comfortable than the standard lounge chairs.

The overall deck plan is More almost identical to other Carnival ships I've been on with the promenade deck providing the main thoroughfare for afternoon and night-time activities. The Lido deck served as the 24/7 food deck along with the fun, sun and swimming.

We planned late, so we ended up with 2 internal staterooms. Overall, the rooms were nice and spacious. My wife and I shared a cabin with a king bed and the kids next door had twin beds (two on the floor and 1 fold out from the wall.) The rooms were fine, nothing great. My only complaint was that we didn't get any light in the mornings - so if I didn't set an alarm, we probably could have slept forever.

About the food:
Food-wise, this was very comparable to other Carnival trips I've been on. The one really nice addition was an Indian buffet station. The food was really good, and my older son and I ate at it a lot! And, because it's a buffet, my other sons and wife were willing to try it all. We ended up with the early seating for dinner because we registered late, but it looked like a great idea to use the flexible dining option instead. We had a lot of friends that were using flexible dining, so we ended up trading our table 2 nights (the staff was very accommodating to us).

Conclusion:
Overall, this was a nice trip. The ports weren't great (except Cozumel), the food was good and the on-board activities were nice.

Good:
The ship is nice, and it feels great to be on a new ship.
Cozumel!
Indian buffet was a nice addition to the food lineup
Red Frog Pub and other dining options (we didn't do it ourselves, but heard lots of raves)

Bad:
The scheduling on Magic was not up to par with other trip we've been on- we had to rush to finish dinner, and by being "on-time" we often had poor seats.
The cruise director (James) was by far, the worst I've experienced on Carnival. He wasn't funny, ran late for a number of events, and didn't seem to be as available as others.

Recommended? Yes
You can't beat going out of Galveston, and Magic is a really nice ship. I'm hoping they work out some of the kinks of scheduling and the cruise staff. Less


Read more Carnival Magic cruise reviews >>
Read Cruise Critic's Carnival Magic Review >>

Cabin review: Carnival Magic Interior Upper 9144

Great access to the Lido deck for food. Being at the back of the ship, you felt the movement a bit more.

Port and Shore Excursions


Costa Maya - we treated this as our "adventure day". We had no plans, so we just got off the ship and decided to do whatever looked fun. We ended up renting a gas powered golf cart for a few hours and used it to go around the beach area and little port town. The kids had fun driving, and we got a little wet and muddy (fun!) as we drove around. There really is little to see/do in the port town, and the beaches didn't look that great. Overall, I didn't like the port much, but we did have fun.

Cozumel - we've been here many times, so we just got off the boat and took a taxi to Chakanaub which is an all inclusive beach. (We normally go to Mr. Sanchez - which I highly recommend, but this time we went with another family that wanted to do the swim with dolphins thing). We had a WONDERFUL time here. There is an amazing under-water cave for SCUBA divers. I did it with my old son, and it was so great, I talked my wife into doing it as well. You have to be certified for the dive, but it was great - HIGHLY HIGHLY recommended.
Read 3117 Cozumel Reviews

Progresso - we ended up doing a Carnival shore excusion that took us to the town of Meridia followed by a horse show. Overall, this was "meh". The downtown tour wasn't that exciting, though we did see the oldest Cathedral in North America. The horse show / lunch buffet was good - just wasn't very exciting. We talked to a lot of friends that tried to beach in Progresso instead - they HATED it.
Read 284 Progreso Reviews

Thank You For Signing Up!

Please Note: To ensure delivery of your free e-letters, please add news@cruisecritic.com to your address book.
We're committed to protecting your privacy and will not rent or sell your e-mail address. By proceeding, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.