My wife and I are seasoned cruisers and sail primarily with RCCL and Celebrity. Anytime we have our choice of sailings that fit into our schedule we will choose Celebrity over all others. In my opinion Celebrity offers the best overall experience for our taste.
Embarkation gets an A - From the time we got to the port until we stepped on the ship took all of about 15 minutes. Quick and painless. The embarkation agent was very friendly and made us feel welcome.
Food gets an A - Celebrity food is always good. Some dishes are not as good as others but overall it's above the other major cruise lines. The Olympic Restaurant was tremendous and worth the $30 charge. I highly recommend it.
This is a great cabin. It's quiet, comfortable, and has a huge balcony.