We booked this cruise last minute and got it cheap but if we,d paid full price I would really be annoyed. The ship has clearly been refurbished so the interior was lovely, similar to Azamara Quest. The cabins are as per usual for a balcony cabin but with better than usual outdoor seats. The beds and pillows were very, very firm and this from people with an orthopaedic bed. The bathroom is the usual tiny size (only Silversea has been bigger so far) and the shampoo etc. was good quality. The hair dryer will frizz your hair no matter what but this is normal on ships (I've found).
The food - English, bland and often cold or dry. The toast at breakfast (both venues) was cold, brittle and inedible. The rest was dull, steak n kidney pie, fish n chips, mash etc. The one exception was the curry night in the buffet, this was quite acceptable though a tad over salted for me.
We took to eating off the ship when possible as the formal dining room wasn't for us and you never knew if or when the buffet was open. Room service was speedy but the choice was limited and a few items cost extra ( chicken & bacon sandwich an extra Â£1.50) which we didn't mind but we heard others complaining.
The trips are cheap but a bit dull. Not sure if this was due to us travelling out of season or due to the "typical" P&O passenger. The wine list was good with the usual cruise ship price mark up. The French champagne was reasonable with Veuve Cliquot at Â£37 a bottle.
The entertainment which is not really our thing was hit n miss. They had a scouser on called Rachel something who sang opera and a few show hits, she was very talented. The resident entertainers made me want to rip my ears off, too loud and too screechy but the old folks seemed to like them. There was also a guy called Jimmy James on one night but we didn't go.
The main problem we had was the other passengers. If you like chatting about who's got the lost/worst ailments, swapping stories about grand kids or whinging about everything then you'll love this cruise ship. If however you like nice food, dining as a couple (alone) when and where you like in quiet surroundings then book with some other cruise line.
Just to reiterate one thing, the ship is very nice. I have read reviews saying it was scruffy and this definately not the case.