Carnival Magic 2

“Disappointed in Carnival”
Cruise review of Carnival Magic

Member Since 2009
13 Forum Posts

Overall Member Rating

The Carnival Cruise that needs a lot of work. We have sailed Royal Caribbean3 times before this and MSC was our first cruise ever. We were really looking forward to cruising to the Caribbean. Unfortunately we didn't make it there until Friday, four days after we left Galveston.
As soon as we set sail and were held captive by Carnival, they then decided to give us a letter in our staterooms telling us the ship is broke. It then went on to tell us that instead of going to Costa May(Caribbean), we would be stopping in Progresso (Gulf of Mexico), for two days. Progresso, Mexico is like going on vacation to Jaurez, Mexico with muddy sea water to look at. It is probably one of the worst places to ever go to on vacation. Carnival should be ashamed of themselves for calling it a port, or maybe it explains Carnival as a company. They are the only cruise line that goes there. I would have rather gone to New Orleans or Tampa, both in the Gulf. Carnival should have given everyone the More option to cruise or cruise later when we were checking in. But thank you Carnival for the $25 dollars that you gave us. What a joke.
Now the ship, The stateroom was nice. The beds were comfortable. Balcony is small. The breakfast was good, the main buffet food was not good. Stick to the sandwiches, tandor, hamburgers, hot dogs, and pizza. If you want to wait in line for an hour, the mongolian was good. The water slides were great, pool was dirty, warm tubs were ok. The sport court was cool. Mutzie was the highlight of the entertainment.
The entertainment staff was usually busy putting together the list of 25 daily activities because i hardly ever saw them. The cruise director is more of an announcer of activities.
Overall I would give the ship a C+, but because I now do not like Carnival, I give it a D+. Good job on winning over customers Carnival.
Congratulations to Royal Caribbean for winning a customer for life. Less

Carnival Magic Cruises to the Western Caribbean

Overall Ratings

Sail Date: November 2011
Destination: Western Caribbean
Embarkation: Galveston
Enrichment Activities
Family & Children
Fitness & Recreation
Public Rooms
Shore Excursions
Value for Money

Cabin review: Balcony

Room 6451 is very noisy because of the Vibe being below.

Published 11/23/11

Read Cruise Critic's Carnival Magic Review

Carnival Magic Cruises to the Western Caribbean

Share feedback
Thank you!  Cruise Critic values your feedback.
How can we improve this page?