I have not sailed on Holland America before. It is a much larger ship than I am used to, but quite manageable in a short period of time.
I will not discuss the port cities in this review, although they were wonderful. I will save those comments for individual reviews.
We had three nights in Quebec City at the Auberge St. Antoine which was a delight. We took the 2 and 1/2 hour carriage ride of the city and I highly recommend the tour.
Large cabin, lots of storage space, large veranda, lots of windows, quiet area of ship, not close to Neptune Lounge (if you care about that). A more perfect location would be a little closer to mid-ship on Deck 7 (Rotterdam).