I cruised on the Sky from Oct. 21 to 24. My daughter got married on the ship prior to crusing. The line was very accommodating on allowing non-cruising passengers to attend the wedding.
As for the cruise, it was just OK. Our oceanview cabin was smaller than what we are used to being loyal Celebrity customers. The food was average in the main dining room. Our dinner in the Italian restaurant was disappointing as well. Perhaps most noticable in a negative way was that the rooms do not have voicemail or a clock. Having no voicemail made it difficult to communicate with others in our party. We had to rely upon our running into them to make plans.
On the postive side, the comedian was very funny and the crew were exceptionally friendly and helpful, especially Sherene in Customer Relations.
As for the cost/value. Going to the Bahamas adds a great deal more in port charges than most if not all other ports. We purchased a balcony cabin for our daughter and son-in-law. The cost was more for that cabin on a three-day cruise than we are going to be paying for a concierge on our 13-day transatlantic coming up next month on the Solstice.