Let me preface this by saynig my gf and I are in our late 20s/early 30s. She was a first-time cruiser and I have been on a few before. I feel the most helpful way to describe this cruise is to break it up into categories, so here goes...
Room: Always clean and the room stewards were very friendly and did their best to cater to our every need. We had an inside cabin and had the twin-beds turned into a queen. Very comfortable and you could not feel any "seem."
Food: Lets be honest this isnt 4/5 star dining so stop comparing it to that. Room service was very good. Sandwiches, juices, cookies and cake were all tastey. Buffet food was what you would expect. The pizza was OK, my gf and I personally prefer more well-done crust, but it wasnt bad pizza. The NY deli was very good. Dining room food was very good. The staff was incredible. Always greeting you warmly, by name and remembering our drinks.
Room 7177... great location as it was close to the elevators but not near where anyone was "hanging-out." Plus, we had no neighbors to the right (if facing our room) since it was just a storage room. It was just as noisy as any other room, since you will hear the occasion person walkin by or child running down the hallway.