Subscribe today
Get Cruise Critic in your inbox
Your Ultimate Cruise Guide

Crown Princess Cruise Review by lenanbette: Nothing Better than Quebec to New York


lenanbette
2 Reviews
Member Since 2011
0 Posts

Member Rating

Cabin 4.0
Dining 5.5
Embarkation 5.0
Enrichment Activities 5.5
Entertainment 5.5
Family & Children Not Rated
Fitness & Recreation 1.0
Public Rooms 4.0
Rates 4.0
Service 5.5
Shore Excursions Not Rated
Value for Money 4.0

Compare Prices on Crown Princess Canada & New England Cruises

Nothing Better than Quebec to New York

Sail Date: September 2011
Destination: Canada & New England
Embarkation: Other

We recently returned from our cruise on the Crown Princess departing Quebec City on September 24, 2011, and arriving in New York City on October 4.. There were six of us in our group, all in our mid-seventies. Our staterooms were forward on the starboard side of Plaza, deck 5. After I had convinced our friends that we should take this cruise, I started reading reviews on Cruise Critic, and I also learned that the ship was due for refurbishing three weeks after our trip. I became very apprehensive about having recommended this trip because there were so many negative comments in the reviews and because I was afraid that since the ship was scheduled to be refurbished, it might not be in very good condition.

With that background being laid, I want to stress that NOT ONE of the negatives I read in the reviews was experienced during our wonderful trip, and even though the ship was to be refurbished, we found the ship to be in wonderful condition. Last week the six of us met to More share highlights of our trip. Not one of the six of us had a single complaint. Let me share what we all agreed were highlights.

1. Even though there were 3,000 passengers, we never felt that the ship was too crowded. We never had trouble finding a place to sit in the Horizon Court buffet; the two tender ports were handled as smoothly as anyone could hope for; we never had a problem moving from one part of the ship to another; we always found a space to sit in the common areas and on the promenade deck where we liked to watch sailing away each afternoon. The only place that was crowded was the Princess Theater for the first show each evening, but we were willing to arrive 30 to 40 minutes early so the six of us always got seats together. It was a great place to wait, relax, visit, people watch, and make new friends.
2. Dining All agreed that the food in the Botticelli dining room where we had traditional dining first setting was outstanding (some would say particularly the desserts!). Enrique and Maja, our waitpersons at table 114, were delightful and super efficient; both of them had wonderful smiles and a cheerful persona. Our orders always came quickly and just as we ordered them. From the first night on, they remembered our individual preferences. For example, I told them the first night I like coffee with my meal and I did not have to ask for that again; they always had it ready. The six of us ate breakfast together in the Horizon Court every morning except two when we ate in the main dining room. The food at the buffet was more than adequate and the variety was good. Made to order omelets and rice pudding every morning were big hits. The International Caf provided an excellent option for a light snack when we needed a bit of lunch or a refresher after our day on shore.
3. Entertainment All three of the main production shows were very well done with wonderful costumes, staging, and lighting effects (although the third one seemed a bit more disjointed than the first two). Ray Cousins, a former pianist for Frank Sinatra, had one performance in the Princess Theater, and Mark Preston, formerly with the Letterman, had two shows in that theater. These shows were at the top of our list of highlights for the trip. Ray Cousins performed nightly in Crooners Lounge, and Indigo performed in various venues throughout the trip. They, along with the pianist in the Adagio Lounge, were outstanding.
4. Ports of Call All nine of our ports were wonderful, but the unanimous consensus of our group is that Quebec City, Halifax, Saint John, Newport, and New York were the top of our highlight list. We did not take advantage of any of the tours provided by Princess, but we did a lot of research before the trip and had our personal walking tours planned before we went. One tip for Saint John we discovered that the city transit system provides a two hour tour on a city bus for $20.00 per person. We found this tour near the Market Place a few blocks from the ship. The driver/guide was simply outstanding, and we had a very complete tour of the city including time at the Reversing Tides area. We also took advantage of a 48 hour pass on the Grayline Hop on Hop Off bus in New York City; we purchased our tickets on line for $49 per person. We used the bus to get acquainted with the city, to get to from Times Square where we stayed for two nights at the Hotel Edison to Battery Park for our trip to the Statue of Liberty, to get to the site of the 9/11 Memorial, and to get back from those sites. We rode five or six different segments at different times, and each time we had fascinating guides that told us so much interesting information about the city with each guide having a different area of interest/expertise that made it all the more interesting.
5. Embarkation/disembarkation Both of these events could not have gone more easily or efficiently.

All in all the six of us making this trip together would rate it 10 on a scale of 10! Less


Read more Crown Princess cruise reviews >>
Read Cruise Critic's Crown Princess Review >>

Cabin review: Crown Princess P211

Everything was fine with the cabin except the configuartion was not as shown in the diagram on the Princess web site: the web site showed the bed coming from a side wall with a chair under the window. In actuality the head of the bed was under the window so you had to kneel on the bed to see out the window. There was more than adequate storage. The bathroom was just like on all of the ships we have been on - small but very adequate. Being on the Plaza deck near the Atrium was a huge plus.

Port and Shore Excursions


The weather was nasty on our day here so we did not go in as it was a tender stop. However, we have been here on two previous cruises and feel that the free shuttle to Acadia National Park is a huge plus.

Boston is a great stop - but the cruise terminal is a long way from the historic area and even with the $15.00 shiuttle arranged by Princess there was not enough time to really enjoy this city. A longer time needs to be spent here. Maybe Sydney could be by-passed and more time spent in Boston. Our time at Old North Church for a Sunday worship service, a NPS Ranger presentation at Faneuil Hall, and lunch at the Cheers at Faneuil Market Place made the day worthwhile.
Read 223 Boston Reviews

A downside here was that instead of docking in the main terminal area, we were docked in an containerized cargo area and had to be shuttled to the main terminal. Other than that, it is a fantastic stop - the maritime museuem, the waterfront, the Citidel, the public gardens, the historic cemetaries, walk up fish and chips on the dock. Our personal walking tour showed us a lot.
Read 353 Halifax Reviews

We stayed at the Hotel Edison in Times Square for two nights. The use of Grayline Hop On Hop Off added immensely to our stay as we used it to learn to know the city and to get to the 9/11 Memorial and to Battery Park for our trip to the Statue of Liberty and Ellis Island. The availability of SUV's that could handle six people and their luggage was a real plus at the Brooklyn Terminal

A visit to the church that was the site of the Kennedy wedding, a visit to Trinity Church, and lunch at the White Horse Tavern made our day. Another great city for doing your own thing - walking to see what you want to see.
Read 125 Newport Reviews

Easy access from the ship to Old Quebec City is a huge plus. It is just like being in France!!

Thank You For Signing Up!

Please Note: To ensure delivery of your free e-letters, please add news@cruisecritic.com to your address book.
We're committed to protecting your privacy and will not rent or sell your e-mail address. By proceeding, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.