Subscribe today
Get Cruise Critic in your inbox
Your Ultimate Cruise Guide

Disney Magic Cruise Review by VirginiaCruiser75: Not so Magical


VirginiaCruiser75
1 Review
Member Since 2011
0 Posts

Member Rating

Cabin 4.0
Dining 2.0
Embarkation 5.5
Enrichment Activities 2.0
Entertainment 2.0
Family & Children 3.0
Fitness & Recreation 3.0
Public Rooms 3.0
Rates 1.0
Service 5.0
Shore Excursions 2.0
Value for Money 1.0

Compare Prices on Disney Magic Western Caribbean Cruises

Not so Magical

Sail Date: September 2011
Destination: Western Caribbean
Embarkation: Port Canaveral

After spending twice what a "regular cruise" would cost I had some increased expectations for this cruise. My wife and I cruised Carnival on the Miracle a few years ago and that was a great value for what we got. The Disney loses every category hands down to Carnival except Disney has Mickey and the characters for the kids. That is the ONLY thing this cruise has going for it better than any other cruise. The service is fine which is what you expect on any cruise. The staterooms were nice and well kept but again you expect that and they were not anything spectacular. The ship feels small and the pools are very small and very very crowded with kids but my kids had a good time there. The food is just horrible. You have been warned here. There are a couple places you can get hamburgers, hot dogs, and pizza just about any time you want. AVOID unless you just have to have something to eat. The quality of this food is gas station quality. There are also buffets for breakfast and lunch. Again More food here is well below Sunday buffet quality at your local buffet. Very generic and low quality mass produced. Dinner is in a nice dining room and the servers are excellent. I have mixed reviews about dinner. We had 7 nights of dining and 4 were very good. However even the best meal I had on the Magic was not near as good as every night with Carnival. Again nothing special. The 3 bad nights of dinner if served at a local restaurant I wouldn't go back. The special nights where desserts were served late were also a disappointment. Food looks great and is presented well but tastes very generic and cheap like the pies you buy at the grocery store.

Entertainment on the ship was just ok. There were a couple of comedians that were funny and the Disney shows were good for the kids. We skipped the show a couple of nights because the Disney stuff gets old after a few nights even for the kids. There is no Casino which is probably good because of the family atmosphere they try to promote. The bars on this ship are in one word BORING. We were traveling with my wife's parents so we had people to watch the kids at night (we tried the Disney programs for the kids one night but they were bored to death) but the bars were mostly empty and had nothing going on. The sports bar diversions was the biggest joke on the ship. There were no sports. They had televisions everywhere but NO SPORTS. When questioned which I did several times the answer I got was that there was no signal or that they couldn't get ESPN due to contracts. This made no sense to me since Disney OWNES ESPN. All that was on was a few soccer games broadcasted from European networks.. No baseball, no college football, NFL or anything. I felt sorry for the workers here because the place was empty every night. The servers in there were great to talk to but this was supposed to be a sports bar. There were many many angry complaints made here because of this.

The excursions offered by Disney are all overpriced. My suggestion is to get off of the ship and look for a local excursion provider that will give you the same thing for half the price. Do not take any Disney excursions that are only transportation. Example, taxi ride at st. thomas is $16 round trip per person to Magens Bay. If you take Disney they charge you $42.

My kids are ages 7 and 8. They had a great time getting pictures and autographs with the characters but the lines were crazy. Princess night wait times were around 2 hours! As I said before this was the ONLY thing Disney has going for it. If you really want to see the characters I suggest you do Disney World for a day and save $3,000.

Overpriced and Under-delivered is the best way to describe this entire experience. We had a good time because we were all together. Disney however did not enhance this time we had one bit. We would have had just as good of a time on a much cheaper cruise with much better food. It was a lesson we learned and I know people will still go on Disney and give it great reviews because of the allure of Disney itself, but if you look at each aspect of the cruise and compare it to other options it is not worth the cost at all. Less


Read more Disney Magic cruise reviews >>
Read Cruise Critic's Disney Magic Review >>

Cabin review: Disney Magic Standard Inside Stateroom Deck Five 2581

Good sized cabin for 4. No window. Good location at mid ship. Room was very quiet at night.

Port and Shore Excursions


We went to orient beach (caution clothing is optional on this side of the island) and the beach was covered in nasty seaweed. The locals here said a storm washed in the mess and it hadn't been cleaned up. It was nasty. We did have a good time at this beach though because our host on the beach took good care of us. There are many locals walking the beach trying to sell you things which gets very annoying. This beach is not well developed so the area is rough so if you want refinement avoid this place.


We really enjoyed St. Thomas. We took a taxi to Magens Bay and it is beautiful there. Go early to avoid the crowd and get a good spot with some shade. This was the best time of the entire cruise. Shopping at St. Thomas is also very good with many many selections. We just ran out of time to explore them all.

Read 2333 St. Thomas Reviews

Thank You For Signing Up!

Please Note: To ensure delivery of your free e-letters, please add news@cruisecritic.com to your address book.
We're committed to protecting your privacy and will not rent or sell your e-mail address. By proceeding, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.