Subscribe today
Get Cruise Critic in your inbox
Your Ultimate Cruise Guide

Carnival Magic Cruise Review by baggins11: 7 Great Mediterranean Cities to explore


baggins11
1 Review
Member Since 2011
0 Posts

Member Rating

Cabin 5.0
Dining 3.0
Embarkation 4.0
Enrichment Activities Not Rated
Entertainment 3.0
Family & Children Not Rated
Fitness & Recreation Not Rated
Public Rooms 4.0
Rates 4.0
Service 3.0
Shore Excursions Not Rated
Value for Money 4.0

Compare Prices on Carnival Magic Europe - Western Mediterranean Cruises

7 Great Mediterranean Cities to explore

Sail Date: June 2011
Destination: Europe - Western Mediterranean
Embarkation: Barcelona

Last week we returned from generally a great cruise on the Carnival Magic to Monaco and Italy including the star Venice and Dubrovnik. Having never wanting to cruise at all until bullied by my wife last December I am now a very ardent fan of cruising. I use to believe that cruising was Butlins at sea (All Brits will understand for others like a holiday camp with games to play and none stop tannoy announcements but i now find this is definitely not the case on the now 3 cruise companies we have used (the other two being RCL and Norwegian) and really all are very professional and well organised). Its just the exceptional that makes the difference and that's the reason for penning this note. We did initially think the itinerary strange having four straight days of port calls, going to Rome before Florence from Monaco and then back to Naples before a sea day. Only on this fifth day at sea with lovely weather did we fully understand how busy and crowded this ship was. We were told in More excess of 4000 people were cruising on-board when the ship has a quoted capacity of 3700.

With so many people we found it difficult to get a decent seat which wasn't by an air-vent or noisy pool area and people did persist in saving loungers with towels and books etc even though they are asked not to, but who wants a confrontation when they are on holiday. This is something i think all cruise lines have a problem with. The general facilities on the ship were excellent and varied, but we found the staff (particularly the guys in whites) mainly Eastern European very surly and none communicative and lacking any idea of customer service. Other members of staff then shone out, like all the stateroom staff we chatted too were extremely helpful and pleasant our dinner service team were always friendly and had time to speak.

We nightly went to the Red Frog Pub, again some of the staff were excellent. But does it require so many waiters to run a small bar?? Our main reason for going was to watch the very excellent guitarist/vocalist Danny Black, who we believe is wasting his talents just playing on board a ship, particularly as he had to finish each evening by midnight because of noise levels in the staterooms. For a new ship this has to be a design fault with a number of other areas like the piano bar and Italian restaurant having unacceptable noise levels coming through the floor/ceiling. We did go to some of the shows and to see all the other entertainment offering on board most were very average and we thought this also of the cringe giving John Heald whose tannoy announcements reminded us very much of the dreaded holiday camp, his previous life obviously Hi di Hi John !!!

Compared to our two previous cruises the daily information sheet was abysmal, it was never consistent with its placement of information with unnecessary duplication and notable omissions. Somebody really does need to revamp this very important sheet for all passengers to get the very best out of the ships excellent facilities. One daily omission was for us the best food on board which was the Tandoori bar which only served food between 1.30pm & 2.30pm again why we don't know. This was a really fabulous eatery with authentic Indian cooking ovens. Carnival you missed a trick here it should have been used for a greater time in the day and advertised more. But for all that we enjoyed it on several days because of the lack of customers. The other good places to eat on board were the excellent free lunchtime Italian restaurant and most of the evening dinners we had in the fixed dining Southern Lights. The not so good was the Marketplace Buffet style, the seating was good with sectioned booths, but the food was bland and the food service areas were far too cramped with queues at most times. The layout for the food service area again for a new ship was appalling. We tried the Deli once, why does so much meat have to be put on a sandwich the food here was not very good neither was the burger bar which invariable had you waiting around for ages to serve you chicken. But worst of all we thought was the Steakhouse, the food was very average but expensive. But the worst thing about it was the ambiance and what should have been a special dining experience. This didn't happen. The area was cramped and we were seated on a bench seat at the side of some very noisy neighbours who had started dining before us and wanted everybody to know what a good time they were having. This was definitely not worth the additional 30 dollars each.

We didn't take any of the cruise tours which we think are extremely overpriced but prefer anyway to explore places on our own. We usually find the people we meet are extremely friendly and love for you to visit and admire their country and city and are always willing to help and give advice.

The in board stateroom that we had was excellent in size very comfortable with space all round the very large bed plenty of draws and hanging space very well thought out as was the bathroom.

We did get an extremely good deal on this cruise so we will probably cruise with Carnival again but only if RCL are not doing a similar itinerary at a similar price Less


Read more Carnival Magic cruise reviews >>
Read Cruise Critic's Carnival Magic Review >>

Cabin review: Carnival Magic Interior Upper 6409

inside stateroom deck 6 room 6409 plenty of space well laid out full size bed plenty of hanging and draw space bathroom well laid out shower good. The negative was we had vibrations through the walls (assumed the laundry was nearby) and sound noise from one of the entertainment rooms below on deck 5 in the early evening never after our bedtime but that was always late anyway

Port and Shore Excursions


Again we had spent another 10 day holiday exploring Florence so decide to go visit Pisa and Lucca instead. We got a local train from Liverno station to Pisa its only a short ride of about 20 minutes and the trains are regular most of the day. We loved Pisa the walk from the station through the town we thought the best but the grounds that the leaning tower stands in are exceptional. We didn't go up the tower preferring instead to head back to the station and go on to Lucca a lovely small Tuscan town full enclosed buy a wall and it was so lovely just to wonder around the narrow streets and sit at a cafe taking in the surroundings. The trains are fairly cheap and arrive/leave on time but are very busy and crowded

Very picturesque harbour and town and mountain backdrop. The highlight was walking the GP circuit (this takes about 3/4 hour at normal pace) The F1 GP which had taken place just a couple of weeks previously some of the stands where still in place we had watched on TV and seeing all the historic land marks of this great city circuit with the tyre marks of the collisions still fresh on the road. The other plus was walking up to the Royal Palace which was being readied for the upcoming royal wedding and then back down to the port area via the gardens. This is a little steep but still suitable for anybody of normal fitness not just for athletes. The downside is that everything you want to buy is very expensive from a coffee to an ice cream but the ship is always within easy reach from anywhere in Monaco
Read 191 Monaco Reviews

At Naples we visited Pompeii. We always avoid the cruise tours so made our way to the station which is just a short walk through the port gates turning right. Naples is very untidy there apparently is a very big problem with the organisation of the collection of rubbish/garbage and this is everywhere on the streets. Trains are very regular from the main Naples station to Pompeii and it eventually goes on to Sorrento. To Pompeii the train takes about 1 hours and stops about 12 times from the station a short walk takes you to the entrance to the ruins. I think the entrance was 11 euro each and we joined a group with an English speaking guide for another 10 euros each. Guides are always looking for business at the entrance but in our view are well worth the money. We didn't realise how huge the site is the guide was very informative and showed us all the well known landmarks for about 1 half hours when we were free to explore on our own. It was a very hot day so we didn't explore too many other ares before we headed back to Naples and the ship. Next time we will do Sorrento
Read 647 Naples Reviews

We have previously had a 10 holiday in the centre of Rome so preferred to stay on the ship and explore the facilities whilst everybody was ashore

(5.5)
Venice is just fabulous from the entrance at midday on board going past St Marc's to sitting in the square late at night listening to a violinist play whilst you have a very expensive beer (but well worth the 15 euros). There is just so much to see it obviously needs more than 2 days but they were wonderful fun packed days. We walked from the ship out of the port ignored the long queues waiting for the tramway (it was definitely quicker to walk) and headed to Roma square you can buy a canal bus ticket here or quicker walk on to St Marc's over the dozens of bridges down the narrow alleyways and see all the wonderful sites. We went to the Domo Palace as our one must see and this is a place that should never be missed on any visit it includes going over the bridge of seize and some really outstanding rooms. We had always believed that Venice had a bad odour with waste going into the canals. To us this is a myth we didn't find Venice smelt any worse than any other Mediterranean city in June. We did have a meal at a restaurant the food was good but the price was very much inflated by the cost of the drinks of water and beer Having said that this is a magic place which we have only glimpsed a little of so we will definitely be back
Read 509 Venice Reviews

Thank You For Signing Up!

Please Note: To ensure delivery of your free e-letters, please add news@cruisecritic.com to your address book.
We're committed to protecting your privacy and will not rent or sell your e-mail address. By proceeding, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.