Subscribe today
Get Cruise Critic in your inbox
Your Ultimate Cruise Guide

Carnival Magic Cruise Review by Mike and Jet: Carnival Magic Inaugural Cruise


Mike and Jet
1 Review
Member Since 2008
528 Posts

Member Rating

Cabin 5.5
Dining 5.0
Embarkation 5.0
Enrichment Activities 5.0
Entertainment 4.0
Family & Children Not Rated
Fitness & Recreation 5.0
Public Rooms 5.5
Rates 5.0
Service 5.0
Shore Excursions 5.0
Value for Money 5.5

Compare Prices on Carnival Magic Europe - Western Mediterranean Cruises

Carnival Magic Inaugural Cruise

Sail Date: May 2011
Destination: Europe - Western Mediterranean
Embarkation: Venice

The Carnival Magic is another great Carnival ship.

We cannot comment on Venice as we had no time in this city due to flight cancellations and changes. We barely made it to the ship on time. Took a cab directly from the airport to the ship for 4 people with 4 large and 4 carry on luggage was 60 euros, tip inclusive. Great deal I thought. We had pre-purchased Water Taxi and Vaporetto passes, but because we had a flight cancellation and lost all of our time in Venice, we also lost all the money expended for these transportation modes. SO, be aware if you are considering pre-purchasing these items.

The embarkation process was fairly painless although it was not clearly marked at the terminal. Employees of Carnival were available to point you in the right direction. We did miss our embarkation photo and we always purchase one. We just did not ever see it and no one directed us. Disappointed.

Being on an Inaugural Cruise, we expected to have a few bumps and a few bumps More we had. They had very little impact on the cruise itself and our enjoyment of the ship and its ports. One of the items not ready was the TV system. There were few channels available, especially news, but we were able to follow the cruise directors shows and view our portfolios which were crucial. The biggest drawback was the lack of the big shows. They were just not ready for this sailing, however Carnival did a great job filling in with other entertainers. They did have a big show on the last night, but we were unable to see it, as we had to pack and take care of other items before the end of the cruise. Another issue we had a problem with at first was the lack of trays on the lido deck for food transfer to the table. We sailed on Royal Caribbean and they have no trays, so we had always thought this to be one of Carnivals positives and now that is no more, however, they do provide over sized oval dishes which hold more than enough food, and even a bowl for salad etc. Of course you can always go back for seconds or more. While speaking of the Lido deck, let me speak about the food. Keep in mind we have sailed on the Carnival Dream. This was also typical Carnival Lido deck fare. The Mongolian Wok was delicious, but the wait is long and some people take two or three bowls of vegetables at time, drastically adding to the wait time. There ought to be a law about that. The Burrito bar is worth trying for any meal and if you like Indian Food you can find Tandorri on the aft Lido deck. We sampled the food in the Cucina di Capitano, an Italian Food, pay ($10.00 / head for dinner ) restaurant. It was ok but nothing to write home about. The basketball court was directly overhead, so for lunch it was noisy, however there was no cost for the lunch Pasta Bar. This is located on deck 12 above the Lido Deck. In the evening there was entertainment and a different menu. We had dinner at the Steakhouse and it was well worth the additional $30.00 per person. We do this on every cruise and have never been disappointed, but be forewarned that this Steakhouse only seats about 90, half of what the steakhouses normally seat, so make your reservations early, and it is located on the Promenade Deck 5, instead of the top of the ship. The Promenade deck is always busy. The Casino, ( which took my money )the shops, ( which took my wife's money ) Coffee, Sushi Bar, Piano Bar, ( Ron Pass was fun ) Comedy Clubs, ( the show we saw was not very funny at all. As a matter of fact we left )smoking deck, and lots of entertainment is all there. We have nothing but kudos to give for this deck, the biggest to the Red Frog Pub. A new edition to the promenade deck, it has a Caribbean feel, great beer, ( Thirsty Frog ) and affordable bar food treats, like grouper fingers, and coconut shrimp to name a few. The beer was so well received that they sold out of it on the first sea day ( day 2 of the cruise ) and we had to wait until Sicily to get more. Someone said it was brewed on the ship, but I was never able to verify that fact. The room stewards were great, the dining room staff seemed to be a bit strained, especially on the the first day. Everyone was up on deck enjoying the sailaway from Venice,and as soon as we hit open water, there was a mad rush to the dining room, especially for anytime diners.

PORTS of CALL:

In Sicily we did the Carnival excursion titled " In the Steps of the Godfather". We enjoyed this as well, however part of this excursion was cancelled do to rain washing away a dirt road. It took us to the Bar Vitelli, where Michael Corleone, visited, and the church where Michael married Appelonia. We were able to spend a longer time in Savoca,and the photo ops we good at this locale as well. Twisting switchback roads took us up the hill to this small village. After this half day tour, we walked around Messina, climbing the bell tower you will see from the ship, enjoying some pizza and gelato at some local shops.

In Livorno we rented Harley Davidsons and toured Tuscany, visiting Volterra, Siena, and San Gimignano. All of them medieval towns and absolutely must sees.

Our Day in Monaco was cancelled due to high winds, so we missed that port entirely, probably saving me some money but disappointing as well.

Debarkation was a non issue. As we planned on staying in Barcelona for a few days, we were in no hurry to get off the ship, so we had a leisurely breakfast in the dining room, then began the Disney style line to get off. I guess many were staying an extra day and not in a hurry to get off. We caught a cab to the hotel. I was traveling with a a group from Cruise Critic and each of us had different cab fares to the same hotel, ranging from 17 Euros to 35 Euros. Get your rate before you get in the cab. Get out if you think its too expensive.

Overall it was a fantastic trip. The ship was amazing, the service and food were great, the ports and excursions were wonderful, informative and fun. Flying sucks. :-) Less


Read more Carnival Magic cruise reviews >>
Read Cruise Critic's Carnival Magic Review >>

Cabin review: Carnival Magic Interior Lido 10206

Our little secret is room 10206 for both the Carnival Dream and Magic. It is an over-sized room at the front of the ship,for great views with a picture window and an obstructed view. The obstruction is the deck that is right outside the door. Its almost like getting a balcony room for the cost of an inside cabin. Drawback is that is next to the stewards closet.

Port and Shore Excursions


Barcelona is an awe inspiring city of fantastic architecture. You can take a million picture of the different designs and styles of the buildings. I recommend the HOHO bus. Hop on Hop off city sponsored, open double decker bus. You get an audio tour in any language and can virtually see every high point in the city. La Sagrada Famiglia is covered in scaffolding so to be able to enjoy its architecture is hard. We did not go in, so no comment there. We did go in the Barcelona Cathedral and that was an interesting church with access to the roof for a birds eye view of the city. Highly recommended would be an excursion to Montserrat Monastery. It is an amazing Basilica built into the side of a mountain. There is a cable car that takes you to the very top of the mountain where you can enjoy walking five different trails of different levels of difficulty. The photo ops are endless and what a view. Unbelievable. I wish I was there for an entire day or more. Awe inspiring for sure. Be sure to hear the Boys Choir sing at 1 PM, Get in the church early as it gets packed. The tour was booked through Day Tours Barcelona and our guide, Alicia was informative and accomodating.

In Dubrovnik we got off the ship, took a Carnival shuttle into the old walled city for a round trip cost of $12.00. Yes they even took American dollars. We walked the old city, both street level and up on the wall. There is a cost to walk the wall, and they only take Croatian money, but there is a money exchange store on the other side of the fountain. They will exchange dollars or Euros for the Croation Kuna (sp?). I think it was worth it for the views and the photo ops. There are several little cafes in and around the city and the town square even on the wall. Coffee, Gelato, and trinkets are easy to find. Many took the Euro, some even gave the Euro as change. We enjoyed just visiting this city and taking in its history.

In Naples we also did a ship excursion. It was inclusive of Pompeii, Sorrento and the Isle of Capri. There was a strike at Pompeii so it was closed in the morning, so our guide took us first to the Isle of Capri. A beautiful island where all you do is walk around and take pictures. It was a haven for designers, such as Prada, Louis Viutton, Dolce and Gabbana ( excuse my spelling ) and high priced four and five star hotels. Again, a great place to take some photos and to say you have been there, but, I will skip that part of the trip the next time. Its one of those been there, seen that places. Sorrento was a crowded area of small pedestrian shopping streets. We had lunch in the marina before we headed into the city. Lunch was good, but I wish I would have seen more of the city. Disappointed in Sorrento, at least through this Carnival excursion. Pompeii was astonishing. Its hard to imagine the devastation of the volcano, the lives of the inhabitants, and the fact that it was covered over for so long. A very interesting stop and highly recommended.
Read 647 Naples Reviews

In Rome we did a Romeinlimo tour. The guide Julia was great. There was also a strike at the Colosseum in the morning and we had to change the tour itinerary and see other areas first and the Colosseum last. No big deal. We bought our tickets on line weeks in advance and with a tour guide, we did not have to stand in a single line. Not at the Colosseum nor at the Vatican. Very recommended. We visited the Trevi Fountain, Spanish Steps, Piazza Narvonna, the Pantheon, the Vatican, St. Peters, and the Bone Church. Ask your guide about that extremely interesting 15 minute stop. You will see nothing like it ever in your life. Google it.

Thank You For Signing Up!

Please Note: To ensure delivery of your free e-letters, please add news@cruisecritic.com to your address book.
We're committed to protecting your privacy and will not rent or sell your e-mail address. By proceeding, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.