Subscribe today
Get Cruise Critic in your inbox
Your Ultimate Cruise Guide

Carnival Miracle Cruise Review by mr0315: Carnival Miracle 2/7/11 8 day Southern Caribbean


mr0315
4 Reviews
Member Since 2006
135 Posts

Member Rating

Cabin 5.0
Dining 5.0
Embarkation 5.5
Enrichment Activities 2.0
Entertainment 3.0
Family & Children 2.5
Fitness & Recreation 2.0
Public Rooms 5.0
Rates 5.0
Service 5.5
Shore Excursions 5.0
Value for Money 5.0

Compare Prices on Carnival Miracle Southern Caribbean Cruises

Carnival Miracle 2/7/11 8 day Southern Caribbean

Sail Date: February 2011
Destination: Southern Caribbean
Embarkation: Fort Lauderdale (Port Everglades)

My husband and I booked this cruise last year while we were aboard the Splendor. We try to cruise for his birthday (2/11) every year and neither of us had been to any of these ports. We sailed the Miracle out of NY a few years ago. This was my Platinum cruise! Our two daughters 4 and 11 were sailing with us.

We took our chances and flew into Ft Lauderdale the morning of embarkation. No delays at all. We used Carnival's transfer service and utilized the VIP line at the terminal. It took less than 10 minutes to check in, take pictures and step onto the Miracle.

Overall, the activities seemed to be cut back from what I remember. Typically, I have decisions to make when it comes to activities on board. On this cruise, there were times where there wasn't anything I really wanted to do. The last night at sea was especially bad - no shows, no comedians, etc. It felt like Carnival was trying to push people toward the casino and the bars in the evenings. During the day the More activities were also lacking (unless you like to hang out playing cards all day).

Our stateroom steward, Jassen, was wonderful! He always said "hello" in the hallway and kept the room in tip top shape - difficult with 4 people in one room! He encouraged us to utilize the free laundry service for Platinum members and left a new bag for us daily.

Our dining team (Donald from the Philippines and Clyde from Grenada) were excellent! My husband drinks gallons of ice tea/lemonade/water at a meal, and his glasses were never empty. By the second night, they knew our preferences and automatically brought my coffee and my daughter's hot chocolate with dessert. The dining room was where I was most aware of the much-talked-about Carnival cutbacks. Donald and Clyde were busting their behinds and it showed. They never missed a beat, but the stress level was palpable. Our bar waiter stopped by the first evening and we didn't care for anything. He never came back the rest of the cruise! Food was good, although I think the menus need to be changed up a bit.

We had my husband's birthday dinner at Nick and Nora's. Amazing food and an amazing experience as always. Milica (sp?) was our sommelier and we quickly recognized each other from the Pride. Service was excellent!

My husband joked the entire voyage that he felt like he had gotten onto a Holland America ship by mistake. The demographic was primarily 65+ on this voyage and there were only about 19 kids on board. My 4 year old was just happy to have Funship Freddy to herself! I was really shocked by the Camp Carnival staff - they actually seemed annoyed when anyone did utilize camp. Our biggest complaint happened because the early seating was moved from 6pm to 5:45pm. On the second night, we attempted to drop our youngest off so she could have dinner with Camp Carnival. We were met with a very snotty attitude and informed that we would have to wait until 6pm and be late for dinner. Luckily, the Camp Director (Maria) stepped in and allowed us to drop off at 5:45 so that we could be on time for dinner. The last sea day, Camp Carnival had activities scheduled all day, but I was told a sign was posted stating that they were closed due to low attendance. Most parents I spoke to were very irritated. My older daughter is almost 12 and is 5ft 5 - we requested she be able to attend Circle C. She attended the first night, but complained that every time she went there, no one was around. She spent most of her time hanging out with mom and dad.

We enjoyed the Punchliner comedy club, but after Curacao, everyone disappeared and late nights were dull. The production shows were OK, but if you sail Carnival with any regularity, you've seen them all multiple times. Time to change it up! The entertainment staff did NOT bring any FUN to the Funship. Malcolm Burn was only present to introduce the major shows - we never saw him around the ship or on a morning show that many of the CD's do. The social hosts were DULL! They seemed bored and lacked enthusiasm. Nothing started on time. The scheduling just seemed "off" - for instance, the midnight deck party was held the night before an early port??? Why not hold it the night before a sea day? I actually found myself going back to the cabin for naps for lack of something fun to do. Groove for St Jude was held on the 2nd sea day. No sign of Malcolm, no announcements promoting it - I thought this was Carnival's big charity event???? My family made up 3 of the 6 that showed up.

As I mentioned before, we had never been to any of these ports and were looking forward to them. Grand Turk...we did the Gibbs Cay Stingray excursion through Carnival. It was very interesting, especially for my 11 year old who is in the middle of a research paper about them. My only gripe was that it seemed way too short. We took the Catalina Island beach break on the DR. 20 minute tender ride from the ship. Everything a tropical beach should be! The vendors were extremely pushy though. On the way back, the water was very choppy and one woman was sick the entire time - I felt so bad for her. Curacao is a beautiful, clean port - we spent the day just wandering around and did some shopping. Our youngest had fun playing with some local kids at a park. On Aruba we took the Gold Coast Jeep Tour. We saw all the sights and got some beach time in. The whole family agreed that this was the favorite excursion of the trip.

Disembarkment was a breeze! This was one area where the Miracle team excelled. No lines - we just waited until our number was called and walked off the ship.

I think that the age of the passengers on this trip had a lot to do with the sedate atmosphere on this cruise. Not that I'm a big partier or anything, but this was not the Carnival experience that I'm used to. Less


Read more Carnival Miracle cruise reviews >>
Read Cruise Critic's Carnival Miracle Review >>

Cabin review: Carnival Miracle Interior Riviera 1130

Standard inside cabin. We were a bit nervous about being more forward than we usually book, but found the location to be very convenient to the forward elevators/stairways. Great when leaving Mad Hatters after a late show! Location was very quiet.

Port and Shore Excursions


We took Carnival's Gold Coast Jeep tour. Excellent! Drove in Land Rover 4 x 4s and toured the sites...Natural Bridge, California Lighthouse, Ayo Rock, the Ostrich Farm, Gold Mine ruins and of course, the beach. Great tour guides who were informative and a lot of fun! Later we wandered around town to buy some souvenirs. Found the prices to be a lot cheaper here than Curacao.

Read 684 Aruba Reviews

We actually docked in La Romana, Dominican Republic, but took the Catalina Island beach break excursion. The boat ride over was a bit rough (bad enough on the way back that people were sick). The beach was gorgeous! My only complaint would be about the aggressive vendors. They would come up to us and give out free wood carving necklaces on cord and then ask you to come to their hut. They were aggressive and territorial - not happy if you tried to check out another vendor's wares! Cheap t shirts and counterfeit Cuban cigars...


We did not take an excursion, but instead wandered around town and did a bit of shopping. Very European feeling and very clean. The local people were friendly and not pushy at all. Kids enjoyed the swinging pontoon bridge and the colorful buildings. A bit pricier compared to Aruba.

Read 502 Curacao Reviews

Grand Turk is a Carnival built cruise port. There is a little of something for everyone - beach, shopping, dining, pool, Flowrider, excursions etc. The port was very clean, although extremely touristy. The Gibbs Cay Stingray and Snorkel was lots of fun and very interesting - just wish it was longer.

Thank You For Signing Up!

Please Note: To ensure delivery of your free e-letters, please add news@cruisecritic.com to your address book.
We're committed to protecting your privacy and will not rent or sell your e-mail address. By proceeding, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.