Subscribe today
Get Cruise Critic in your inbox
Your Ultimate Cruise Guide

Carnival Liberty Cruise Review by cruisinbuddy: Loved the Liberty


cruisinbuddy
4 Reviews
Member Since 2006
4,254 Posts

Member Rating

Cabin 5.0
Dining 4.0
Embarkation 5.0
Enrichment Activities Not Rated
Entertainment 5.0
Family & Children Not Rated
Fitness & Recreation Not Rated
Public Rooms 5.0
Rates 5.0
Service 4.0
Shore Excursions 5.0
Value for Money 5.0

Compare Prices on Carnival Liberty Eastern Caribbean Cruises

Loved the Liberty

Sail Date: January 2011
Destination: Eastern Caribbean
Embarkation: Miami

Background info, DW 7 I have sailed 9 times now, 4 with Carnival, this is our 2nd sailing on the Liberty, we sailed her back in '07.

Hotel, we stayed at the Hilton Downtown Miami on Biscayne Blvd. $12.00 cab ride to the port, $22.00 cab ride to the airport. It's a beautiful hotel and we able to get port side rooms at no extra cost, the clerk said $5.00 more but never charged us. The friends we were traveling with were generous and booked us rooms pre & post cruise with their Hilton points. We got some great pics of all the ships in port.

The Liberty, The kiosk check in is so easy, even I could do it. You got to the kiosk, swipe your passport, then your cc, take the little piece of paper to the section it tells you and they give you yous S&S cards. Then once your zone is called, you get to go aboard where they put your pic on the card, and you're done. We arrived at the port 10:55 and were on board at 11:50, not too darn bad. We had cabin 8244 for the 4th More time, we also stayed in the cabin on a b2b on the Freedom. We really like this location, gee can you tell? Great ship and well maintained. Never an oder, or a mess. The staff were cleaning all the time. Lido deck table cleaners could have been a little faster though.

We went to the piano bar once, Brad was funny. We only went to the Motown Show in the theatre, it was very good. We saw a couple comedians and there were both very good. They had a deck party the night we left and another one, the red, white & blue deck party, on the Wednesday, that was a lot of fun.

Our dining room staff weren't on their game at the beginning of the cruise, but it did get much better. The food as always good to very good, all over the ship. We again never got to the pizza, even though we thought about it. Our friends went to the fish & chip and said it wasn't great. Deli was always good, as was the burger grill. Went to the dining room for breakfast and lunch once each. As for the line ups at the buffets and different stations, they were never that long. I even noticed the Mongolian grill with no line up once, in the middle of lunch service.

Our room stewart was Romolo and he was very good. Never needed to ask him for ice or anything. Always a towel animal and chocolates. Pursers desk staff were always pleasant, as were any other staff we encountered. We enjoyed the live music everyday, most days twice on the Lido deck. Lido deck games were fun to watch. On the Lido Deck we met Komang, one of the waiters, he was great. We got to know him well. He was the only Bar waiter I've ever given an extra tip to. Our friends did also. Search him out and please say Robin, Kim, JoAnn & Fred say hi. At one point Fred was in his cabin and JoAnn told Komang to phone him. So he did, " Fred this is the Captain, we need you on the Lido deck", too funny. Less


Read more Carnival Liberty cruise reviews >>
Read Cruise Critic's Carnival Liberty Review >>

Cabin review: Carnival Liberty Balcony Verandah 8244

Our Cabin was 8244 on Verandah deck forward of the atrium elevators. Nice and quiet. This cabin is about 12 back from the bridge and no you don't really feel the pitching of the ship, like I'm sure some would think. There were cabins across the hall. Great location

Port and Shore Excursions


This was our favorite. Our friends decided that they'd just hang out at Margaritaville and wait for us to get back from our excursion. Great. We did the Power Snorkel to the Drop Off, a 7000 foot drop off. They have these "Underwater Propulsion Devices" made by seadoo that zip you along in the water. They take you out about 25 yards, you put on your gear and get in the water. Then he throws a UPD in the water near you, and you're off. Those things are so neat. We spent about an hour in the water, which is about 25 feet deep, just before the drop off. Think of the movie Finding Nemo, "the drop off!" One of the escorts, used his UPD to get him to the bottom, not the 7000 ft. bottom but the 25, let his UPD go, it floats, and sat on a rock with his legs crossed. I wish I got a picture. If you like snorkeling and gadgets, this one is for you. So, while we were having a great time, the port got a good drenching. It poured rain, but had stopped by the time we got back. We looked for our friends but couldn't find them so we just went back to the ship after a bit of shopping. Turns out, when it started to rain they spent about a half hour in the washroom, waiting it out, but they still got completely soaked. We met them back on board, We had a great day.


We've been here a few times too. We gave our friends a mini walking tour of old San Juan. Nothing much happened here. But still love the Blue cobblestones, the only place in the world, that you'll see them.

Read 1380 San Juan Reviews

This is our most visited island, and the jewelry store across the street from the port loves us. We did the Two Island Powercat snorkeling. It was very good. They had a guide in the water with us and she was pointing out different fish etc. Then we went to another island, darn I forget the name, and saw turtles. I love sea turtles. I got some pretty good pics.

Read 2342 St. Thomas Reviews

Thank You For Signing Up!

Please Note: To ensure delivery of your free e-letters, please add news@cruisecritic.com to your address book.
We're committed to protecting your privacy and will not rent or sell your e-mail address. By proceeding, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.