Subscribe today
Get Cruise Critic in your inbox
Your Ultimate Cruise Guide

Rotterdam Cruise Review by Luvsailing: Never Again on Holland America's Rotterdam


Luvsailing
5 Reviews
Member Since 2006
830 Posts

Member Rating

Cabin 4.0
Dining 4.0
Embarkation 1.0
Enrichment Activities 1.0
Entertainment 1.0
Family & Children Not Rated
Fitness & Recreation 3.0
Public Rooms 5.5
Rates 4.0
Service 5.5
Shore Excursions 1.0
Value for Money 3.0

Compare Prices on Rotterdam South America & Antarctica Cruises

Never Again on Holland America's Rotterdam

Sail Date: October 2010
Destination: South America & Antarctica
Embarkation: San Diego

I can honestly say that of all the cruises we have taken this cruise is one of the two worst cruises we have taken and we will never again sail on Holland America.

The activities were minimal and not at all interesting - napkin folding, picture frames and sail boats in origami classes, to name a few of the hohum activities. On the two occasions they offered WII bowling, there were so many people who showed up we each had very few turns. The movies they showed were very old. Lizabeth, the activities director, has a staff of 7 yet they couldn't come up with anything interesting - kept on blaming Seattle. Every day Lizabeth went on the loudspeaker bragging about the "exciting activities in store" - raving about bingo, slot tournaments, port information - saying these were just highlights of the many things to do. I wanted to ask her how she could say that with a straight face. Lew, the authority on the ports spoke in such a monotone and was so boring that the first lecture I More went to I fell asleep.

We crossed the Equator. Exciting event for first time Equator crossing passengers, right? Well, HAL didn't think so. We all gathered and saw a ridiculous display of a few crew members being chastised and then covered with foam and thrown in the pool. Woo hoo, how exciting!!!! Not. We were not acknowledged - not even with a champagne. toast. They didn't even have the crossing the Equator tee shirts which they had in a window. They were going to get then after we disembarked. Makes as much sense as the rest of the cruise.

People who returned to the ship from Lima, Peru brought the Norovirus and we were operating under the virus condition for 2 weeks. Most of the crew told us the usual was 3 days and they were surprised it lasted so long as less than 1% were stricken.

We had no air conditioning in our cabin and after numerous attempts to fix it they finally gave us a fan.

Our friends next door had plumbing problems with the toilet overflowing on the last day. What a horrible stinking and disgusting mess that was. Our friends reported flushing problems daily and each time they were told that was the first they heard of it. The plumbers were trying to clear the toilet lines at around 1:30 to 2:00 am on at least 3 occasions. Since we were next door you can imagine the unsettling experience of being awakened in the middle of the night to the sounds of roto rooters, so loud that the cabin shook.

People are allowed to smoke in their cabins and we had a cigar smoker near us. My husband was badly affected by the cigar fumes and had a sinus infection for 3 weeks.

They charge $2 daily for a refrigerator so if you have to refrigerate medication you need to put it in the medical department.

There are no trays in the buffet area. No water carafes in the room.

The perks for Mariners are so minor that they didn't even bother offering them. This cruise was treated as two 15 day cruises when it was convenient for HAL, and as one cruise when it was convenient for HAL. We should have received Shareholders credit for two cruises but HAL treated the cruise as one even though this was two separate 15 day cruises.

The ports were, by and large, mostly poor Mexican and South American ports with not much to see. The ship's excursions were expensive and not good at all. For instance, an 11:30 am Catamaran open bar sailing around the bay excursion turned into a 9:00 am excursion fully packed with people in life jackets sitting shoulder to shoulder with everyone else. Very unpleasant and very uncomfortable. The reason for the overcrowding was the vendor wanted to fill the 11:30 excursion with another cruise ship in port so instead of HAL having two excursions everyone was crowded into one. By the way, people were notified by a note in the cabin the night before when they didn't have an opportunity to cancel since the excursion desk was already closed. Less


Read more Rotterdam cruise reviews >>
Read Cruise Critic's Rotterdam Review >>

Cabin review: Rotterdam Large Oceanview Stateroom Dolphin 1883

We were in cabin 1883 which is on the Dolphin Deck, mid ship. The location was great. The cabin had plenty of storage and was adequate in size. The window was a good size although it was so dirty we could barely see out of it. The bed was very hard and not at all up to the standards HAL brags about. We requested a mattress topper and that made it better. There were no water carafes, and no refrigerator. The air conditioning did not work so they had to bring a fan. Smoking is allowed in the cabins so we had cigar fumes from another cabin keeping us awake on most nights. When reported we were told "cigar smoking is not allowed but we can't do anything about it because smoking is allowed in staterooms."

Port and Shore Excursions


Nice port to visit. Lots of seaside restaurants and typical souvenir shops.


(3)
HAL was charging $4,200 for 3 a three day excursion in Machu Pichu so we stayed around the town. We went to the Indian Market which was had a lot of native items. There was a mall by the sea which had high end shops. Other than that there wasn't much else to do.

Read 23 Lima Reviews

Very poor area, not worth going to.


We walked across the street from the pier and went to Walmart. There is a beautiful mall nearby and we enjoyed walking around in an air conditioned mall.

Thank You For Signing Up!

Please Note: To ensure delivery of your free e-letters, please add news@cruisecritic.com to your address book.
We're committed to protecting your privacy and will not rent or sell your e-mail address. By proceeding, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.