Overall, the ship was very good. The Amalfi dining room food and service were very good with some excellent nights. The specialty dining rooms are a waste of time with the food not even as good as the main dining room. waiters have a long way to walk for anything -- bad design of the dining services.
The deck plan is terrible. Getting from our room on Deck 14 forward to our dining room in the rear on deck 6 was always a challenge as very few of the decks allow you to walk through the entire length of the ship. The main dining room is serviced by only two elevators at the rear of the ship and there are no restrooms near the dining room. Finding a restroom is a challenge as they seem to go out of their way to hide them.
I really don't like having the tip included in each purchase you make. After all, TIP means "To Insure Promptness" and if it is automatic, what control do you have?