Subscribe today
Get Cruise Critic in your inbox
Your Ultimate Cruise Guide

MSC Fantasia Cruise Review by ap23: Beautiful ship, but needs to take a few lessons.


ap23
2 Reviews
Member Since 2010
0 Posts

Member Rating

Cabin 5.0
Dining 3.0
Embarkation 5.0
Enrichment Activities 1.0
Entertainment 3.0
Family & Children Not Rated
Fitness & Recreation 4.0
Public Rooms 5.5
Rates 3.0
Service 4.0
Shore Excursions 4.0
Value for Money 4.0

Compare Prices on MSC Fantasia Europe - Western Mediterranean Cruises

Beautiful ship, but needs to take a few lessons.

Sail Date: September 2010
Destination: Europe - Western Mediterranean
Embarkation: Barcelona

The Fantasia is one of the new ships in the MSC line. We were told it is currently the largest ship sailing the Mediterranean. the public areas of the ship are extremely attractive and inviting, with great attention to detail. Every asspect of the ship appeared to be well maintained. the cabin was nicely done, but not much different from other ships. Cabins could use a little more storage space. Though ships seem to get larger, the shower stalls remain the size of an upright coffin.

We boarded and disembarked at Barcelona without any problems, The circular route of the western Mediterranean made for an interesting situation. At every port, except Tunis, passengers were embarking or disembarking. the fact that you could begin your cruise in Spain, France, or Italy, seemed to make for continual upheaval. Every day the staff had to unload luggage and bring new luggage onboard. The staff had to treat each day as the first day of the cruise. Apparently the ship was repeating this More same route for weeks at a time.

As the ship is Italian, that is the primary language. For the English-speaking passengers who boarded at Barcelona, a brief life-jacket presentation was done in one of the lounges, followed by a short introduction to the optional excursions. Two ports later, at Genoa, we finally had a "mandatory" lifeboat drill for the entire ship. It amounted to exactly what we did two days prior. As for "mandatory", there seemed to be no checks as to whether or not passengers attended.

Apparently certain cabins are designated as English-speaking. The daily newsletters deliver to our room were in English. Few announcements are made, so you must be certain to read the newsletter. As we booked our excursions in advance, our tickets were delivered to our cabin, nightly. Europeans typically do not use wash cloths, but once it was determined we were Americans, wash cloths were provided daily. Though there was an ice bucket in the room, we never had ice, even though we had requested it at one time. That could be due to a policy of advising Americans and Canadians to use bottled water.

As for the problems we encountered, the major one appeared to be the overall attitude of the crew. At best, we found them to be indifferent to barely cordial. A maitre 'd and a customer service rep were particularly gruff. Our best experience with our waiter at table 902 in the gold dining room. Perhaps some of this is a result of the continual turn-around in passengers. It is understandable that the constant coming and going could be frustrating to the staff.

The dining experience was, shall we say, "different", from nay other cruise lines. The cafeteria/buffet was only open for breakfast and lunch. Your choice at dinner was the dining room, to which you were assigned, or, one of the them restaurants, where you must shell out additional money. The beverages at breakfast were water, coffee, tea, or watered-down juices. At lunch, the ONLY provided beverage was WATER, from the machine. There are two bars in the buffet dining room. If you want coffee, tea, iced tea, etc. during lunch you MUST PURCHASE them. At dinner, American and Canadian passengers were provided with coupons to get one two-liter bottle of water, per cabin. All of the Americans at our table had coupons, though not all had received them the first night. The Lebanese couple had to pay for their water each night. You can purchase soda or alcohol, but coffee is NOT available at dinner. If you want coffee, you would need to purchase it at one of the coffee bars after dinner. It is interesting to note that if Americans and Canadians are given the coupons for the bottled water at dinner, then there are no beverages available to them at lunch, if they should not be drinking the machine water. As for the overall food, it was satisfactory. The breakfast selections were exactly the same each day. the lunch menu varied, plus pizza, burgers, and hot dogs were available each day. Dessert choices were always fruit, jello, or a choice of two pastries. It seemed as though the same cake was used several days, with simply different frosting on top. If you wanted ice cream, your only chance was to get a scoop for dessert at dinner, otherwise it had to be purchased. The big problem at lunch was the number of people. It was often difficult to locate a seat, silverware, or drinking glass. Overall, people seemed to be rude. they pushed in line for their food, then many wasted an enormous amount. The dinner menu had a sufficient number of selections and was nicely presented. The problem was that it took almost two hours to compete the meal, especially if you had were assigned to a large table and people at your table were ordering a number of items. You had to sit and wait through each course.

As for the entertainment, the shows were short (about 25-30 minutes), unless you count the 15 minutes prior to each show when Enzo, the cruise director, enjoyed hearing himself talk. He spoke mainly in Italian, though he did throw in a little of some of the other languages. The English was definitely the condensed version of what he had said in Italian. Of course, foreign speaking travelers on an English-speaking ship, probably feel the same. The majority of the passengers on this ship were European. The production shows had different themes each night, but for the most part, were variety shows. There were some excellent acrobatic acts. It wasn't until we went to the "Son Amar" dinner show on Palma de Mallorca that we realized the Fantasia shows were really a rip-off of the large Palma show, including a Michael Jackson tribute. We cannot speak for any of the lounge acts, as we did not spend time in the bars.

As many other reviews have indicated, some Americans would not enjoy traveling on an MSC ship. You do feel as though you have been "nickel and dimed" with the mealtime beverages. The gift shops are very pricey. In Marseilles, if you wanted to travel from the port to town, MSC charged adults 15 Euros for a round-trip on a shuttle bus. There is more smoking on European ships than what is permitted on other lines. Though instructions were given not to smoke in the cabins or on the balconies, it did happen. We had problems with cigarette butts showing up on our balcony, as did the people next to us. They were being dropped from cabins above. One time an empty cigarette package appeared. Obviously, there is a lack of concern, by passengers, about polluting the world's waters.

As previously mentioned, the ship is quite lovely, but MSC does need to take lessons from other cruise lines as to how to better provide a more comfortable trip for their passengers. Less


Read more MSC Fantasia cruise reviews >>
Read Cruise Critic's MSC Fantasia Review >>

Cabin review: MSC Fantasia Standard Balcony Radioso Deck 9250

Needs more storage space. Showers typically small. At the rear of the ship with great views of the ports. Some motion, but not a problem.

Port and Shore Excursions


This was the port where we boarded our cruise, so we did not do any ship excursions. We spent 5 nights in Barcelona prior to the cruise and loved it. If you have time to spend there, do it. Barcelona is now one of our favorite European cities.

At Naples, we chose an excursion to Portofino and, as a result, saw almost nothing of Genoa. The one problem we find with doing so many ports in such a short period of time is that you actually see very little of each location.

The drive was very scenic with the numerous tunnels through the mountains. We were given about 30 minutes to look around Santa Margarita before boarding the boat to take us to the island. Once on Portofino, we had approximately 45 minutes to tour. The limited time at each location made us feel as though we were constantly watching the clock.

Read 127 Genoa Reviews

Our excursion was a city-tour of Marseilles. the tour was okay. Our guide was quite pleasant and informative. She had to switch between languages and did it effectively. We were given a little time near the waterfront at the end of the tour. If we wanted to stay in town, we were told we would have to pay for the shuttle back to the ship. Passengers not on a paid excursion were charged 15 Euros for adults and 6 Euros for children to the ride the shuttle bus back and forth to the main part of the city.


Again, we saw virtually nothing of Naples because we chose the optional excursion to the ruins of Pompeii. Our tour guide did the entire tour in English, which was a pleasant change. She was very thorough, though it would have been nice to have had a little time to explore some other areas of the site on our own.

Before we toured Pompeii, we were taken to a coral factory for the usual "sales pitch" and to use restrooms. Afterwards, we were taken into another store where restrooms were available. We were given a little time to shop or grab a snack and drink.

Read 643 Naples Reviews

This time we chose to do the city tour and a trip to the mountain village of Monreale. Our guide seemed to be in a constant rush. He would expand on his Italian commentary, but as there were only a few of us who were English speakers, his English commentary was greatly abbreviated. The majority of the trip was to see the interior of four churches. Major traffic in Palermo seem to keep us from having very much of anytime in Monreale. Once there, we walked up the hill, went into the church, then walked back down the hill to the bus.

Read 102 Palermo Reviews

As we did not arrive in port until 2pm, our time was limited. We had purchased tickets to the "Son Amar" dinner show for that evening. This did not afford us the time to do the island tour we were also interested in.

When you get off the ship, there are taxis and sightseeing buses available. We rode the double-decker sight-seeing bus and did the city tour loop. We did not get off at any of the stops, so it was a quick tour, but did give us a good look at the city.

That evening we were taken out of the city to the dinner/show venue. The show was okay, but if you have been to Las Vegas, you have seen better shows. It was then we realized that the shows on our ship were a copy of what we were seeing that night, including the Michael Jackson tribute. The meal was okay, though the steak was a little tough. People who did not book one of the two dinner show excursions, had little to do onboard that evening, as the casino and shops were closed and there was no show.


In Tunis, we chose the optional excursion to the ruins of ancient Carthage and a visit to the city's Medina or market. The guide was very personable. Our fist stop was for a photo stop of the exterior of a mosque. Next, we went to Carthage and the guide provided some commentary.

Our last stop was in Tunis where we briefly walked through a small section of the Medina. There was no time given to stop and look at any of the shops. We were taken to what we were told was a "government" shop where we would be given good prices. First, we had to sit through a showing of carpets. These carpets appeared to be of a lower quality than what we have seen in Turkey, China, and Morocco. You could then go downstairs to see other merchandise. Immediately a salesperson followed us around the shop as we browsed. As a collector of magnets from our travels, we inquired about them. He didn't know of any, but finally a guy at the sales desk pulled out a handful. We asked the price, but they wouldn't give us one until we were finished shopping. After selecting a small painted jar, we told the salesperson that was all he wanted. Finally he gave us the price of 200 Euros!!!! Unbelievable!! He said the jar was 150 Euros and the magnet 50 Euros. We told him he had to be kidding. A few minutes later he came ack and quoted 100 Euros. Needless to say, we made no purchase. Our next stop in the Medina was a perfume shop with another presentation. It was small and we didn't feel the high pressure as in the "government" shop, but we made no purchases. We then walked back the same route. without really seeing much of the Medina. Before boarding the bus, we quickly purchased a magnent from a vendor for 2 Euros!

Thank You For Signing Up!

Please Note: To ensure delivery of your free e-letters, please add news@cruisecritic.com to your address book.
We're committed to protecting your privacy and will not rent or sell your e-mail address. By proceeding, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.