Subscribe today
Get Cruise Critic in your inbox
Your Ultimate Cruise Guide

Maasdam Cruise Review by capellirossi: Ship and Itinerary - Yes. Food -No.


capellirossi
2 Reviews
Member Since 2007
4 Posts

Member Rating

Cabin 4.0
Dining 2.0
Embarkation 5.0
Enrichment Activities Not Rated
Entertainment 3.0
Family & Children Not Rated
Fitness & Recreation 4.0
Public Rooms 4.0
Rates 3.0
Service 5.0
Shore Excursions Not Rated
Value for Money 4.0

Compare Prices on Maasdam Canada & New England Cruises

Ship and Itinerary - Yes. Food -No.

Sail Date: September 2010
Destination: Canada & New England
Embarkation: Montreal

We sailed for the 3rd time with a group of long-time friends, and our 5th as a couple. Overall, we enjoyed the cruise, the ports and the accommodations. We must, however, give HAL one of our lowest ratings for food overall.

We stayed at the Le Square Phillips Hotel & Suites for 2 nights before sailing, which we booked separately. (See TripAdvisor reviews.) Each of the couples in our group chose their own pre-cruise accommodation. It is easy to find hotels within one-half to one mile of the port. Highlights:

Embarkation: quick and easy. The process seemed less involved than for other cruises. If you arrive early, you have to wait in the embarkation terminal on folding chairs. Fortunately, we were allowed to board earlier than our cruise docs stated.

First day: We had checked our main bags and so went up to the Lido with carryon. You can leave carryon in a staffed area on the pool deck before passing the pool to get to the Lido. We met up with our More friends in the Lido and so spent much of the afternoon there and in investigating the ship until we heard the announcement that our staterooms were ready (around 1:30-2:00). Our luggage arrived within an hour after that. The safety drill was blessedly short - we did not have to put on the life-vests, though we did have to gather at our assigned station on the prom deck.

Itinerary: We chose this one specifically because it included both Montreal, Quebec City and Boston. Montreal is possible because the ship is smaller in size. Only one day at sea. See ports, below.

Ship: it's old, but we didn't encounter any of the problems mentioned by others (such as backed up toilets) or that we encountered on another older HAL ship previously. But it's good the ship is going into drydock because it is not up to date - the bathrooms have no storage, for example. However, the storage in the stateroom was ample. Our stateroom had a tub-shower; we would prefer a walk-in shower. We especially enjoy the Explorations Cafe-Library and Lounge. HAL has the best libraries I've seen on cruise ships. We went up to the Deck 12 "sky" lounge a few times but I found it chilly and the seating and layout uncomfortable.

Food/Dining: Sigh. My husband and I both dislike HAL's food overall, though there are exceptions. We mainly ate in the Lido, because we could meet up with our friends and because we found the Dining Room slow for breakfast. We were usually out at lunch time and ate an afternoon snack in the Lido. There were 2 big problems with the food for us: the lack of variety, especially in the Lido, and the inability to serve oneself as is common on other cruise lines now. The first few days everything was served by the crew, including coffee, tea and water, to protect us from illness. But after that, most food in the Lido is served by crew - they make sandwiches, for example. The bread was often dry and sandwiches were assembled poorly. My over-easy eggs were broken. We thought the baked goods, like muffins, waffles, etc., were dreadful. The cookies and some desserts were quite good, however. Out at the pool, we sampled the pizza - again, dreadful. We ate dinner as a group every night in the Dining Room, where the food was better except for one disastrous night when the fish entree was just plain inedible (our waiter warned us about it and brought other entrees). Other entrees were good, soup was quite good, and there were a variety of desserts every night. The dessert extravaganza was mostly cakes.

Activities: This is a smaller ship, so there weren't the big, glitzy shows of big ships. But I thought the young Maasdam troupe that performed in the theatre was hard-working and multi-talented. A string quartet had a good audience every evening in the Explorations Lounge. Other activities tended toward trivia and name-that-tune. They allow smoking in the casino - bad form.

Passengers: Definitely older. A few toddlers, not many. But this was the oldest age demographic I've seen on a cruise. Less


Read more Maasdam cruise reviews >>
Read Cruise Critic's Maasdam Review >>

Cabin review: Maasdam Large Oceanview Stateroom Lower Promenade

Good closet and storage but not in the bathroom, quiet, view is of the Prom Deck. Lights are left on all night on the Prom Deck, so you can't see anything because of the glare.

Port and Shore Excursions


In some ways, Bar Harbor is enjoyable just because of its setting. Some of our group walked the shore trail, some took an excursion to the Acadian National Park, some shopped. We ate lunch (clam chowder, a huge haddock sandwich) at a tavern-restaurant in town called the something Whale. Bar Harbor did seem to be the more touristy port we visited - but a lot of the tourists were not from cruises. They were traveling on their own, by car or other means.


(5.5)
I can't believe I'd never been to Boston. There is a lot to do here. We ended our trip by staying in a short-stay apartment for 3 days. I recommend the Museum of Fine Arts, the North End (especially to eat), the Common, Faneuil Hall/Quincy Market - and getting around on the T. You can get either a CharlieCard (plastic) or CharlieTicket and add money to it as you go along. But Boston is also walkable - we walked the entire Freedom Trail, including crossing the Charles River and visiting the U.S.S. Constitution, in part of one day.

Read 217 Boston Reviews

All of our group enjoyed PEI. One took the Anne of Green Gables tour, another couple spent time in Charlottetown, finding it fun and charming, and others rented a car and toured the middle part of the Island. PEI seems unspoiled, really a nice place whether you stay in town or visit the shore, historic sites, etc.. Tip: go to the visitors center at the museum, a few short blocks from the port - the staff was very helpful and there are computers available.


(5.5)
Halifax is sort of a smaller Montreal: a major city with everything from churches to large sports facilities. We headed for the boardwalk and Maritime Museum, a very interesting experience. We also walked up to the Citadel, which costs money to enter - but one of our friends got in free by walking around to the north side. The Public Park near the Citadel, Victorian in vintage, is lovely and peaceful.

Read 338 Halifax Reviews

It helped to have spent time in QC before, so we knew where the highlights were. Tip: walk through the lower city and either take the stairs or the funicular up to the upper city to get to the Plains of Abraham and the man city. There is also a nice public market a few blocks east of the ship port.


There's not a lot to do here, but we enjoyed walking around the town and taking care of a few personal errands. The bid draw here was the Alexander Graham Bell home and museum, which means either a shore excursion or car rental.

Thank You For Signing Up!

Please Note: To ensure delivery of your free e-letters, please add news@cruisecritic.com to your address book.
We're committed to protecting your privacy and will not rent or sell your e-mail address. By proceeding, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.