Subscribe today
Get Cruise Critic in your inbox
Your Ultimate Cruise Guide

Caribbean Princess Cruise Review by MRiseling: Great Destinations-Not So Great Service


MRiseling
1 Review
Member Since 2009
17 Posts

Member Rating

Cabin 3.0
Dining 1.0
Embarkation 5.0
Enrichment Activities 3.0
Entertainment 2.0
Family & Children Not Rated
Fitness & Recreation Not Rated
Public Rooms 4.0
Rates 3.0
Service 2.0
Shore Excursions 3.0
Value for Money 3.0

Compare Prices on Caribbean Princess Canada & New England Cruises

Great Destinations-Not So Great Service

Sail Date: September 2010
Destination: Canada & New England
Embarkation: New York (Manhattan)

This is my 8th or 9th cruise and my second on Princess. My last Princess cruise was over 20 years ago to Alaska.

EMBARKATION & DISEMBARKATION WAS A BREEZE. We got the Princess transfer tickets and the staff was right there to meet us at the baggage claim area at LaGuardia. We were on a bus in less than 30 minutes. Don't worry about booking an early flight. We were able to get on the boat before noon once we reached the Brooklyn Harbor. When you are disembarking to go home, get one of the longshore workers to handle your bags ($1 a bag for a tip) for you. They are the really big guys and they are usually standing around with a flat cart. They load your luggage and then push you right through the lines in front of everyone. (Who's going to day no to a guy that looks like a linebacker for the NY Giants and talks like Tony Soprano, right?) We were off the ship, cleared customs and on our bus to the airport within ½ an hour.

FIVE PORTS OF CALL ARE ALMOST TOO MUCH More on a 7-day cruise but they were really good ports. You will be really tired by that 6th day at sea on the end of the cruise.

ENTERTAINMENT on the ship wasn't too bad. There was one guy that was really fantastic. He is a piano player named Martin Kaye. He was in the Martini lounge every night and then had a stage show in the theatre on the last night which was standing room only. If he is on the ship when you sail, definitely see him. Well worth it and the martinis are pretty good as well.

RETHINK OPEN DINING - We did open dining on the ship because we felt it would give us more flexibility. On two separate nights, we had to wait to get a table in the Island Dining Room. One night the wait was over 40 minutes. We went at different times on the different nights. On the final night of the cruise, we didn't have to wait for a table but when we got to the dining room, the Maitre D met our request with a table for four with "well, we only have shared table dining right now." The negative comment didn't really go over well and we didn't really have a problem with sharing a table just with his attitude. Actually, his attitude pretty much was poor throughout the cruise. Anyway, on the last night we went to dinner at 6:30 p.m. and it took TWO HOURS to get through the dinner service. We were so long in getting out that it made us late for the theatre show and we had to stand in the back.

AIR CONDITION IN THE CABIN - I agree with a previous reviewer when they complained about the air conditioning (or lack thereof) in the rooms. We also experienced a problem with the a/c. We like our room cool and we turned the thermostat down to it's lowest point to try and get the room cooled down when we arrived. The room was NEVER cool and on many occasions it was stuffy. We complained and a maintenance man came and did something with the thermostat but the room never did cool down. On the last night when it was humid outside, it was quite uncomfortable in the room. If you are sailing in the south, this could be very problematic.

Also, I would recommend that you NOT BOOK AN INTERIOR ROOM. We decided to go this route because we didn't want to spend all that much money but I won't make that mistake again. There is LOTS of noise coming from the maintenance staff on the interior wall of the room cabin. Also, if you are on the Piazza deck, you can hear the bands when they are playing in the Piazza.

ROOM ATTENDANTS WERE OK AT BEST. While our guy seemed very nice, he certainly did not go over and beyond anything he had to do. We ordered robes for our rooms on our arrival but they were never received. We also had to ask for extra shampoo and amenties. They were not left every day for us. If you are someone who likes the towel animals, be prepared to be disappointed. According to one of the room stewards (not ours), the towel animals are not required anymore.

FINAL TRAVEL TIPS: Arrive early for the ship. Prepare to wait for dinner on some nights See Martin Kaye if he is still performing on the ship. Don't get an interior room Book a trip that lets you spend time in Peggy's Cove. Use the longshore personnel with disembarking. Less


Read more Caribbean Princess cruise reviews >>
Read Cruise Critic's Caribbean Princess Review >>

Cabin review: Caribbean Princess Interior Double Aloha P330

P330-is a tiny closet with bad air conditioning. It is noisy in that you can hear the crew and maintenance staff on interior wall at night when you are trying to sleep. You can also hear the bands playing on the 5th floor of the Piazza inside the room.

Port and Shore Excursions


BAR HARBOR – We spent part of the morning taking a mile long shore walk that started right where the tender let’s you off. It was really beautiful—actually the whole area is beautiful. In the afternoon, we took a whale watching trip booked through the ship. We were disappointed that we didn’t see more whales but it was a nice trip out and back.


BOSTON - We did the Freedom Walk on our own using a Ho-Ho. We had plenty of time to see the things that we wanted to see. There is a trolley that you can catch right at the ship’s pier. Use Old Town Trolleys. They are really good about giving you information about the sites you are seeing as you travel from place to place. FYI, the USS Constitution is closed on Mondays!

Read 223 Boston Reviews

HALIFAX – We did the Peggy’s Cove and Halifax Ho-Ho trip booked through the ship. Peggy’s Cove is fantastic. The one thing that we all wished we would have done was booked a trip that allowed us to spend more time in Peggy’s Cove. The trip we were on only allowed for an hour and it just isn’t enough time to roam around and really appreciate the beauty of the place.

Read 352 Halifax Reviews

NEWPORT - We pre-ordered tickets for the mansions online through the Newport Tourism folks and then did part of the Cliff Walk. If you are doing the mansions, definitely see The Breakers. Don't miss the Cliff Walk. Take it from Ruggles Avenue to the 40-steps (about ˝ a mile walk at most). You see some great shoreline and the back yards of some beautiful homes.

Read 125 Newport Reviews

ST. JOHN – We took a photography tour booked through the ship. He took us to several different places within the city. I think this was one of the only tours that day that actually got to see the Reversing Falls as the tide was coming in and also going out. He took us first thing to see the low tide with the river flowing out to the Bay and then the last thing we did was go back to see the tide as it reversed the river flow. It is a pretty cool thing to see.

Thank You For Signing Up!

Please Note: To ensure delivery of your free e-letters, please add news@cruisecritic.com to your address book.
We're committed to protecting your privacy and will not rent or sell your e-mail address. By proceeding, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.