Subscribe today
Get Cruise Critic in your inbox
Your Ultimate Cruise Guide

Norwegian Epic Cruise Review by mjayr5859: PROS & CONS FOR THE NCL EPIC


mjayr5859
2 Reviews
Member Since 2009
1 Post

Member Rating

Cabin 3.0
Dining 5.0
Embarkation 3.0
Enrichment Activities 5.0
Entertainment 4.0
Family & Children 3.0
Fitness & Recreation 4.0
Public Rooms 5.0
Rates 4.0
Service 5.0
Shore Excursions 3.0
Value for Money 4.0

Compare Prices on Norwegian Epic Western Caribbean Cruises

PROS & CONS FOR THE NCL EPIC

Sail Date: September 2010
Destination: Western Caribbean
Embarkation: Miami

In January of this year my family and I sailed on the Oasis and like that ship our time on the Epic rates as one of our favorite cruises but there are some areas that can be improved on as well.

First the cabin: very spacious and with a lot of storage, more so than any other stateroom we've ever had. We also liked the"wave" design as it was new and different. The problem with the stateroom which really alienated my wife was the bathroom. Everyone complains of the bathrooms in the cabins on this ship; the comedians at Second City even make fun of them in their routine. The doors are transparent and you have no privacy; the sink is outside of the bathroom & has a very small bowl that splashes if you turn the water on beyond a very low level. My wife preferred to use the spa bathroom when open.

The other problem with the spa deluxe was how NCL sold it and what it was. When we booked we were told that A) there would be a wall across from our door to limit More accessibility and noise and that we would have 24 hour access to the spa. Well, there is no wall, you get off the elevator and your in the spa, make a turn and your at our cabin. And the 24 hour access? Not even close, instead you get black bracelets that you have to wear after you go to the desk at the spa and trade in your cabin key for spa access. That means the spa is only available when the spa is open and you have to check in & out. Other spa cabin passengers complained they too thought we'd have longer & better access.

The ship itself is very nice & very clean & new. The crew could not be nicer. I'd rate crew performance higher than Oasis. The only cons for the ship is a small pool deck & the need for mid-ship elevators as the set fore & aft get very crowded during the day & night. We had to take elevators going in the opposite direction and take a ride just to get in one. The Oasis with over 2,000 more passengers never felt as crowded.

My last major complaint before we get to the good stuff is the children's area, Recess, & the kid's entertainment. I have a nine year son and he liked going to Recess but it seemed somewhat disorganized. What I had the biggest problem was that unlike every other cruise line we've been on they charge $6.00/hour to watch your child on port days even if your on the ship. Nickel & dime... Also, really, do they need to charge $10 or $15 for the Slime Time Live or the Meet the Nicktoon's characters breakfast? As I said nickel and dime.

Now the good stuff. Starting with the food. Simply put the food on the Epic was the best ever of any cruise we have been on! The buffet was fresh & hot, the meals at Taste was great as well as the Manhattan room which we did feel was a little too noisy; we preferred Taste.

We ate at two speciality restaurants in addition to the Cirque Dreams dinner. One dinner was at Cagney's and was as good as Chops on the Oasis. The other was at Teppanyaki which was incredible. Your meal takes almost two hours and the chef was amazing! He asked me if I liked my fillet Mignon and when I said it was great he cooked me another one! Cirque Dreams you have a limited menu and they feed you Pre-prepared meals and that was the least favorite of our dinners on the cruise.

As for the Ice Bar, do it to say you did it but don't expect much. It is very cold and very, very crowded. It was a let down at $20.

We loved the Blue Man Group and would have seen them again but could not schedule it. Howling at the Moon was okay but it seemed like the two piano players were more busy trying to get tips than performing; my wife & I left early. I'm not a big fan of tribute shows but Legends was very good and I enjoyed it very much. Both the Murder Mystery & Improv show by Second City was fun and both my son & I got picked to participate in the murder mystery show.

That leaves Cirque Dreams. What can I say? Most of my party liked it very much, me not so much. It was too frenzied and parts of it not appropriate for my nine year old. I would not pay to see it again.

No cruise is perfect and when I wrote my review on Oasis at the start of the year I said it was my favorite cruise ever but there were some areas for improvement. The Epic now ties as my favorite cruise but as noted above there are areas they can improve on, starting with those darn bathrooms!

If you asked me which I would pick to recommend, Oasis or Epic, I'd say they both have their pros & cons and you wouldn't go wrong with booking on either one. Less


Read more Norwegian Epic cruise reviews >>
Read Cruise Critic's Norwegian Epic Review >>

Cabin review: Norwegian Epic 14167

Average balcony; average bed. The third party "bed" is a joke, my nine year old son almost fell off it, a adult could not sleep on it. Really great storage! Very bad bathroom (as it is in every cabin on the ship). Location: Not blocked from the elevators & spa as indicated on the deck plans. Can be crowded and noisy in front of cabin.

Port and Shore Excursions


Lot's of potential. If your ship is not the first ship in, ours was preceeded by the Carnival Dream, you are not going to get a spot by the pool in port. Take a taxi for $3.00 into town and walk along the beach. I can see it really growing into a very nice sea-side port & resort.


The first time in port we went to see the ruins. On this cruise we toured the town. How many Diamonds International can you walk through? Not so great.

Read 3140 Cozumel Reviews

Take a tour of the city with a guide and visit the Iguana Farm!

Read 1660 Roatan Reviews

Thank You For Signing Up!

Please Note: To ensure delivery of your free e-letters, please add news@cruisecritic.com to your address book.
We're committed to protecting your privacy and will not rent or sell your e-mail address. By proceeding, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.