After much arm twisting from our kids (11 & 16) we finally agreed to go on a cruise. We picked the Legend primarily for the itinerary (we love to snorkel / SCUBA) and the mostly positive feedback. Since we had a very good time & experience, I will start with the positives.
The Good (no particular order):
Food- much better than we expected. We ate at the Golden Fleece one night and for only $30 per person this is the best bargain on the ship. It might not be quite as good a Ruth Chris, but it's not too far off. We found the food in the main dining room (Truffles) to be quite good with a nice variety of choices (usually several fish, chicken, & steak options).
We had a balcony cabin and would not consider going on a cruise without one. Our daughters had a joining room that did not have a balcony. They used ours and it was never an issue. I can't imaging more than 2 people to room...no matter how close your family! :-0