“Cruising for the Walmart crowd.”
Cruise review of Carnival Liberty

Airshofoto Carnival Liberty 3 Cruising for the Walmart crowd.
Member Since 2010
No Helpful Votes
Overall Member Rating
This was our first cruise and it only partially met our expectations. The areas that underwhelmed us where the dining and the character of some fellow passengers.

First for dining. We ate in the Golden Olympian Dining Room at our own time selection which was very convenient especially with a 2 year old along. The quality of the food was good, however the food was rarely served hot. If this were a land based restaurant, I would assume it sat for quite a while before being picked up. The portions were quite small compared to a land-based restaurant, especially for the level of pomp that the restaurant displayed. For example, at a breakfast I ordered french toast. What I received were two half slices when I would expect 3 or 4 full slices on land.

Service was rather slow which wasn't a problem, but when combined with having to ask for every single beverage refill, be it water, coffee or juice, it became frustrating. The dinner at Harry's Steakhouse was only marginally better. Wait staff in the dining rooms seemed to be on auto-pilot. This may be because we had a different service team at every meal and they knew their tip was already assured due to the pre-billed tips. On land, I would be hard pressed to give a 15% tip when 20% is my norm. We found ourselves at the buffet lines regularly simply because we could get what we wanted in a timely manner.

Secondly, the fellow passengers. There were a lot of passengers that did seem to be way out of their comfort zone. For example, a lengthy discussion about why there was more than one fork at each place setting. Even on elegant dress nights, the attire of many may seem to be dressy for dinner at Applebee's, but it did not fit with coats, ties and dresses.

There was evidence of graffiti being carved into the interior highly polished elevator doors on several occasions which was very disappointing. During the arrival on deck 1 to prepare for departure at a port visit, we exited the elevator and were rudely addressed by one of the "Walmart crowd" to "get out of here and go to the back of the line". This was in a sardine can environment while pushing a stroller with a 2 year old. Totally uncalled for. Everyone got off the boat and to show that level of disrespect to a fellow passenger really gave me cause to seek a more exclusive cruise line when we go on another cruise.

Camp Carnival was the one shining element that this ship got right. Our 2 year old was ecstatic and simply couldn't wait to go there and put up a fight to leave.

Carnival Liberty Cruises to the Western Caribbean
Overall Ratings
  • Cabin
  • Dining
  • Embarkation
  • Enrichment Activities
  • Entertainment
  • Family & Children
  • Fitness & Recreation
  • Onboard Experience
  • Public Rooms
  • Rates
  • Service
  • Shore Excursions
  • Value for Money

Cabin review: Balcony

Very quiet away from stairs, elevators or any activities. It was perfect. Size was more than enough and the balcony, storage space and bathroom were everything we had hoped for.

Port and Shore Excursions

The port is neat clean and freshly constructed. It however does not give much or a tate of Mexico or the real Cozumel. We did our excursion to Tulum to see the Mayan ruins. It was well done with an exce3llent guide.

Read 4,598 Cozumel Reviews
We took our son swimming with the Stingrays and it was a highlight of the trip. The amount of time in port did not leave a lot of time for shopping, so we made a quick round the block tour and headed back to the ship in a monsoon downpour.

Jamaica, OK to visit but I wouldn't want to move there. We took a Jeep tour of the Ocho Rios area with a stop at Dunns Falls. My wife loved the falls, I wasn't particularly impressed. The most memorable occasions were the guy at the base of the falls trying to sell me marijuana and the trinket sellers who just wouldn't take no for an answer.

Published 06/01/10
Thank Airshofoto
No Helpful Votes
Read Cruise Critic’s Carnival Liberty Review
Carnival Liberty Cruises to the Western Caribbean
Share feedback
Thank you!  Cruise Critic values your feedback.
How can we improve this page?