Subscribe today
Get Cruise Critic in your inbox
Your Ultimate Cruise Guide

MSC Magnifica Cruise Review by summer66: Magnifica was great for us!


summer66
3 Reviews
Member Since 2008
33 Posts

Member Rating

Cabin 5.0
Dining 5.0
Embarkation 5.5
Enrichment Activities Not Rated
Entertainment 3.0
Family & Children Not Rated
Fitness & Recreation Not Rated
Public Rooms 5.0
Rates 5.0
Service 5.0
Shore Excursions Not Rated
Value for Money 5.5

Compare Prices on MSC Magnifica Europe - Eastern Mediterranean Cruises

Magnifica was great for us!

Sail Date: April 2010
Destination: Europe - Eastern Mediterranean
Embarkation: Venice

We booked this cruise because our best European friends saw that it was a new ship with a great itinerary and included Istanbul, our favorite port. After researching MSC, we were a little nervous that it would be less satisfactory than our other experiences, so we booked the most expensive accommodation, thinking that would be a hedge against this worry. This was the only mistake we made in choosing the Magnifica.

Our friends had an oceanview cabin for almost two-thirds less than our 14th deck suite. While the suite was roomy and somewhat deluxe, we used the balcony very little on this port-intensive cruise.There were no particular perks to being at the suite category, which is different from what the cruise line puts in their brochure. We had a little problem with a very loud Fussball game that was directly under us, but this was addressed after we called it to the attention of reception. If we travel again on MSC, and we'd be happy to do so, we'd look for an aft facing More balcony cabin, which we discovered were lovely and very quiet on a very lively ship.

Embarkation in Venice was the most seemless we've ever experienced. We drove from Vienna and parked the car, not at Piazzale Roma, but at the port parking lot. We came after the rush and were on board in ten minutes. Disembarking took longer but was not the nightmare it can be. We were staying at a home exchange in Venice for several days after the cruise, so we weren't in a big hurry.

Make no mistake, this is a European ship, and for us this was great. Fellow passengers were almost entirely Italian, with a mix of other Europeans, and perhaps lastly, Americans. We travel to Europe often, at least once a year, and we don't go to be surrounded by only Americans. The only reason I can find that explains why the reviews of this line have been so bad, is that the reviewers somehow didn't share our feelings about this. It is not a quiet ship; the pool area is packed and jumping, and there were lots of children aboard, even though it was not a school holiday time. The average age of passengers was much lower than any ship we've been on, but we did not experience any rudeness as a result of this.

Every night at dinner, we exclaimed over how different our meals seemed from descriptions we had read about them. Our opinion was that the food was way better than Carnival, as good as Cunard, but much more interesting, and only surpassed by the quality of the former Celebrity ship, the Galaxy. We had great service in a lovely room and the only drawback was that the tables were quite close together. The dining room ambience was very lively, bordering on noisy, but to us, that's Italian and charming.

We probably didn't give the entertainment a fair chance. We enjoyed one show except that the dancing was seriously old fashioned, and only ducked into two others before bailing for the same reason. Our friends found a favorite after dinner spot in the cigar lounge, which was quiet and very clubby in feeling, with a very good classical quartet playing outside it most days. We bought a few things in the shops which were much like ones in other ships we'd been on.

The itinerary was perfect for us. In addition to wonderful Istanbul, where we like to visit family friends, Bari, Olympia, and Izmir were brand new destinations for us. Best of all was Dubrovnik, which we'd heard for thirty years was gorgeous, but really defies description. The walled city is a gem, but it's the harbor that is certainly one of the most spectacular locales on earth. All of these places are easy to see on one's own - perhaps especially Dubrovnik as the ship provides a shuttle bus to the old town and it would be silly to go on a group tour once there. We did each port on our own; a highlight was renting a car in Katakolon and driving to wonderful Olympia.

The Magnifica is not for those looking for a staid, reserved holiday. Cunard would be an ideal choice for that. But if you like fresh, international food, a new and spotless ship, and to be surrounded in a vivid European atmosphere, you might like it as much as we did. Less


Read more MSC Magnifica cruise reviews >>
Read Cruise Critic's MSC Magnifica Review >>

Cabin review: MSC Magnifica Balcony Suite Positano Deck 14033

Our suite was lovely but not so superior to other balcony cabins that we would choose it again. Nice bathtub and lots of storage in the bath and throughout the cabin. Placement right at the opening to the pool below wasn't noisy but the game tables under us were sometimes played late into the night.

Port and Shore Excursions


Dubrovnik was the highlight of this trip for me. Natural beauty and the wonderful walled old town are just stunning.


Istanbul is truly amazing and very accessible to Westerners, in my opinion. If on your own, the place to see is Sultanahmet park. There you will find the Blue Mosque, and close by, Hagia Sophia and Topkapi Palace. A real highlight for us, and one we never miss, is the Arasta Bazaar just behind the Blue Mosque. While the Grand Bazaar and even the popular Spice Bazaar are a bit overwhelming, the Arasta Bazaar has a wonderful atmosphere and high quality goods.

Read 258 Istanbul Reviews

Izmir is a big city and we had our worst day of weather here. Nonetheless, the ruins at the Agora are very worthwhile, and the city bazaar is charming. It's easy to get to these with an inexpensive cab ride.

Read 153 Izmir Reviews

The little port town of Katakolon is very pretty, but the must-see here is Olympia. If you wouldn't feel comfortable renting a car, book a ship's tour, but don't pass up the chance to see Olympia. The ruins are tremendous and beautiful, and the town has lovely shops and cafes.


(5.5)
What can be said about Venice that hasn't been said a million times? It's magical and our fifteenth trip here at the end of our cruise was as thrilling as our first was when we were young.

Read 508 Venice Reviews

Thank You For Signing Up!

Please Note: To ensure delivery of your free e-letters, please add news@cruisecritic.com to your address book.
We're committed to protecting your privacy and will not rent or sell your e-mail address. By proceeding, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.