“Disappointing!! Princess has been ”
Cruise review of Emerald Princess

Vrob99 Emerald Princess 2 Disappointing!! Princess has been
Member Since 2010
No Forum Posts
No Helpful Votes
Overall Member Rating
As veterans of many, many cruises, we were sorely disappointed in our latest journey aboard the Emerald Princess. The dining was the biggest disappointment- nowhere near worthy of a 5 star rating. Princess has taken to cutting it's busboy wait staff in half- so service has become painfully slow. They've cut the number of courses by two (combining such offerings as soup & salad)- portions are small & tasteless. The specialty dining (Sabatinis, at $20 per) was little better. I've never been on a cruise where I heard the staff tell passengers "NO" so much- even for simple requests. Nearly all of the staff seemed depressed & unhappy.

The ship was jam packed- & unfortunately like some other cruise lines, particularly Carnival, they've taken to designing ships with very small & nondescript dining rooms and surprisingly small public areas, buried in the inards of the ship. The gym, vines winebar & the pub are enjoyable & well done, though crowded. But little else will impress. The entertainment was absolutely embarassing. The production shows (2) had one or two quality staff, the rest were rank amateurs. They had the same comedian entertain for 3 of the remaining nights- he was funny the first night, & the crowd pretty much looked at each other the second two. It was almost like they had an entertainer cancel at the last minute & decided to just have the same comedian stand up there for three nights. Worthless!

The beds could hardly be called beds- more like a slab of wood with a thin pad on top- very hard & uncomfortable, & of course, small. This cruise ship reminded us of flailing airlines with service problems- as if they enjoy endlessly finding ways to cut this & that to save a few pennies. Though we've previously had good experiences on them, they've clearly changed their experience for the worse- we'll never sail on Princess ever again-

Emerald Princess Cruises to the Eastern Caribbean
Overall Ratings
  • Cabin
  • Dining
  • Embarkation
  • Enrichment Activities
  • Entertainment
  • Family & Children
  • Fitness & Recreation
  • Onboard Experience
  • Public Rooms
  • Rates
  • Service
  • Shore Excursions
  • Value for Money

Cabin review: Balcony

The BB cabins were well appointed by unusually narrow- we aren't large & could barely maneuver in the shower. This was one of the higher categories yet one of the smallest cabins we've ever had. Clearly, when they designed this ship, they shaved an extra foot or two off the width of the cabins to squeeze more in. We had a fantail (rear facing) location- they have outside doors between balconies, which is nice- but the balconies were very small. The beds were the hardest & most uncomfortable we've ever tried to sleep on.

Port and Shore Excursions

Old, tired, expensive. Don't take a cab- filthy & drivers with bad attitudes. The customs was good- one of the most efficient we've experienced, though they took to screaming at people in line that had inadvertently formed a second line where they didn't want one. Back to reality, I suppose.

Nothing but a cool name & a commercialized port developed by Carnival where they try to contain you in their walled port zone. Everybody goes to margaritaville & sits around getting drunk by a mediocre swimming pool. Stay on the ship.

Read 1,368 Grand Turk Reviews
Beautiful! What a pleasant escape from the dirty, commercialized & dangerous port of St. Thomas. Skip the dubious & repetitive watch/perfume/jewelery/liquor shopping, get on the ferry asap & enjoy the day on St. John, one of the gems of the caribbean.

Nothing much to write home about, have visited here 3 or 4 times. Don't bother with the island tour or Orient Beach- nothing special at all, be it French or Dutch. More shopping with deals little better, if at all, than one can find at home on the internet or at a good retailer. Suspect health standards in their food prep, avoid eating on this island.

Read 3,326 St. Maarten Reviews
Published 04/29/10
Thank Vrob99
No Helpful Votes
Read Cruise Critic’s Emerald Princess Review
Emerald Princess Cruises to the Eastern Caribbean
Share feedback
Thank you!  Cruise Critic values your feedback.
How can we improve this page?