I must admit the Atlantica is a beautiful ship. The atrium was spectacular!
But the dining room service was quite poor. It was noisy and exceptionally warm. Getting refills on water or ice tea took several attempts. The food was mediocre at best.
We tried one morning to have breakfast in the main dining room and left after not being served for over a half and hour. Complaints were made to several of the staff to include the head person and nothing happened!
Noisy room seemed to be above where a lot of work was going on. Was awakened several days with pounding below us.