Subscribe today
Get Cruise Critic in your inbox
Your Ultimate Cruise Guide

Jewel of the Seas Cruise Review by russg140: The Good, The Bad and The Ugly


russg140
12 Reviews
Member Since 2005
185 Posts

Member Rating

Cabin 5.0
Dining 5.0
Embarkation 4.0
Enrichment Activities 1.0
Entertainment 2.0
Family & Children Not Rated
Fitness & Recreation 4.0
Public Rooms 4.0
Rates 4.0
Service 5.0
Shore Excursions 3.0
Value for Money 4.0

Compare Prices on Jewel of the Seas Western Caribbean Cruises

The Good, The Bad and The Ugly

Sail Date: March 2010
Destination: Western Caribbean
Embarkation: Miami

This is not going to be your typical day by day detailed recounting of our 11 Night "Ultimate Caribbean and Panama" cruise (there are enough of those already posted). Instead this review will talk about what RCCL has done or undone to push their loyal to other cruise lines.

To start: We have cruised with RCCL 6 times always in a Junior Suite or better and for a minimum of 10 nights on each cruise. We are in our mid-40's and chose RCCL for the "Get Out There" approach to active cruising.

The Good: Food, staff, ship - all very good to excellent.

The Bad: In an age of discounting where every nickel is important to a company's bottom line it is understandable that some things will need to be reduced or eliminated all together. However, it should not be as noticeable as it was on this cruise. Gone are: mints on the pillows at night, the daily newspaper (not the Compass, but the excerpts from the Times, etc.), salad included with dinner, and variety of choices More for room service breakfast. If RCCL wants to save money, eliminate the Head Waiters. Ours was completely worthless and on "tip night" didn't even bother coming over to our table.

The entertainment and activities were just the same old tired bingo, art auctions, belly flop, line dancing, Battle of the Sexes, comedian, ventriloquist, etc. In the casino you might as well have just handed them your money and walked out. $50 was gone in 5 minutes - never saw anyone win.

In addition to charging for internet use, RCCL now charges a $3 "convenience fee' to buy chips using your room card in the casino and $2.50 for fresh orange juice (8oz.).

On previous cruises we had "smuggled" liquor on board in our suitcases without any problem (yes, it is stated that this is prohibited). This time our liquor was confiscated (1/2 gallon each of scotch and vodka) with a note letting us know that it would not be returned. About a dozen passengers had to go to security to pick up the bags for the same reason. Even a pint of brandy was confiscated. Enforcing this policy is (regrettably) understandable, but other policies were not enforced (jeans, shorts and tees in the Dining Room during dinner, for example). The lack of consistency was frustrating.

The Ugly: RCCL needs to completely overhaul the Crown and Anchor program. This is a huge beast that is only going to get worse. With Oasis OTS (and soon Allure) RCCL is adding thousands of new members each week. What happens to the Concierge Club when they all reach Diamond Plus level? Here's their current solution: Only Diamond Plus members or Suite guests (Junior Suites do not qualify) can use the concierge club, which was overflowing into the Library just adjacent. Diamond members were offered a secondary lounge in Hollywood Odyssey on Deck 13 (staffed by a lovely young woman from Argentina, Virginia). From 5:00-8:00 you were offered complimentary wine and a 25% discount on cocktails. No hors d'oeuvres at all. They also held two receptions for C&A members, but we didn't bother attending based on previous reviewers' lackluster feedback. We did get a small plate of chocolates one day in our room with the "Loyalty Ambassador"'s business card placed on the lid. A very impersonal touch for "our best guests".

RCCL has now adopted a new ad slogan "The Nation of Why Not" to appeal to a much broader mass audience in order to fill the new mega-mega ships. After our experience on this cruise we left feeling "Why Bother?"

We're now looking into other cruise lines where we feel we will be truly treated as valued. As far as cruising with RCCL again? That ship has sailed. Less


Read more Jewel of the Seas cruise reviews >>
Read Cruise Critic's Jewel of the Seas Review >>

Cabin review: Jewel of the Seas Junior Suite Deck 10 1092

We were in a Junior Suite, deck 10 in the rear port side. The cabin is spacious with a walk in closet. The bathroom is standard. The balcony is larger than standard. Our location put us directly below one of the dining areas of the Windjammer and you could hear people dragging the furniture around from time to time.

Port and Shore Excursions


Aruba is a great destination. However, on the day we were in port EVERYTHING WAS CLOSED due to a national holiday. Our plans took us to Eagle Beach and, once the light rain passed, we had a lovely day. Normally there is decent shopping in town, but for those looking to buy they were out of luck. RCCL should have informed everyone of the holiday prior to arrival.

Read 682 Aruba Reviews

We took a cab to old town and walked around a bit. Our cab driver wanted to give us a walking tour (at $40/hour) and we had to firmly tell him that we wanted to be on our own. There are beggars everywhere outside the old town and aggressive crafts people selling their wares. They had a hard time taking "No" for an answer. We had lunch in old town (expensive and nothing special). Others who took tours found the history to be very interesting. In 10 years with a lot of work this could be a much better destination.


We didn't have anything planned and none of the ship's tours interested us. We got off the ship and had 50 cab drivers offer us tours, but we decided to just walk around the port shops and within 15 minutes were back on the ship.


We had planned a Stingray City and snorkel tour with a private company. Since we were tendered we didn't get off the ship until well after 9:30 (we were supposed to meet the tour at 8:15). We walked around Georgetown, but there were no great deals to be had and it didn't seem like a lot of people were buying. We had lunch at Fidel O'Reilly's (a 15 minute walk from port) a great Irish pub. Overall a nice port.


We took a private tour with Oscar Brown - white water rafting and ziplining - which was excellent. The tour included a terrific lunch at the ziplining venue and Oscar gave us a lot of information about Costa Rica and the town. Right at the end of the pier there is a nice craft market where we bought some gifts to bring home. Everyone was very friendly and welcoming.

Thank You For Signing Up!

Please Note: To ensure delivery of your free e-letters, please add news@cruisecritic.com to your address book.
We're committed to protecting your privacy and will not rent or sell your e-mail address. By proceeding, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.