Subscribe today
Get Cruise Critic in your inbox
Your Ultimate Cruise Guide

Carnival Victory Cruise Review by Gillian Anderson: Not so much of a Victory


Gillian Anderson
1 Review
0 Post

Member Rating

Cabin 4.0
Dining 2.0
Embarkation 4.0
Enrichment Activities Not Rated
Entertainment 4.0
Family & Children Not Rated
Fitness & Recreation Not Rated
Public Rooms 4.0
Rates Not Rated
Service 3.0
Shore Excursions 3.0
Value for Money 3.0

Compare Prices on Carnival Victory Southern Caribbean Cruises

Not so much of a Victory

Sail Date: February 2010
Destination: Southern Caribbean
Embarkation: Barbados

We have just returned from the 7 night cruise with Carnival Victory sailing from Barbados booked with Virgin Holidays. We stayed a week in Barbados at the Sea Breeze (fantastic) and then joined the cruise.

For us this was a very expensive holiday that I don't think lived up to expectation - at least the cruise part.

We transferred from our hotel to join the cruise which was very easy, we were on board the ship checked in and dropped our bags off in the cabin by 11.30 am which I thought was great - no fuss or timewasting. The only thing I would say is that the gentleman from Carnival checking us in wasn't very good and it was only because I was listening to the lady next to us checking in that we actually found most of the information!

Our cabin was smaller than I thought it would be, but the balcony was nice, especially being able to get outside when we wanted and watching the ship coming and going from the ports. We were on the 'odd' numbered side and I More suppose that wasn't the best side but we did get the sunrise and sunset most days from this side so that was really nice. The cabin steward was great, always pleasant when we saw him and always left the cabin tidy and well stocked with towels and ice in the bucket.

The food on the ship was the biggest let down for us, we have previously sailed on the Oriana and this was no comparison. The waiter in the Pacific dining room was terrible, he walked away half way through a sentence when asking for drinks - which took forever to arrive. Our daughter had to wait around 20 minutes just to get a soft drink. We were on the late sitting at 8.15 pm which was just far too late for us, the first night it was gone 10.00 pm before we even left the dining room. We tried this twice but gave up then and ate in the buffet restaurant for 3 nights, when we got a bit fed up of this we tried to change to the anytime dining, but after visiting the dining room 3 times to see the Maitre d' we just gave it up as a bad job. The food that we did have in the Pacific was lukewarm at best - we did tell the lady that came around checking on everyone but it seemed to fall on deaf ears - not exactly good customer relations!

The breakfast was just ok, towards the end of the week when the cruisers changed in Puerto Rico was much busier, the first half there were no queues and the lunchtime buffet was the best with great desserts.

The ship itself was quite nice, even though it was 10 years old it didn't look dated or scruffy in any areas. The lido deck was nice with plenty of chairs around the pool area, which was open every day except for Puerto Rico but the jacuzzis were just far too hot, only managed to get a toe in before it was burning!

The worst thing for us around the Lido deck was when the live music was on, the steel drum guy was great, this was quite relaxing and the duo (man and woman) were fantastic but they moved around the ship. The worst was the Latin band who played on the sail away from PR, they were abysmal, far to loud and we ended up going to our balcony cabin for a bit of peace and to save our eardrums. Also, Jim the guitar man - where did they find him? He couldn't sing or play the guitar - Carnival - listen to him and find someone decent.

I agree with the earlier review about the times of the films on the ship, we never managed to see any because you were either eating, getting ready to eat or in bed!

The entertainment we found was quite good for a ship, the singers and dancers were entertaining and the comedian was very funny. The magician was ok when he was interacting with the audience, but wouldn't really call him a magician?? Karl (with a K) was pretty good at his job, a bit cheesy for my liking but that seems to be the theme of the whole ship so I guess he's in the right place. Having said that I thought his impressions of singers was very funny and his commentary was always precise and accurate.

All in all, for us this just wasn't what we quite expected. The food and the service in general wasn't the standard of cruising, unless this is what is normal for Carnival? I don't know, but I do know that we won't cruise with Carnival again as for us it was a little bit like 'Hi de Hi' campers!!!!

Some of the ports were good - but far too many jewellery shops - what is that all about?? We did like begin able to get off the ship every day - see seperate port review. Less


Read more Carnival Victory cruise reviews >>
Read Cruise Critic's Carnival Victory Review >>

Cabin review: Carnival Victory Balcony Upper 6255

Smaller than we anticipated. Clean and plenty of storage. nice balcony quiet

Port and Shore Excursions


We boarded here so didn't actually do an excursion on the cruise day. However, we did do Silver Moon Catermeran whilst we were staying here. It's quite expensive ($110 each) but there are only 12 on the catermeran and it was fantastic. They would not stop to swim with the turtles if it was too busy but would return on the way back if necessary.

The price included lunch and all drinks all day and collection from the port.

If you wanted to walk into Bridgetown from here it would take about 15 minutes along the sea front, or there are loads of taxis waiting just outside the terminal.

Read 701 Barbados Reviews

This is a really pretty island, but looks quite poor and there is virtually nothing in the Port except a few stalls all selling the same thing.

We took the Wacky Rollers tour through Carnival, quite expensive but really enjoyed it including the visit to the emerald pool where they filmed part of Pirates of the Caribbean 2 which really pleased our daughter! We managed to swim through the crevice in the rock to the waterfall - exhilarating.

Read 491 Dominica Reviews

This was a day excursion for us because we boarded at Barbados. We walked along the Pier to the tourist information and picked up a map. Walked along the harbour and through the town exploring old San Juan, which was really nice with lots of buildings to look at.

We grabbed a taxi to Plaza las Americas shopping centre here as the weather wasn't too good and our daughter was desperate to do some 'girly' shopping. Cost $15 each way but was worth it as it was a long day here and it passed the time.

Read 1353 San Juan Reviews

Took lots of other advice here and was so glad we did and opted for Cosol Tours. If you are thinking about booking this tour then just do it, don't listen to the reviews that say it's just too long on the van, I almost did and cancelled it because of what they were saying. I am so glad I didn't - it was a great day out.

We were met at 8.30 on the dock and transferred to minivans with at most 10 people in each. For $65 each it was fantastic value, we saw so much of the island and lots of drinks and food. The breakfast was super, with fresh fruit and local produce to try washed down with whatever you wanted!

We also got the water taxi to Jalouise beach, saw a flying fish and stingray on the way over! Stopped for hot fresh bread and cheese on the way home before arriving back at the port in plenty of time.


Nice town here, get the water taxi when you get off - $6.00 each for the full day, you can come and go as many times as you want for that price.

If you are looking for any bargains or deals I think here is better than St Thomas, there are a few other shops besides jewellery here!

Beach is really nice as well here with sunbeds and umbrellas to hire if you want.


The terminal shopping here is probably the biggest of all the ports. You can get a taxi into town - $4 each, but you can walk it in about 10 minutes if you want to. Just keep to the port side and walk through the Yacht Club.

When you get off the taxi's there are lot's of guys wanting to do island tours. Most charge $25 each for a few hours with the option of going to the beach or returning straight back to the ship.

Read 2318 St. Thomas Reviews

Thank You For Signing Up!

Please Note: To ensure delivery of your free e-letters, please add news@cruisecritic.com to your address book.
We're committed to protecting your privacy and will not rent or sell your e-mail address. By proceeding, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.