Subscribe today
Get Cruise Critic in your inbox
Your Ultimate Cruise Guide

Brilliance of the Seas Cruise Review by aberfeldy1986: The Good and the Bad - Barcelona to Dubai - January 2010


aberfeldy1986
1 Review
Member Since 2010
0 Posts

Member Rating

Cabin 1.0
Dining 3.0
Embarkation 5.0
Enrichment Activities 2.0
Entertainment 3.0
Family & Children Not Rated
Fitness & Recreation 3.0
Public Rooms 5.0
Rates 1.0
Service 2.0
Shore Excursions 3.0
Value for Money 2.0

Compare Prices on Brilliance of the Seas Middle East Cruises

The Good and the Bad - Barcelona to Dubai - January 2010

Sail Date: January 2010
Destination: Middle East
Embarkation: Barcelona

My wife and I were excited about our Royal Caribbean International repositioning cruise to Dubai in early January of this year but the excitment soon passed to a feeling of, "I'll think twice about cruising with this line again."

The good stuff. * This is our sixth cruise on six differnt cruise lines and we found the decor and furnishing of the ship, " Brilliance of the Seas," the most elegant of all the ships we had cruised on. * The captain of the ship was very good in communicating with the passengers. He kept us up to date on travel distances, points of interest to port and starboard and what to do in case of a pirate attack off the coast of Yemen. * We weren't too concerned about a pirate attack in the International Transit Corridor in the Gulf Of Aden. The ship and its crew seemed well prepared should it happen and we had received written instructions of the military protection the ship had and procedures to follow in the event of an incident. We also had a practice More drill on what to do should there be an attack. Fortunately there was no pirate attack. * The ports of call were great and added immensely to the enjoyment of our trip. * While I didn't attend any of the nightly entertainment in the theatres, the people I talked to about the shows enjoyed them. * The Indian food, when available at the Windjammer buffet, was very good. * Our cabin attendant was excellent.

The bad stuff. * The bathroom in our cabin stunk! After a call to housekeeping and the cabin attendent doing a second cleaning and the officer in charge doing an inspection, we were told it was the toilet trap that didn't completely clear itself from the last people using the cabin and the smell would 'go away' after a few uses. It didn't! We were also told to leave the bathroom door open all the time so the stink wouldn't build up in the bathroom! Unfortunately we believed him. A mistake. * With the ongoing bad bathroom smell we didn't want to drink the ship's water, so ordered a case of bottled water at a cost of $50.13 U.S.for 16 bottles. To our dismay there was a $8.00 gratuity charge, which we were never told about, added to the fifty plus dollar cost of the water. What a rip off! * Of the twelve times I ate at the first seating in the dinning room, my waitress got my entree order wrong three times...that's 25% of the time she screwed up my dinner order. Not very professional. * The ship used bar room lounge chairs for the poker table players to sit on. While all the players complained about the wrong type of chairs being used, our request for a different chair was ignored and we all ended up using two seat cushions from other lounge chairs to give us the support we needed for our backs. * After attending three destination lectures on tours availble in our ports of call, we felt that the lecturer was trying to be more of a stand up comedian, than giving good information about what we could expect to see on the tours. Maybe he didn't really know his stuff and was trying to cover up. * It seemed that the so-called library was an after thought and was crammed into a wall side pocket just so they could say they had a library on board. * The food in the dining room and the Windjammer buffet was OK. When talking to a guest who was a frequent cruiser on RC, she said the quality of the food had gone down since her last cruise. Also, a staffer who my wife talked to said the food on the ship was not as good this year as it was last year. * On the afternoon of the last day when inquiring about a charge on our bill (two items from our in-room fridge were added together and charged as one) my wife was told by a rude man on the phone to "just pay it!" What happened to courteous and friendly service that RC is supposted to be famous for? * While waiting to take the Dubai city tour and exit the ship on the morning of our last day, the young lady staffer in the auditorium kept referring to the people waiting in the auditorium as "you guys." Where in the world did she ever learn to use this slang language when refering to mostly senior citizens. After she called us "you guys" for the umpteenth time, there were a few rumbling of discontent in the crowd. * The Dubai city tour was 1-1/2 hours late getting away! Wow, so much for ship board punctuallity. * It seemed like the left hand didn't know what the right hand was doing when it came to getting our passports to exit the ship. During the morning in the auditorium, specific number and colour sticker holders were told to go to the dining room to get their passports, upon arriving at the pick up station we were told to go back to the auditorium because they weren' t ready for us yet. What a frustrating experience it was with what seemed like a bunch of incompetents. Where was management through all of this mess? * The last and most annoying part of the whole cruise was the CONSTANT hustle to buy, buy, buy...sales pitches in the information section of the daily newsletter, two and three advertising inserts in the daily newsletter itself, continuous TV infomercials to buy framed pictures, daily PA announcements reminding you of the so called sales in the shops, camera and gold/silver chain tables set up outside the Windjammer buffet blocking the aisle and a young man at the inside front entrance during the breakfast buffet trying to sell us fresh squeezed orange juice at $3.00 and $4.00 a glass. Next year they"ll probably try selling us toast at breakfast for $2.00 a slice.

Would my wife and I cruise Royal Caribbean again...probably not! Bob Sagness Thorold, Ontario Less


Read more Brilliance of the Seas cruise reviews >>
Read Cruise Critic's Brilliance of the Seas Review >>

Cabin review: Brilliance of the Seas 3540

See review above concerning bathroom odour.

Port and Shore Excursions


For our first visit to an Egyptian city, we found it both disgusting and fascinating. The palace of King Farouk was fascinating to see, as was the Citadel. The city itself was dirty with garbage littering the streets. Pollution hung over the city like a blanket. The traffic was chaotic and you took your life into your hands when trying to cross a street.


A clean, neatly laid out city compared to Alexandria. Traffic was not that bad and the houses were clean and tidy. As we drove through the city on our way to the Dead Sea we marvelled at the difference of Alexandra and Aqaba. My wife and I both had the feeling that we would probably enjoy an extended stay in this city.

Read 27 Aqaba Reviews

A fascinating, modern city. The architecture was spectacular. There seemed to be order and organization to the layout of the city and the roads and traffic. We found the souks delightful and enjoyed bargaining with the merchants and making a number of purchases. We stayed at a 4-star hotel, close to the souks and across from the Creek, that was comparable in cleanliness, food and service to the best that North America has to offer. Unfortunately, because our stay was not long enough we could not visit the world's tallest building because the tours were full for 3 days in advance. We definitely will revisit Dubai some time in the future to enjoy the modernism of the city and the many points of interest we still want to visit.

Read 50 Dubai Reviews

We have no experience to share regarding this port as all we did was get off the ship and onto a bus for the tour to Luxor and the Valley of the Kings.

Read 40 Safaga Reviews

Thank You For Signing Up!

Please Note: To ensure delivery of your free e-letters, please add news@cruisecritic.com to your address book.
We're committed to protecting your privacy and will not rent or sell your e-mail address. By proceeding, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.