“NEVER AGAIN on MSC”
Cruise review of MSC Poesia

Brit's Grandpa MSC Poesia 2 NEVER AGAIN on MSC
Brit's Grandpa
Member Since 2009
No Forum Posts
No Helpful Votes
Overall Member Rating
My wife and I booked on a Christmas Cruise on MSC Poesia and were anticipating a wonderful time. We should have known something was up when our cabin was changed at the embarkation desk, with no reason being given. The embarkation process went relatively smoothly, and we were escorted to our cabin. We had asked for second seating on the meals and were assigned to the first seating. We joined a long line of disgruntled passengers on the first night who shared the same problem we did. We were successful at getting the change in meal times and ended up at a table for four with a wonderful couple from Miami. Our meal service was severely lacking, to say the least, and we attributed the poor service to a lack of training. It may seem like trivial issues, but when you add them together, it mounts up and ends up with a poor experience. Things like, not taking meal requests from the women first, no water at the table, forget about ice or a second glass, no introductions by the waiter or his part-time assistant, wine service arriving at the completion of the meal, reaching in front of guests to remove plates and utensils. We had purchased the wine package for our meals and the waiter could make no recommendations to us, primarily due to communication issues, but he made no attempt to seek assistance to answer our questions. The menu choices and presentation were also lacking, one entree, called a Bolognese Delight consisted of three meatballs and a quarter of a potato!!!! When we ordered fish, it was overcooked and very dry, and forget about ordering a cut of steak, it appeared to have been boiled. Coffee was served cold and when brought to the attention of the ass't waiter, he laughed it off, but he did bring another pot. Mid-week, my wife and I were offered an evaluation form about the service in the dining room, our table mates were not offered this survey, but after requesting one, they got one. We were honest in our evaluation, and the next night, some of the points we brought up had been addressed and changes were made. In fairness to the staff, I can't blame them, they did not get enough training to perform their jobs correctly.

The ship was extremely clean, and our cabin attendant was excellent, that offset some of the negativity we encountered in the dining room. The entertainment was lackluster by the dance team, the singers were adequate, and the contortionist and gymnasts, etc were above average. We have to consider that the make-up of the guests was primarily European, and most of the entertainment was in a language other than English. We were disappointed in the types of excursions that were available, and as a result we negotiated on our own with local vendors. We were able to receive tours and excursions at about half the price quoted by the ships personnel. Overall, it appeared as though the crew was uninterested in customer service, they seemed to be more interested in walking around looking bored. We had conversations with others on the cruise who shared our views and we will certainly make other choices for our next cruise. Hopefully, MSC will read these reviews and take what is being said here as constructive criticism, and they will learn from it.

MSC Poesia Cruises to the Eastern Mediterranean
Overall Ratings
  • Cabin
  • Dining
  • Embarkation
  • Enrichment Activities
  • Entertainment
  • Family & Children
  • Fitness & Recreation
  • Onboard Experience
  • Public Rooms
  • Rates
  • Service
  • Shore Excursions
  • Value for Money

Cabin review:

bal
We were on the ninth deck in a balcony cabin, which was adequate, suitcases went under the bed, clothes in the closet and drawers, shower was very small and could have used a different type of curtain. Cabin attendant was exceptional, he was always working in his area of responsibility, and our cabin was always spotless and well stocked. Balcony got a work out on the sea days..

Port and Shore Excursions

Port
Again, negotiate your own deal and customize your tour. Beautiful country with charming people. We got a cab driver to drive us around half the island for two hours, we saw things that were not on the "official"tour. The area closest to the dock has a great little wine bar that serves only South African wines, and an ice cream shop that had some of the best ice cream to be had.

Read 1,035 Antigua Reviews
Port
We got there on Boxing Day and were treated to the end of a very colorful and loud parade. When the stores opened after the parade, most people were in a festive mood. Still has the British influence and the people seemed very glad to see us, no pressure to buy things, but there were some deals to be had. Local beer Kalik, is very good.

Read 4,130 Nassau Reviews
Port
Forget the tours, walk to the end of the pier and negotiate your own deal. Ask to be left off at the shopping area, get a local meal and walk back to the ship. Beautiful city and great food. Could have spent more time here.

Read 2,280 San Juan Reviews
Beautiful country and scenery, horrible traffic jams everywhere. Took us over three hours to encircle the island. Dutch side of the island has casinos, hotels and resorts, French side has stately homes and estates and some very beautiful resorts.

Read 3,331 St. Maarten Reviews
Published 12/31/09
Helpful?
Thank Brit's Grandpa
No Helpful Votes
Read Cruise Critic’s MSC Poesia Review
MSC Poesia Cruises to the Eastern Mediterranean
Share feedback
Thank you!  Cruise Critic values your feedback.
How can we improve this page?